share
email
font size
options
 
Monday, August 18, 2008

So, Nastia Liukin missed out on a gold medal Monday. She and her father immediately blamed the low scores of an Australian judge, then blamed Aussie judges in general for other low scores Liukin has received over the past few competitions.

Then they puched a kangaroo, trapped a koala, ripped Paul Hogan's thespian genius and called Elle MacPherson a stretch-marked hussy.

Aussie aside, Liukin lost the gold yesterday due to an oft-used, 9-year-old tiebreaker rule that nobody knew: not her, not her coach, not the reporters who cover the sport.

Imagine a hockey game going into overtime, one team scoring, everybody leaves the ice ... but nobody knows why.

Bizarre.

After Liukin and her dad, Valeri, betrayed their ignorance to a group of likewise ignorant scribes, the scribes stormed through the bowels of the Gymnastics Federation offices, demanding ... what?

 

A better copy of the rules already supplied by the Fed 15 minutes before? Information on a rule change almost a decade old?

A pig-in-a-blanket thing like the one Fed spokesman Philipe Silacci was eating when he was accosted by a frothing, insistent mob?

Ties used to mean mutiple golds or silvers or whatever. That changed after Atlanta in 1996.

Silacci and his boss, FIG pres. Prof. Bruno Grandi , each explained the rules and their history in heavy, wonderful Olympic accents.

What a mess.

She lost.

She still won all-around gold.

She'll still never have to work a day in her life.

And she's still as lovely as a daytime vampire.

 

Posted by Marcus Hayes @ 4:46 PM  Permalink | 21 comments
21
Comments   
Posted 05:51 PM, 08/18/2008
jcpaul
Yea well that is sport! I learned something fro my brother-in -law, a former Olympian, he said "Champions Adjust" He was the Captain of the USA basketball team 1972 Munich games. He knows all about a bad call by a Ref, or 2 or 3; until the other team wins. That Silver Medal was never accepted. That's another story.
Posted 09:28 PM, 08/18/2008
scars73
I can't tell if Marcus is on her side, or ripping her?
Posted 09:38 PM, 08/18/2008
atp2007
That scoring gimmick was probably the only way they could get around the judges' bias for Russian-eastern Eurpoean womens gym style which has won all the Golds since the 1950s except for 2004 (Mary Lou did not beat any Warsaw Pact teams). Whether it was competition from a Romanian or a Russian style trained American, any other style woman gymnast has almost no chance (excpet for 2004), so the only way Shawn or a Chinese gymnast can win Gold head to head with the Slavic style is with help from those above the judges.
Comment removed.
Posted 01:35 AM, 08/19/2008
StefanDio
boo hoo wah wah wah. Man I'm tired of all the whining and crying and sour grapes. The scoring is no gimmick. They get their scores by throwing out the lowest and highest judges scores and comparing the remaining scores, and in this case they tied. The tiebraker rule then looks at the low scores that were thrown out, and that's why Nastia lost (her low score was lower than the other girl she tied with.) And James Blake's whining was ridiculous-he came off as a spoiled brat, an excuse-maker and a sore loser. If Americans can win with class why can't we lose with class? Gimme a freakin break.
Posted 02:51 AM, 08/19/2008
tfarnath
StefanDio.....I take it you didn't watch the event this article is about. I don't care what James Blake did, Nastia got ripped off in this event. Go watch it and tell me different.
Posted 08:32 AM, 08/19/2008
lgeagles
Any sport that has judges is an exhibition and not a competition. Exhibitions should be eliminated from the olympics. Exhibition sports should find a way to obtain an objective winner before they are allowed in the olympics.
Posted 08:35 AM, 08/19/2008
lgeagles
Marcus is on Marcus' side. He wants readers.
Posted 09:06 AM, 08/19/2008
Zues
first, my girl made me watch and it was interesting. all i can say is the judges totally screwed the american girls score. That said,they screwed the chinese girl who got bronze even more. She was by far the best to watch. So in the end Nasty was second best and that is what she ended up going home with. I agree with lgeagles on the whole olympics thing. If you think gymnastics gets it wrong try being a american boxer.
Posted 12:20 PM, 08/19/2008
dutchman
but the big issue is still how old were the little chinese girls? The gymnastics Fed had copies of their old passports that said they were too young. now they can't seem to remember that they keep copies on file. Nastia did get ripped off and the team was scewed by NBC during the team competition. It happens every 4 years to someone. She and the other American girls deserved better, but sometimes you get burned. they can not let it hurt them. they were very good regardless. And this column is a nasty piece. What happened, did she blow you off Marcus?
Posted 01:13 PM, 08/19/2008
sp570
lgeagles, that's ridiculous. referees as just as subjective as judges. so, using your logic, we'll have to eliminate gymnastics, diving, basketball, baseball, fencing, figure skating, some snowboarding and skiing events, hockey - you get my point? also, i agree with zues: the 15 yr old chinese girl who placed third was, in my opinion, better than both nastia and he (the other chinese girl.) she executed her routine more perfectly than the other two, who both had more than one noticeable errors (breaks in form.)
Posted 01:52 PM, 08/19/2008
Nick4102
StefanDio by the way the next last 2 low scores thrown out hers was higher not lower. It was the remaining scores that were higher.
Posted 03:32 PM, 08/19/2008
Scarlet
what a stupid blog, not even funny. Surprised it is online.
Posted 03:57 PM, 08/19/2008
lgeagles
sp570 - gymanastics -gone, figure skating - gone, ski jumping - gone. Boxing should end on a concession. Sports need to come to a meaningful conclusion.
Posted 04:12 PM, 08/19/2008
NickEeee
I'm so proud of her for blaming the Aussie judge! It's hard to know who makes me more proud, the 'competitive' Baseball team, the trash talking pole vaulter, or the gymnast!
About Sam Donnellon and Marcus Hayes

SAM DONNELLON's career began in Biddeford, Me., in 1981, and has included stops in Wilkes-Barre, Norfolk, and New York, where he worked as a national writer for the short-lived but highly acclaimed National Sports Daily. He has received state and national awards at each stop and since joining the Daily News in 1992 has been honored by the Associated Press Sports Editors, the National Sportswriters and Sportscasters Association, the National Association of Black Journalists, the Associated Press Managing Editors of Pennsylvania and the Keystone Awards. He and his wife have raised three fine children, none of whom are even the least bit impressed with the above. Sam is veteran of Olympics coverage for the Daily News, including the Games in Sydney and Turin, among others.

MARCUS HAYES grew up on a small farm outside of Hermon, NY., a small town near the Canadian border about the size of Reading Terminal Market. In high school he played three varsity sports and aspired to be faster, or more skilled, or taller. Having failed in those aspirations and seeking a warmer climate, Marcus attended Syracuse University's S.I. Newhouse School of Public Communications and eventually graduated with a degree in Magazine Writing. He also earned a degree in English from the College of Arts and Sciences. To date he has written for no magazines. His English is spotty at best. Upon graduation in 1990, with Jim Boeheim's talent-leaden SU basketball teams having won no titles, Marcus spent 4½ years working for the now-absorbed Syracuse Herald-Journal covering high school sports, local small college sports and non-revenue sports at SU. Marcus joined the Daily News as a feature story writer in 1995. Among other assignments he has covered the Eagles and Phillies beats for most of his tenure. Still, the paper soldiers on. This will be his first Olympics assignment for the Daily News.

Get it now
Archives
 
August 2008
 
August
Categories
 
Baseball
 
Gymnastics
 
Swimming
 
Track and Field