Eagles' offense: Evaluating every player
News blogs, sports blogs, entertainment blogs, and more from Philly.com, The Philadelphia Inquirer and the Philadelphia Daily News.
Eagles' offense: Evaluating every player
Sheil Kapadia, Philly.com
I was going to write a notebook-type item on the Eagles' offense after re-watching yesterday's game, but when I was finished taking notes, I realized I had something to say on pretty much every guy. So we'll do it player-by-player:
Donovan McNabb - He played well, completing 10 of 18 passes for 79 yards, two touchdowns and an interception. McNabb also ran four times for 27 yards and a score. On the shovel pass to Brian Westbrook, it looked like McNabb changed the play at the line of scrimmage. The receivers did not help him out early. I counted at least three dropped passes in the first quarter. Now we wait and see when he can get back on the field.
Kevin Kolb - I'm going to write a separate post later this week breaking down Kolb's performance, but to me, it seemed to be more of a timing issue than anything else. He comnpleted 7 of 11 passes for 23 yards, and the offense seemed out of sync when he was in the game. A fumble by DeSean Jackson, a poorly thrown wide receiver screen, miscommunication with Hank Baskett. These seem like things that could be improved with a week of practice with the first team. Kolb made a couple nice throws when he rolled out to his right. His strength is still intermediate passes. The one shot Kolb took deep was ugly as Jackson had to break up an interception.
Leonard Weaver - He actually missed a block on the Eagles' first offensive play of the game, forcing McNabb to scramble. I don't remember seeing that happen once during training camp. Weaver did a good job as a blocker, specifically on Jackson's run out of the Wildcat, and he even had a nifty 11-yard run on his only carry. He's going to prove to be a great addition to this offense.
Brian Westbrook - His performance was one of the most positive things to come out of this game. Forget the job he did running the ball. With 53 seconds left in the first quarter, Westbrook gathered both the offense and the defense on the sideline. The Eagles were off to a sloppy start -- missed tackles, dropped passes, penalties. And from the view on TV, it looked like Westbrook was rallying the troops. The Birds went on to score 28 unanswered points. Look, I'm not saying Westbrook's speech was a direct cause of that, but with Brian Dawkins gone, it was nice to see him assume the role for the entire team. As for his performance on the field, Westbrook carried 13 times for 64 yards. He had a 6-yard run near the Panthers' goal line that showed just how healthy his knee and ankle feel. In fact, if he's ever injured in the future, the coaching staff and trainers should just ask him to replicate that run to see how close to 100 percent he is.
LeSean McCoy - Nine carries for 46 yards. Not a bad debut at all. McCoy also made a great one-handed catch on a pass from Kolb. He only picked up a yard, but it showed a glimpse of what we can expect from him in the future.
Brent Celek - Led the Eagles with six catches for 37 yards and a touchdown. Good toughness on the score to take on two Panthers at the goal line and barrel into the end zone. I know he's been working on it, but Celek has a ways to go as a run blocker.
Alex Smith - Did not make a catch in his debut, but was in the game. He lined up in the slot on one play and was used as a blocker on a wide receiver screen in the first quarter to Jackson, which was incomplete.
Winston Justice - I've been hard on Justice in the preseason, but he played well against the Panthers. Give the coaching staff (Andy Reid, Marty Mornhinweg and Juan Castillo) a ton of credit here for putting him in a position to succeed. I only counted four or five plays where they left Justice completely alone on a pass play. Most often, it was Celek helping Justice out before going out in his route. However, on the occasions where he was left by himself, Justice did a good job. He also made multiple good blocks in the run game. One helped spring Westbrook for an 18-yard gain, and another on a 7-yard run by McCoy. You can't kill Justice for the play where Kolb was sacked and fumbled. He really held on to the ball for a long time there. Definitely a step in the right direction for the big fella.
Stacy Andrews - It looked to me like he probably was the least impressive of the Eagles' offensive linemen, but let's cut him some slack and remember he had offseason knee surgery and is playing on a new team. Andrews got beat a couple times on pass plays, once for a sack in the fourth quarter.
Jamaal Jackson - He really stood out when I re-watched the game this morning. Jackson leveled a defender on the 25-yard end around to D. Jackson and did a nice job throughout.
Nick Cole - He also was very good. Did a nice job when the Eagles ran the Wildcat with Jackson and also opened up a hole for a 17-yard Westbrook run. On Westbrook's TD, Cole got just enough push up the middle to allow No. 36 to get into the end zone. He also created space on Weaver's lone carry.
Jason Peters -- He got off to a rough start with two false start penalties early, but Peters made up for it. He manhandled linebacker Thomas Davis on a 17-yard Westbrook run and displayed the athleticism that had Reid so excited when the Eagles traded for him. One more thing I really liked to see from Peters. When McNabb was intercepted by Jon Beason, Peters was the one hustling to bring down the Panthers linebacker.
DeSean Jackson - His big play came on the 85-yard punt return. Jackson had two catches for 9 yards and a couple carries for 33 yards. He also dropped a ball on the offense's first possession. The Eagles didn't really take shots deep down the field. I'll explain why later.
Jason Avant - Just one catch for 18 yards, but it should come as no surprise that it was an 18-yard pickup on third down.
Kevin Curtis - Two catches for 26 yards. He also dropped a pass from McNabb. Curtis is probably the team's weakest blocking receiver. It seems like any time a cornerback is making a play in the run game downfield, it's Curtis' guy.
Hank Baskett - One catch for 6 yards. But he did make a nice block to give Westbrook room to pick up a first down on a toss in the third quarter. Looked like Baskett and Kolb weren't on the same page on a play in the second half that was incomplete.
And some more notes that I couldn't fit in above:
** Nice design on the play-action pass touchdown to Celek. The Eagles run play-action so much that you wonder how much it really fools defenses. But the entire line, Westbrook, McNabb and even Celek, sold the run.
** There was some confusion in our chat about the celebration penalty after the Celek TD. The Eagles' tight end handed the ball to J. Jackson, who spiked it for him. D. Jackson then fell to the ground, as if it were an explosion. He was whistled for the penalty.
** With 4:48 left in the second quarter, Panthers defensive tackle Damione Lewis brought McNabb down on a pass play to McCoy. As both players got up, Lewis slapped McNabb on the helmet, a gesture of sportsmanship. Why do I bring this up? Lewis is the guy who hit McNabb in the end zone and fractured his rib. I really don't think it was a dirty play. A late hit? Quite possibly. But not a dirty play.
** How did the refs initially call a fumble on McCoy? It didn't really look close. But did you notice Westbrook talking to the rookie after the play? Probably instructing him to hold on to the ball no matter what.
** The Eagles used their timeouts on defense near the end of the first half so that they could get the ball back. So why did they then call a running play to Westbrook from their own 26 with 1:18 left?
** Did McNabb take a shot deep at all while he was in there? Kolb took one. Again, good game-planning by the coaching staff to put their offensive line in a position to succeed.
Comment removed.
Good article, nice breakdown and in depth analysis. Finally, a true reporter.— greekeagle- I don't think the timeouts on Defense at the end of the half had anything to do with stopping the clock. The Panthers were running no huddle at that point and they were taking timeouts to rest the D and make subs. I would like to see this done on Defense more often during long drives.— sla6yer
- Very Nicely done. The review was on point, except I would have expressed more displeasure with the Jackson celebration. It wasn't even his touchdown and he is acting a fool. I ain't mad at him for it' more upset with NFL (No Fun League), it's their rule so don't do it DeSean. Happy Day, Onyx G. (Eagles fan from the time with Carmichael rolling dice after TD) If you don't know, ask Les Bowman, I am sure he remembers.— OnyxG.
- Keep it up. Your hard work shows.— e4stringer
- Yes, McNabb took a shot downfield to Kevin Curtis and he dropped the pass that almost knocked him out. I did not think that I would ever say this, but I would rather see Reggie Brown on the field rather than Kevin Curtis....shaking head....— Bigbadrookie
- The offense played well in this game but the defense won the game. They honestly could have held them to only a field goal if Parker had not put his hand in the facemask of the Panthers player on their failed third down conversion during the initial drive. The offense (under Mcnabb) held its own, but the defense and special teams dominated. We'll need them to step up big versus the Saints next week if McNabb can't play (which is very likely).— kcruel
- i appreciate the insight on the OL. we rarely get that and i hope you can write more about the OL each week after the game. that said, please dont speculate on what 36 told the rookie. you dont know. and we dont know. and that's okay. just stick to what you see.— jb99
- Comment removed.
- Re: "Did McNabb take a shot deep at all while he was in there?" After the Panthers' long opening drive, I can see the Eagles wanting to run a more methodical drive simply to give the D some time to rest and recover. By the time the Eagles got the time-of-possession more balanced out, the game was lopsided enough that there was no need to go to the deep route.— Dirty Davey
- Birds called the TOs near the end of the half in hopes of a good return. Once the ensuing return fell short, the risk-reward to all out pass was too high.— PhillyPhantastico
- Andy often takes time outs when the other team has the ball at the end of the first half. It never works and often backfires. It almost did again yesterday but for some reason the Panthers took a knee with 30 seconds left.— TripleCap
- Kolb looked like a guy who didnt have any reps in practice. He is getting killed in every article and media conversation and it may well be warranted. But what was with the lousy play calling for him. Why do coaches feel the need to throw 7 yd out patterns when the new guy is in. Kevin was terrible on the one deep throw, awful. But the rest of the plays were vanilla at best. I want to see the kid get a chance to throw it down the field on 7 step drops. If he cant play lets really find out why. Not cop out with dink and dunks.— TimeforChange
- excellent article sheil. great to read something about the game and the players in the game instead of one man's injury and mike vick. the big story durning the week was the rookie starting at strong safety. surprised you didn't report on #35. great article otherwise.— JACK V
- Good article. Its good to read about the football game.— Tom98786
- Sheil, let me join many of my fellow posters in congratulating you on an excellent post. It seems as if you have a Jaworski-like ability to break down film after the game, and the Philly fans can always relate. Thanks for putting in the extra time to keep us informed...it's easy to take short cuts on a blog but you didn't and we have taken notice!— bobo_29
- I would rather see Macklin rather than Curtis on the field. Curtis is a poor blocker and drops too many balls. Here's hoping Macklin becomes the starter soon. Kolb looked clueless. He has no pocket presence. He held on to the ball too long several times, was sacked twice, fumbled twice, and should have been picked on the deep pass to Jackson, and the WR screen. I am certain that a week of practice with the ones will not make him a better alternative than Feeley. I hope there is no Kolb show on Sunday, because if it occurs, it will be ugly.— arrowamy
- Comment removed.
- Perfect summary of the game Sheil. Keep up the good work, i see great things in your future. As for the Eagles, I pray McNabb is back ASAP. Hope he doesn't hurt his feelings when Vick becomes a factor. Celek is getting better and better. If our defense and special teams play like that all year, Super Bowl here we come!— TheKeeper
- Jack V - you may want to check out the title to the article. He was only dealing with the offensive players in this post.— catnameddomino
- I agree with those who are wondering what's happening to Kevin Curtis...his performance has really in the tank. Lots of talk about trading Reggie, but here's hoping they unload Curtis instead and start working Maclin or Gibson into the rotation [or give Hank more reps].— jmk1512
- Comment removed.
- Good Article... All you dummy's clamoring for Brown to start over Curtis cuz of dropped passes must have forgotten why Brown doesn't start in the first place.— Philly4Eternity.gov
- they stink and i am saddened that i missed him cryin on the field or was he smilin as always go giants even better would be if they lost the game and shaun andrews offed himself at the fifty— rickrick
- All this journalist does is write great articles...He's quickly becoming my favorite. He's honest and accurate, unlike this Bob Ford debacle.— dsh192
- Good article...and for once good posts in the comments!— jerry42570
** The Eagles used their timeouts on defense near the end of the first half so that they could get the ball back. So why did they then call a running play to Westbrook from their own 26 with 1:18 left? -- That's because Andy knows so much more than us that only a "genius" would understand that play call. For us mere mortal fans who only watch the game it seems like the most idiotic of play calls. Of course he's good for that exact situation 4-5 games a year, so I guess I shouldn't expect anything different. In a big win, no one notices these situations but, for me it's proof positive that Andy is so full of himself he doesn't realize how moronic that play call is. Even if Westbrook gains 9-10 yards it eats up too much clock to be worth it.
Follow
Sheil on Twitter. And become
a fan of Moving the Chains on Facebook.
Download our NEW iPhone/Android app for even more Birds
coverage, including app-exclusive videos and analysis. Download it here.
