Friday, November 28, 2014
Inquirer Daily News

How the Philadelphia Union's payroll compares to other local sports teams

ESPN The Magazine put together a really interesting feature this week ranking payrolls for teams across a wide range of American and other sports.

How the Philadelphia Union’s payroll compares to other local sports teams

The Union ranked No. 255 in a report on payrolls across American and other sports. (Laurence Kesterson/Staff Photographer)
The Union ranked No. 255 in a report on payrolls across American and other sports. (Laurence Kesterson/Staff Photographer)

ESPN The Magazine put together a really interesting feature this week ranking payrolls for teams across a wide range of American and other sports.

This allows us to compare how the Union's payroll stacks up against those of the big four professional teams, as well as other MLS and international teams.

Although the article does not directly state the source of its MLS salary data, it does say that the key "average weekly pay" figure is "calcualated from base playeyr salaries from current or most recently completed seasons from each sport."

The MLS Players Union hasn't released this year's salary figures yet. So either ESPN got new numbers on its own, or the figures used to compile MLS payrolls came from the end of last season. Judging from what ESPN used as the Union's total payroll figure, I'm guessing the former.

More coverage
Buy Union tickets
 
Buy U.S. national team gear
 
Latest soccer videos

Last year's numbers can be found here. It would not surprise me if we get new updates for the 2012 season some time soon.

ESPN's rankings are quite diverse. They include teams from:

- American sports leagues: Major League Baseball, the National Basketball Association, the National Football League and National Hockey League

- Soccer leagues: Major League Soccer, Spain's La Liga, England's Premier League, Italy's Serie A, Germany's Bundesliga and Scotland's Premier League

(Among the notable soccer leagues not included are France's Ligue 1, the Netherlands' Eredivisie and Mexico's Primera Liga, all of which have teams with large payrolls)

- Other sports: Indian cricket's Premier League, Japan's Nippon Professional Baseball league, the Australian Football League and the Canadian Football League

Here's how the Union's payroll compares to the big four Philadelphia pro sports teams. The ranking is determined by average annual salary paid out to each player:

Rank Team Avg. annual pay Avg. weekly pay Total payroll Payroll rank
9 Phillies $5,817,965 $111,184 $174,538,938 5
23 76ers $4,801,957 $92,345 $67,227,398 91
100 Flyers $2,524,821 $48,554 $70,695,000 84
128 Eagles $2,233,333 $42,949 $113,900,000 36
255 Union $162,232 $3,120 $4,542,484 253

Here's how the Union's payroll stacks up within Major League Soccer:

Rank Team Avg. annual pay Avg. weekly pay Total payroll Payroll rank
219 Los Angeles Galaxy $555,799 $10,688 $17,229,783 206
222 New York Red Bulls $529,126 $10,176 $13,228,155 211
228 Toronto FC $321,959 $6,192 $8,370,923 223
251 Chivas USA $178,644 $3,435 $4,287,461 260
253 Seattle Sounders $173,024 $3,327 $5,363,729 249
255 Philadelphia Union $162,232 $3,120 $4,542,484 253
256 FC Dallas $157,387 $3,027 $4,406,842 257
257 Vancouver Whitecaps $150,092 $2,886 $4,202,583 262
258 Real Salt Lake $149,296 $2,883 $3,898,065 268
259 Portland Timbers $149,515 $2,875 $4,485,462 254
260 Houston Dynamo $147,882 $2,844 $3,697,038 270
261 Chicago Fire $145,521 $2,798 $3,929,075 267
262 D.C. United $141,307 $2,717 $3,673,994 271
263 Colorado Rapids $127,457 $2,451 $3,823,719 269
264 New England Revolution $125,802 $2,419 $3,522,468 273
265 San Jose Earthquakes $120,802 $2,323 $3,624,062 272
266  Montréal Impact $118,464 $2,278 $3,316,994 274
267  Sporting Kansas City $116,786 $2,246 $3,270,014 275 
268 Columbus Crew $89,369 $1,719 $2,770,428 276

So the Union have the sixth-highest payroll in MLS, according to these figures.

On average, MLS teams are in the neighborhood of a lot of Scottish Premier League and Australian Football League teams, along with some lower-level La Liga and Serie A squads.

It's also worth noting that the Crew are the very last team in ESPN's rankings.

The two teams that most draw my eye, though, are Toronto FC and Sporting Kansas City. Toronto is the worst team in MLS despite its high payroll. Sporting Kansas City is one of the best despite spending less then half as much as the Reds.

That said, no MLS team's spending comes anywhere close to what the world's elite clubs splash out. Here are the top 10 payroll figures for all of the soccer teams included in the survey:

Rank Team Avg. annual pay Avg. weekly pay Total payroll Payroll rank
1 Barcelona $8,680,569 $166,934 $217,024,221 1
2 Real Madrid $7,796,637 $149,935 $194,915,932 3
3 Manchester City $7,403,754 $142,380 $185,093,858 4
4 Chelsea $6,795,899 $130,690 $169,897,463 8
7 AC Milan $6,104,769 $117,399 $152,619,219 10
8 Bayern Munich $5,907,652 $113,609 $170,231,332 7
10 Inter Milan $5,700,915 $109,633 $142,522,871 12
11 Manchester United $5,521,423 $106,181 $138,035,567 14
16 Arsenal $5,280,108 $101,541 $132,002,699 16
18 Liverpool $5,230,525 $100,587 $130,763,119 17

That's two teams from Spain (Barcelona and Real Madrid); five from England (Manchester City, Chelsea, Manchester United, Arsenal and Liverpool); two from Italy (AC Milan and Inter Milan); and one from Germany (Bayern Munich).

It's no surprise that Barça and Real top the table, or that Man City is the highest-spending English team. But I find it quite interesting that Manchester United, long one of the world's truly elite teams, is so far down.

Here's another interesting figure: The third-highest-spending Spanish team, Valencia, is all the way down at No. 71, with yearly per-player spending of $3,065,511 and weekly per-player spending of $58,592. Their overall payroll figure of $76,637,764 is ranked No. 75.

For as much as people around the world enjoy watching Barcelona and Real Madrid, the lack of spending by other teams shows how how unbalanced La Liga has become.

The two teams that the Union will face in their summer friendlies this year, Schalke 04 and Aston Villa, are both ranked fairly high.

Schalke is the second-highest-ranked Bundesliga team at No. 34, with yearly per-player spending of $4,187,722 and weekly per-player spending of $80,533. Their overall payroll of $115,844,040 is ranked No. 24.

Aston Villa is the next-ranked English team after Liverpool at No. 41, with yearly per-playre spending of $4,067,464 and weekly per-player spending of $78,220. Their overall payroll of $101,686,591 is ranked No. 47.

(For this, Villa are in 15th place in the Premier League, three points off the relegation zone.)

Finally, here are the top 10 teams overall in ESPN's ranking. Note the presence of a certain baseball club that has won the last five National League East championships. 

Rank Team Avg. annual pay Avg. weekly pay Total payroll Payroll rank
1 Barcelona $8,680,569 $166,934 $217,024,221 1
2 Real Madrid $7,796,637 $149,935 $194,915,932 3
3 Manchester City $7,403,754 $142,380 $185,093,858 4
4 Chelsea $6,795,899 $130,690 $169,897,463 8
5 Los Angeles Lakers $6,278,088 $120,732 $87,893,233 63
6 New York Yankees $6,186,322 $118,968 $192,962,289 2
7 AC Milan $6,104,769 $117,399 $152,619,219 10
8 Bayern Munich $5,907,652 $113,609 $170,231,332 7
9 Philadelphia Phillies $5,817,965 $111,884 $174,538,938 5
10 Inter Milan $5,700,915 $109,633 $142,522,871 12

You can interpret that chart in a lot of ways. The biggest conclusion I draw from it is this:

The Phillies have a bigger payroll than Manchester United.

Seriously. Think about what that means.

The Phillies have a smaller stadium (by nearly 38,000 seats) and not nearly the same level of global brand recognition (which translates to sponsorship and other forms of revenue). But they have a higher payroll - and a higher annual per-player salary figure - than the Red Devils.

You could walk around any major city in the world wearing something with a United logo and it would get recognized. You can't say the same thing about a Phillies cap.

Next time you're chatting with a United fan, mention those numbers. Not that Philadelphia sports fans ever need an excuse to brag, but I think this is a pretty good one.

Jonathan Tannenwald Philly.com
About this blog
The Goalkeeper is your home for the latest news about the Philadelphia Union, Major League Soccer, U.S. national teams and the rest of the world's most popular sport. It's also a place for fans to gather and celebrate the culture of soccer and its unique place on the sports landscape.

Reach Jonathan at jtannenwald@phillynews.com or 215-854-2330.

Jonathan Tannenwald Philly.com
Latest Videos:
Also on Philly.com:
Stay Connected