Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
share
email
print
font size
options
 
Tuesday, June 17, 2008
Blog Image
Photo by Christina Mazza/Daily News

Now that he's had time to think -- and 10 hours in police detention gives you time for introspection -- Dan Moffat  concedes things might have gone better if he'd cooperated.

When officers came to his door in Francisville Friday morning about 10 a.m. asking to speak to the owner of the property where he and three roommates were living, he said the guy wasn't home.

Even though he's been co-owner of the place since 2004.

And when they said they were going in anyway to investigate a complaint, he says he probably shouldn't have tossed the keys behind a gate where the cops had to fish them out.

He woundup cuffed in the back of a squad car for a couple hot hours then taken to the 9th District where he was held another eight hours as the police sorted out what was happening in his house before freeing everyone without bringing charges.

But not before the police thoroughly searched the place, carting away a computer, and L & I sealed the building, leaving the four roommates homeless. Police told a City Paper reporter on the scene that the roommates were being investigated for belonging to a hate group or terror cell.

The four roommates -- two men and two women in their 20s -- are to appear at a press conference outside City Hall at 1 today to make their case that they were mistreated by police, who they say searched before getting a warrant. Accusations on both sides are prickly.

I talked to Moffat yesterday. He said he's interviewing lawyers. He said he does not know why he was targeted by police, but he had been going around the neighborhood with a petition that questioned why police had installed five security cameras on utility poles without asking for imput of the residents. He also had been getting names on a petition calling for city leaders to address the community about the recent police beating that involved 18 officers.

He says police came to his door investigating whether the group was living legally above the old Gilbert's Shoes store at 1652 Ridge Ave.

That wasn't why they were there, police say. Department  spokesman Lt. Frank Vanore said one of the neighborhood surveillance cameras had been spray painted yellow and was out of commission. Someone living nearby fingered people living in Moffat's house, which is why the police went there, Vanore said.

And when two women inside wouldn't give their names, and Moffat said he didn't know where to find the owner, police assumed the group was trespassing.

Moffat says he messed up. "I just woke up and was making bad decisions," he says. He's not an anarchist. Not even an activist, at 28, unless you consider feeding neighborhood residents on Fridays from their community garden to be activism.

Yet police say they recovered anti-police propaganda in the house, and that someone had written "Kill the Pigs" in yellow spray paint on the walls.

If anyone did that, Moffit  says, it was the police, themselves.

Vanore says the police had every right to be there to investigate vandalism to the camera, especially after finding the writing on the wall and the beginnings of what he called a bunker on the roof.

"We've seen things like this in Philadelphia that lead to bad situations. We're trying to be proactive. The totality of what the officers saw there led to further investigation."

Moffat scoffs at the word bunker, which, of course, was what the MOVE group had atop their home.

"We have a greenhouse on the roof."

So the investigation continues. Moffat and friends hold a press conference, consider lawyers, and someone isn't telling the truth. The Daily News has an account as well.

All I know is that if a bunch of cops came to my door and woke me up -- at 3 a.m. even -- my instinct would be to cooperate to the point of blurting out anything I'd ever done, including not telling on my friend Gary when he stole a comb from Mr. Vincent's barbershop 40 years ago. But that's just conservative old me.

Posted by Daniel Rubin @ 8:52 AM  Permalink | 20 comments
Comments   
Posted 10:16 AM, 06/17/2008
jeffreyg61
(Crickets)
Comment removed.
Posted 12:31 PM, 06/17/2008
Rauol Duke
You are making excuses where these the actions of PPD is again inexcusable. Their primary responsibility is to preserve the peace and protect the public. This is an example of the public sector gone wild. What did they do to deserve this kind of a response? How many people were called in, how much was spent? Mr. Nutter are you for wasting this much money on this nonsense. The Sergeant on this case appears to think he is above the law and has shown no respect for it, it sounds like something from the Shield. Somebody needs to sit this Sergeant down today. This type action can not be tolerated.
Posted 12:43 PM, 06/17/2008
jeffreyg61
I'm surprised people want to move to Philly. I'm also surprised the Philly.com media empire has given Michael Nutter a free pass so far. His commenets blaming the NRA for a cop shooting were very insensitive to the families and inaccurate. He appeared at campaign rally after rally for Hillary Clinton but when John Street wants an iPhone, Street gets the bad pub.
Posted 12:45 PM, 06/17/2008
Leron
HE DID IT!!!
Posted 12:49 PM, 06/17/2008
jeffreyg61
I also love how we are all concerned with white peoples small injustices (alicia lane, "Bonnie and Clyde") yet many black people get killed and not one article is written on them and their injustice of not having a safe neighborhood.
Comment removed.
Posted 01:04 PM, 06/17/2008
SouthPhillyRob
I think the obvious needs to be stated: What the hell are 2 unemployed white boys from California doing in a bombed out house in the North Philly hood? Go back to Berkeley, you losers. Jeffrey - I beg to differ with your comments about the obsession with white peoples small injustices. Alycia Lane and Bonnie and Clyde were not treated unjustly. Lane is public figure who showed the world that she is a homophobe and a bigot. B&C were lowlife thieves. There are lots of stories about black people getting killed every night. It's called Channel 6 news..."and the big story on Action News tonight is another 5 year old was caught in the crossfire at 22nd and Diamond". If you don't like the safety of your neighborhood, then do what all my black friends did. Move to the suburbs.
Comment removed.
Posted 01:10 PM, 06/17/2008
DonQ
A little devil tells me that if the individuals involved in this case had been "of color", the point of view of the news reporting would have been a bit different. Instead of "bohemians" they would have been "suspects", instead of a press conference they would have gotten a court hearing, and instead of a search they would have gotten a beating from the cops with no cameras to film it. Didn't the whole thing start when they got fingered for vandalizing a surveillance camera? This is tarting out as a "long, hot summer". I dread the possibilities.
Comment removed.
Comment removed.
Posted 01:40 PM, 06/17/2008
Leron
[points to the bearded guy in the photograph] IT WAS HIM!!
Posted 02:35 PM, 06/17/2008
msmame
The funny thing is just about EVERYONE who lives in the vicinity could be guilty of vandalizing the camera. I live near by and that part of Ridge is the ghetto...(white & black) poor people, livin' bad and making it worse. I wonder if it was the drunk who lives on the lounge chair in the vacant lot right there who fingered these guys.
Posted 02:43 PM, 06/17/2008
Kevin O.
The police here do not have any respect for the laws they have sworn to protect. The faith I had in Mr. Nutter is vanishing. With all that went on violence wise yesterday in our city, this is where he felt best to spend the time and tax payers money. This wasn't a heat of the moment response from police, it was an organized, detailed and planned action. How many hours were spent planning this event before it occurred, and who raised their hand and said this is the most pressing issue?
About Daniel Rubin
Since joining The Inquirer as a staff writer in 1988, Daniel Rubin has reported from 27 countries, but most of them were small. He's a metro columnist and has been the European Correspondent for Knight Ridder Newspapers. For two years he sat at home and wrote Blinq, the paper's first daily blog. Now we make him come to work. Dan began newspaper work in Norfolk and Louisville, Ky., after getting his undergraduate and graduate degrees from Northwestern University. He has lived in all four commonwealths, most recently in Pennsylvania. He teaches urban journalism at the University of Pennsylvania

Email Blinq here. Visit Blinq 1.0 here. My day job - Inquirer metro columnist - is here.

Blog Roll
Local Interest
 
A List Of Things Thrown Five Minutes Ago
 
A Smoke-Filled Room
 
Afro-Netizen™
 
artblog
 
Attytood
 
Balls, Sticks and Stuff
 
Swing and A Miss
 
Blankbaby
 
blonde sagacity
 
Citizen Mom
 
Daily Sally
 
The BM Rant
 
How Appealing
 
philly
 
Philly Future
 
Tom Gralish's Photo Blog
 
The All Spin Zone
 
The700Level.com
 
slacktivist
 
Suburban Guerrilla
 
The Rittenhouse Review
 
Philebrity
 
Philadelphia Weather
 
Above Average Jane
 
Beerleaguer
 
Phillyist
 
Philadelphia Will Do
 
The Clog
 
This Urban Life
 
Changing Skyline
 
Books, Inq.
 
Philly Skyline
 
The Casual Critic
 
Philadelphia Restaurants
 
Skaroff Blog
 
The Long Cut
 
The Smedley Log
 
Young Philly Politics
 
Politics Philly
 
Philly Burbs Blogs
 
Mental Hopscotch
 
The Daily Jive
 
TheIlladelph
 
The Phanatic
 
Mere Cat
 
Starting A Landslide In My Ego
Poli Sci
 
Booman Tribune
 
My DD
 
538
 
Brad DeLong
 
pandagon
 
Little Green Footballs
 
The Daily Howler
 
War & Piece
 
Digby
 
Instapundit
 
Informed Comment
 
The Huffington Post
 
Pajamas Media
 
Daily Kos
 
Power Line
 
Eschaton
Foreign P.O.V.
 
signandsight
 
Der Spiegel Online
 
Guardian Unlimited Newsblog
 
Global Voices Online
 
Economist.com
Media Mania
 
Daou Report
 
Blogspotting - BusinessWeek Online
 
CJR Daily Home
 
First Draft by Tim Porter
 
Hypergene MediaBlog
 
Online Journalism Review
 
Poynter Online - Romenesko
 
PressThink
 
Reflections of a Newsosaur
 
editorsweblog.org
One-stop
 
BuzzMachine... by Jeff Jarvis
 
DeepBlog
 
Joho the Blog
 
Technorati
 
The Daily Beast
Arts, Culture, Cheap Thrills
 
Some Velvet Blog
 
Stereogum
 
songsillinois
 
Said the Gramophone
 
Music (for robots)
 
Largehearted Boy
 
Wonkette
 
WFMU's Beware of the Blog
 
THE TOFU HUT
 
Spoilt Victorian Child
 
Blackmail Is My Life
 
Gawker
 
Fluxblog
 
Blogcritics.org
 
ArtsJournal Blog Central
 
Arts and Letters Daily
It's Technical
 
Slashdot News for nerds, stuff that matters
 
Gizmodo
 
Dynamist Blog
 
Boing Boing: A Directory of Wonderful Things