Shooting holes in theory that a Secret Service agent killed President Kennedy
A Secret Service agent accidentally shot President Kennedy in the head?
This seemingly incredible theory was revived last week by JFK: The Smoking Gun, a two-hour Reelz special that’s scheduled to run again Friday at 5 and 8 p.m. Among many programs remembering Kennedy around the 50th anniversary of his Nov. 22, 1963, assassination, it stands out for focusing on a suspect besides Lee Harvey Oswald.
Despite some cheesy reenactments – that actor’s supposed to look like Arlen Specter? – JFK: The Smoking Gun builds a seemingly plausible case based on ballistics and suspicious behavior by government officials.
“I believe,” Americans have overwhelmingly voted, according to a poll at the show’s companion website. Critical media reports are tough to find.
Let’s take a closer look.
The main evidence in favor of the theory, proposed in the 1970s by Baltimore gunsmith Howard Donahue and newly resurrected by Australian detective Colin McLaren, focuses on the third shot at President Kennedy, tearing apart the upper right side of his skull.
JFK’s head wounds suggested to Donahue that the third shot was not fired by the Mannlicher-Carcano rifle found on the sixth floor of the Texas School Book Depository. Most investigators, including Donahue, believe that weapon, linked to Lee Harvey Oswald, fired the first two shots, if not all three.
The way the bullet produced as many as 40 tiny fragments inside Kennedy’s brain, and the reported 6mm diameter of the entry wound in the back of the skull, were inconsistent with 6.5 mm Carcano bullets, Donahue contended. His analysis did agree with Specter’s “single bullet theory” that such a full metal jacket projectile was capable of drilling through Kennedy’s upper back and throat, and Texas Gov. John Connelly’s back, rib and wrist before lodging in his thigh. But Donahue couldn’t comprehend such a bullet disintegrating inside a brain.
His calculations put the trajectory over the left side of the trailing car, which was full of Secret Service agents, including one who at some point picked up an AR-15 rifle. Donahue concluded the agent, George Hickey, accidentally shot the president when the car suddenly lurched.
The theory got little notice, despite a 1977 write-up in the Baltimore Sun and a 1992 book, Mortal Error: The Shot That Killed JFK, by Bonar Menninger. Donahue died in 1999.
In the Reelz report , McLaren extends the case to argue that there was a coverup, because the Secret Service was mortified that the president was killed by a man who was assigned to that car only because other agents allegedly had been partying and drinking till early that morning.
It all makes for an intriguing case. But it has some major holes.
Accidents don’t get any freakier. Think about it. A stationary marksman aiming a rifle misses with his first shot, but a federal agent in a lurching car just happens to fire at the perfect up-down, left-right angle to hit Kennedy in the head? Isn’t it much more likely that at least one of Donahue’s estimations was off-target?
No solid witnesses. McLaren makes a big deal of trusting witnesses, but more than 100 people there that day thought shots came from the Book Depository or the infamous grassy knoll. No one claimed to see Hickey discharge his weapon directly at the president.
Yet JFK: The Smoking Gun discredits the grassy knoll idea (as does Cold Case JFK, Nova’s reexamination of the scientific evidence that debuts at 9 tonight on PBS), while giving credibility to those who smelled gun smoke at street level, who thought the third shot was louder or came from near the presidential limousine, or who thought Hickey may have picked up his rifle after the first shot (Hickey testified it was after the third shot).
Hickey’s car had two administration officials inside, and seven other Secret Service agents aboard, counting four on the running boards, while at least two Dallas motorcycle cops rode alongside. Behind them were more cars full of agents and officials. Yet no one was sure that Hickey's AR-15 was fired in Dealey Plaza? Kennedy aide Dave Powers said, “Someone a foot away from me or two feet away from me couldn’t fire a gun without me hearing it,” according to Mortal Error. A coverup might produce such post-event denials, but what explains a lack of immediate reaction in the followup car? Wouldn’t a trained agent have snatched the gun, or knocked Hickey down, in case he was a real assassin? Or to prevent this klutz from killing someone else?
One photograph (above) is said to show Hickey without the rifle at the time of first shot, and the only photograph of him with it shows it pointing skyward well beyond the assassination scene. Hickey’s lawsuit over Menninger’s book resulted in a settlement.
It’s dubious to use a gaping hole to calculate a trajectory. If Donahue’s trajectory is wrong, his whole theory falls apart.
Did the bullet enter near the base of Kennedy's skull (as the autopsy report suggested) or four inches higher (as the House Selection Committee on Assassinations concluded)? Then, did it travel toward the middle of the area with missing skull, or travel more toward the top, bottom, front or rear?
Even Donahue, according to Mortal Error, believed the bullet curved to the right and upward, disagreeing with the House Select Assassination Committee’s contention it curled to the right and downward. The science is revisited in Nova’s Cold Case JFK. During experiments firing Carcano bullets at skulls filled with ballistics gel, the bullets “did not follow a straight path inside the skull, because they were deformed on impact,” the narrator explains.
Scientist Larry Sturdivan said the bullets would yaw, or wobble, and develop lift. If the bullet rose, it could have been fired from an angle over Hickey’s head. Add in disagreements about how much JFK’s head was leaning forward or turned toward the left, as seen below in a frame from the Zapruder film, and the trajectory further resembles guesswork.
A “completely disintegrated” bullet also confuses the trajectory. A big part of Donahue’s theory was that the third bullet “explosively disintegrated into dozens of tiny fragments.” That would fit the kind of bullets used by Hickey’s AR-15. Mortal Error quotes Russell Fisher, a Maryland medical examiner, as telling Donahue that “the bullet that hit him [Kennedy] in the head disintegrated completely,” judging from autopsy x-rays.
So which is it? Did the bullet shatter to smithereens, or did it leave enough evidence to pinpoint a path? JFK: The Smoking Gun gives both impressions, poking a dowel through two holes in a model of a skull (above), and blowing up a cantaloupe with an AR-15 bullet. Forget about threading any dowel through that melon. And forget about the Carcano bullet piercing the cantaloupe neatly. Nova’s Cold Case JFK shows footage of skulls fracturing apart when struck by Carcano bullets.
Carcano bullets did break apart in tests on skulls. Kennedy’s brain went missing after the autopsy, so no one knows if bullet fragments seen in x-rays from the autopsy add up to an AR-15 bullet or the lead core and other bits of a Carcano bullet. Two sizeable Carcano bullet fragments (above) were found in the presidential limo, and the Warren Commission concluded they were from the bullet that caused the head wound and that they damaged the windshield and its chrome before dropping to the floor. The missing middle section might account for the dozens of tiny fragments seen on the x-rays. And the aforementioned tests on human skulls did produce deformed pieces resembling those found in the limousine. Donahue’s explanation is that the first shot missed, hit pavement and ricocheted, with three fragments winding up in the limousine, including one that strikes Kennedy’s head, causing him to react before he and Connelly got hit by the second bullet. Donahue examined the two found fragments, and eliminated them as coming from the third shot, because he saw no brain-tissue residue, according to Mortal Error.
The entry wound’s diameter isn’t clear. Again, JFK: The Smoking Gun tries to have it both ways. On the one hand, it plays up how botched the autopsy was, and on the other hand, wants to use an autopsy estimate as hard evidence. Donahue decided the autopsy was four inches too low in locating the entrance wound in the back of the head, and that’s plausible since it was Dr. Fisher’s conclusion after viewing x-rays at the National Archives, according to Mortal Error. (The Nova special leans toward the lower location, based on skull fracture patterns.)
And yet Donahue assumes the autopsy was precise about the entry wound diameter down to one-fiftieth of an inch. Further, it’s unclear if the 6 mm measurement applied to the bone itself, since it was clearly given for a “lacerated wound” “in the posterior scalp.” When the report then notes “a corresponding wound through the skull,” is that a declaration it was exactly the same size, or just in the same location? As Menninger notes, “Certainly, the scalp tissue may have shrunk.” The wound in Kennedy’s back and throat, agreed to have been from a Carcano bullet, was measured as only 4 mm wide in the autopsy report. The Warren Report said “elastic recoil of the skull” could explain the seeming discrepancy.
Cover-ups can have many reasons. The autopsy was dubious and evidence was lost, but that doesn’t make fatal friendly fire the only possible explanation. Losing the president was embarrassing enough to the Secret Service, and it’s widely suspected the FBI and CIA were covering up how much they really knew about Oswald. The way the medical evidence was "rushed and bungled" allowed all sorts of conspiracy theories to arise, said New York Times reporter Philip Shenon, author of A Cruel and Shocking Act: The Secret History of the Kennedy Assassination.
There’s a saying about quantum physics, that if you think you understand it, you probably don’t.
Ditto for the assassination of President John F. Kennedy, in Dallas 50 years ago this month.
Contact staff writer Peter Mucha at 215-854-4342 or firstname.lastname@example.org. Follow @petemucha on Twitter.