Friday, August 1, 2014
Inquirer Daily News

All-Time Phillies Poll

All-Time Phillies Poll

Who are the all-time greatest Phillies?

We want to know who you -- readers and Phillies fans -- think are the best Phillies ever, by position.  

PITCHER
Who is the Phillies' all-time best pitcher?
Grover Cleveland Alexander (HOF, 1911-17, 1930)
Jim Bunning (HOF, 1964-67, 1970-71)
Steve Carlton (HOF, 1972-86)
Robin Roberts (HOF, 1948-61)
Curt Schilling (1992-2000)
SECOND BASE
Who is the Phillies' all-time best second baseman?
Napoleon Lajoie (HOF, 1896-1900)
Juan Samuel (1983-89)
Tony Taylor (1960-71, 1974-76)
Manny Trillo (1979-82)
Chase Utley (2003-present)
LEFT FIELD
Who is the Phillies' all-time best left fielder?
Pat Burrell (2000-present)
Ed Delahanty (HOF, 1888-89, 1891-1901)
Del Ennis (1946-56)
Greg "The Bull" Luzinski (1970-80)
Sherry Magee (1904-14)
CATCHER
Who is the Phillies' all-time best catcher?
Bob Boone (1972-81)
Darren Daulton (1983, 1985-97)
Bo Diaz (1982-85)
Mike Lieberthal (1994-2006)
Andy Seminick (1943-51, 1955-57)
SHORTSTOP

Who is the Phillies' all-time best shortstop?

Davey Bancroft (HOF, 1915-20)
 
  196 (1.5%)
Larry Bowa (1970-81)
 
  4174 (31.0%)
Granny Hamner (1944-59)
 
  333 (2.5%)
Jimmy Rollins (2000-present)
 
  8634 (64.2%)
Bobby Wine (1986-68)
 
  121 (0.9%)
Total votes = 13458

CENTER FIELD
Who is the Phillies' all-time best center fielder?
Richie Ashburn (HOF, 1948-59)
Lenny Dykstra (1989-96)
Billy Hamilton (HOF, 1890-95)
Garry Maddox (1975-86)
Cy Williams (1918-30)
MANAGER
Who is the Phillies' all-time best manager?
Gene Mauch
Dallas Green
Larry Bowa
Danny Ozark
Jim Fregosi
FIRST BASE
Who is the Phillies' all-time best first baseman?
Dolph Camilli (1934-37)
Ryan Howard (2004-present)
John Kruk (1989-94)
Pete Rose (1979-83)
Jim Thome (2003-2005)
THIRD BASE
Who is the Phillies' all-time best third baseman?
Dick Allen (1963-69, 1975-76)
Dave Hollins (1990-95, 2002)
Willie "Puddin' Head" Jones (1947-59)
Scott Rolen (1996-2002)
Mike Schmidt (HOF, 1972-89)
RIGHT FIELD
Who is the Phillies' all-time best right fielder?
Bobby Abreu (1998-2006)
Johnny Callison (1960-69)
Gavvy Cravath (1912-20)
Chuck Klein (HOF, 1928-33, 1936-44)
Sam Thompson (HOF, 1989-98)