Mailbag: Howard, Oswalt, Brown and numerology
The latest Phillies and baseball news from Philly.com.
Mailbag: Howard, Oswalt, Brown and numerology
Matt Gelb
We're dusting off some of the cobwebs in here and opening up the mailbag for your questions. If you want a question asked in a future mailbag (and I promise to make this a semi-regular event in the future), fill out this entry form. Or you can ask me a question on Twitter (@magelb) and I will use it in this space.
To the questions...
Is Ryan Howard really going to play in April?
Adam from Quakertown
All signs point to, "No." And why should he? The Phillies need a healthy and productive Howard in October, not April. This team has shown a willingness to be conservative with injury timetables and Howard's recovery from a ruptured Achilles tendon will be no different.
Yes, there are some within the walls of Citizens Bank Park who will not rule out an April return because that would be a disservice to their Big Piece. But in reality, they will be thrilled if he can return at full strength sometime in May from a difficult rehabilitation process.
The updates on Howard during spring training will come with those caveats. Remember, despite Chase Utley's persistence, the Phillies still had him spend more than two weeks playing minor-league baseball last season. They will take every precaution with Howard, as they owe him an average of $25 million per season for the next five years.
Any idea why the Phils aren't interested in Oswalt at what I assume is a lowered price?
@angryelvis on Twitter
That Roy Oswalt remains unsigned on Jan. 25 qualifies as the least surprising development of the winter for me. His agent was trying to sell people on a three-year deal in November, lied about a proposed meeting with the Yankees in New York, and probably misrepresented Oswalt's desire to play for that long.
Most likely, some teams interested in Oswalt have asked Phillies people for their opinion on the righthander who made $16 million in 2011. The Phillies won't say such a thing publicly, but there are serious concerns about Oswalt's back holding up for an entire season, let alone three more. Now the asking price is reportedly down to one year and there still are no obvious suitors. Plus, Edwin Jackson is still out there and he's six years younger than Oswalt.
The fact is, Oswalt probably only wants to pitch for a select group of teams. (Hint, hint: St. Louis.) People have said there's no such thing as a bad one-year contract. But it would take a lot of faith for a team to invest money in Oswalt, who mentally and physically wasn't always there in 2011.
How is Dom Brown progressing this winter? Does he have a particular training agenda he is following?
Don from Bethlehem
Brown has spent the majority of his winter in Clearwater, Fla., at the Phillies' complex. He's been doing some work with Andy Abad, who is the team's new minor-league outfield/base running coordinator. Most of the focus this winter has been on changing positions, from right to left field.
Privately, some Phillies evaluators wondered about Brown's approach at the plate in 2011, but that was secondary to his defensive issues. And while most people are quick to write off Brown because he hit .245 in 184 at-bats, he walked 25 times against 35 strikeouts and managed 16 extra-base hits (35.6% of his hits) less than six months removed from a fractured hamate bone in his hand.
In other words, it's hard to discount six seasons of a .834 OPS in the minors for a player who just turned 24. The thing to watch in spring training will be how he handles left field.
Did Antonio Bastardo change his number after the Phillies signed Jonathan Papelbon?
Michelle from Ardmore
We're not sure of the financial terms, but here's guessing that Cinco Ocho (Papelbon) compensated Bastardo for his old No. 58 because it means a lot to the new Phillies closer. So Bastardo will wear No. 37 in 2012 (last used briefly by Justin De Fratus in September). Just makes all of those old Bastardo shirseys more hardcore.
Some other numerology developments: Jim Thome, of course, will don his customary No. 25. Ty Wigginton grabbed No. 24. Laynce Nix took No. 7 in a clear homage to Ross Gload. Michael Schwimer changed to No. 44 and how soon we forget about Four Aces. Phillippe Aumont now has No. 43 and J.A. Happ fans everywhere shed a single tear.
Of the non-roster players in spring training, there are quite a few issued low numbers. Pete Orr keeps No. 4. Hector Luna has No. 10, Lou Montanez has No. 16, Scott Podsednik has his No. 22 and Kevin Frandsen has No. 28.
Pitchers David Purcey (39), Brian Sanches (48), Raul Valdes (46) and Dave Bush (47) all have normal numbers. Joel Pineiro is the first to be issued No. 50 since Jamie Moyer wore it for five years.
Have a question? Send it to Matt Gelb's Mailbag.
Roy O is shot both physically and mentally. He can still pitch but def has to rely more on deception rather than pure stuff. Anyone calling Dom Brown a bust at this point, is a very ignorant baseball fan. 2 years ago he was called up out because there werent any other options and last year he was constantly "yo yo'd" up and down by the master strategist, Charlie Manuel. Give him the 1st half in LHV and he could be a great addition come July or August.— FABER- as a fan, I'd feel a lot better when I see that Oswalt and Lidge have signed elsewhere --they're both useless garbage..just the type that clueles rube likes to re-sign— warbiscuit
- Yeah, it's all Charlie's fault. Or maybe Brown just isn't that good. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RsI27HpnIS0
— Jeff Dowder - Charlie is actually too loyal and relies too much on past performance. Rollins is worst lead off hitter in baseball. Utley is good but not what he used to be. Polanco is washed up. Howard is way over paid and over rated. Again, good but not a $25m player! Only cleanup hitter that player in front is intentionally walked to get to him. Embarrassing!!! Move them down in lineup! Needs new offensive blood!! — cu2ny
- Lou Montanez should be given #27 as homage to Willie "the Philly" Montanez, Polanco won't mind.— outta work
- Oswalt was not "into it" last season. His heart/mind was at his father's farm, where he wanted to help after the terrible storm.— drhoffman
- I blame Howie Roseman.— warreninrochester
- I agree, I also think Howie Roseman is to blame....for EVERYTHING — jimbo jones
- drhoffman: I agree although it shouldn't have been an issue. My friends Dad died and he had to be back at work after two days. When someone works only part of the year making big bucks they can't be taking off days. .....Unless of course you are a Bucks County teacher.— KINGOFZED
- @ warbiscuit -- Although I agree that both Oswalt & Lidge are certainly not what they once were, to call them " useless garbage ", is a bit extreme and shows you to have little if any class.— phillyjim7
- Here's one vote for warbiscuit for the biggest dope and piece of useless garbage on philly.com. Now that Conlin's gone, of course.— PhillySubsMac
- Pete Orr wore #5 last season, not #4.— BobbyD
- Ouch! Cheap shot on Bill.— Joe at the shore
- "it's hard to discount six seasons of a .834 OPS in the minors for a player who just turned 24. The thing to watch in spring training will be how he handles left field." BINGO! He has gained some weight this off season and is down in Clearwater working hard. Who knows what he will be like in a few years. Too early to give up on him and too early to trade him for nothing. Let him play in AAA to see how he does and how Jr responds by being an everyday player. Things have a way of working out.
— pattymac3 - @warbiscuit... You're certifiably a friggin dope! Without Lidge in 2008 we don't even make the playoffs. Without trading for Oswalt in 2010 we might night have made it then either. We were 6 games back and that Oswalt trade lit a fire in the team, not to mention he went 7-1 with under a 2.00 ERA. Classless man...— BammBamm
- I agree Brown looks raw at times, but an interesting thing I saw him do on several occasions last season after getting a quick 0-2, or 1-2 count was work the pitcher for several more pitches. I know the pitcher wasn't supposed to give him anything good for the next few, but he showed a good eye for the plate passing up on some and fouling off close pitches before taking a cut at a good one. He showed more discipline and looked better after digging himself into a bad pitch count. Don't know if it's something I'll see again this year, but I know opposing pitchers don't like it.— escapedcamden4monterey
- I had this in another thread, but hitting was not a problem for Brown last year.
At age 23 Brown was already as good as the average major-league Left Fielder:
Avg MLB LF: .256/.320/.409 (.729 OPS, overall hitting stat wOBA at .320)
Dom Brown: .245/.333/.391 (.724 OPS, wOBA at .322)
Not to say by any means that we should be satisfied with his current production, and at only 24, he should get better.
These were the starting left-fielders who were about equal to Brown as hitters in 2011 (by wOBA):
B. Gardner .330
A. Soriano .325
C. Ross .321
David Murphy .319
J. Bay .315
R. Rayburn .314
Below that were M. Brantley, J. Rivera, Ibanez, C.Crawford, Delmon Young, R.Ludwick, M.Prado, J.Pierre, V.Wells
Defensively, he needs work, but he's athletic enough that I don't see a problem with him becoming a passable outfielder, along the lines of a Burrell or Ibanez.— schmenkman - How about packaging Brown w/a couple other guys (Choose from Polanco, Kendrick, maybe Schwimmer or another young reliever, Victorino) in exchange for David Wright?— Ringsider
- Why are people so quick to get rid of Victorino? — BleedPhilly
- Ringsider, that would be an EXTREME overpay by the Phillies. Try out this article:
http://www.thegoodphight.com/2011/12/28/2663618/attention-phillies-fans-david-wright-isnt-especially-valuable-domonic
Consider that:
1) Polanco has been almost as good as Wright in recent years
2) Victorino and Wright were about equal in 2009-10, but Victorino was MUCH better last year
3) Brown is young, cheap for several more years, and already hit as well as the average left fielder in 2011
4) Wright is owed $15M in 2012 and is then a free agent— schmenkman - Never seen a big rush to trade Brown. He's plenty young enough to still develop. I mean, Mayberry's 4 years older and just came up last year. Plus, we have enough pitching prospects to make a midseason deal without trading Brown. He's far from perfect but he remains one of the few true position-playing prospects that we have.— eman
- I thought the Rockies sign Oswalt to a one year deal. No?— BleedPhilly
Comment removed.- Lidge was not a head case. He was an arm case.— schmenkman
- Comment removed.
- Yeah, Lidge was such a head case that he went 44-0 next year and won us a World Series. Dope. — mike l
- Comment removed.
- Comment removed.
- I think Brown's problem is mental. He's supposed to be the top guy and I think he's messing up trying to live up to the hype. He was named one of the top prospects in MLB, not just by the phillies, by all of baseball. They can't all be wrong.— mike l
- Comment removed.
- Hanging on to a 24 yr. old like Brown for at least one more year would be smart in my book. He's young, cheap and, when given enough time, has hit on every level. Fielding-wise, he can be no worse than Ibanez in left and with time can be better.— Dragon13
Has any move been made to fill a most important role, that of a bench coach to do the game time thinking for Cholly?— Phil Lee- Roy did great his first season with the Phils, everything we dreamed of. Second season was poor. He's a small guy who throws everything he's got, which is probably why his back is shot. He talked retirement all last season.— Barneyboy
- Roy did great his first season with the Phils, everything we dreamed of. Second season was poor. He's a small guy who throws everything he's got, which is probably why his back is shot. He talked retirement all last season.— Barneyboy
- I guess this confirms that Gload is gone.— benjyedwards
- Oswalt was better than usual in 2010, and worse than usual in 2011.
Overall with the Phililes, he was 16-11 with a 2.96 ERA.
His career record per 162 games? 16-10 with a 3.21 ERA.
2011 could have gone better, but even so, there aren't many pitchers in baseball who had a better record than Oswalt since the trade.
— schmenkman - mainlinephan, regarding Lidge, this is what I'll remember (tweet from Murphy):
"madson once said what lidge did in '09 was more impressive than '08. because he never snapped. just a pro in every sense of the word."
http://twitter.com/#!/HighCheese/statuses/162631549370642432— schmenkman - Weary of the howard-Fielder et al comparisions - the horse is out of the barn, time to ride him not wish we had another mount...— Ed3
- From the day he was traded here, Oswalt's body language seemed to indicate to me that he didn't want to be here. Seemed to keep to himself, mostly, and rarely even smiled.— RightSaidJeff
- Phillies are focusing on the wrong needs with questionable relief pitching. They need to find some real offense! They are betting the World Series on history with Rollins, Utley, Polanco and Howard ( most over rated and over paid player in sports). He is good not great! Only cleanup hitter and $25M player that teams intentionally walk person in front of him and rather pitch to him. Embarrassing!!! They better find offense or it will be another real disappointment when playoffs come around and they fail to hit premium pitching--again three years in a row!— cu2ny
