share
email
font size
options
 
Monday, April 27, 2009

Sitting over in the NovaCare Complex on Sunday when the Eagles traded two fifth-round picks for Patriots cornerback Ellis Hobbs, two questions immediately hit me:

1) What does this mean for disgruntled corner Sheldon Brown?

2) Why did it only take two fifth-rounders to acquire a starting corner?

We're going to take these in reverse order. Why fifth-rounders for a guy who has started for the better part of four years? You do have to wonder a little bit. You do have to wonder about why the Patriots have spent the off-season acquiring new secondary talent, making Hobbs expendable. The price was pretty reasonable, especially for a player at such an important position. So let's not go too crazy about what they got here. They got a professional player, and a guy who is young enough that he might still be getting better. Don't say much more than that, though, until we see more.

Then there is the Brown question. This isn't about him anymore -- it's about other people. Two of them are Andy Reid and Joe Banner, and they are not likely to acquiesce quickly to Brown's demand for a new contract and/or a trade -- because that's not what they do. Even more important than them, though, is the unspellable Jack Ikegwuonu (and, to a lesser degree, just-drafted Victor Harris).  One of them has to be able to play or the Eagles cannot move Brown.

Remember: Lito Sheppard is gone now, and the Eagles play four cornerbacks a decent percentage of the time. And if the fourth guy can't play, opposing offenses will make the Eagles play four cornerbacks an even higher percentage of the time. And it's not even that: they play three corners a ton of the time, and if somebody sprains an ankle, the fourth has to play in place of one of the first three, and the other teams will find him on the field every damn time if he can't play.

When I listen to Reid talk about this stuff, I try to hear the truth beneath the words. And when Reid talked Sunday about Ikegwuonu, who missed his rookie season injured, he said, “Jack is coming off the major knee [surgery]. He has been doing the offseason program and it looks like he has a chance. He is a little bit rusty right now but he is working his tail off so we will add him into the mix.”

That does not sound like a ringing endorsement. This is going to have to play out. Brown has no chance to be moved until the Eagles are convinced Ikegwuonu or Harris (or somebody) can get on the field.

Posted by Rich Hofmann @ 12:13 PM  Permalink | 51 comments
51
Comments   
Posted 10:25 AM, 04/27/2009
riza1976
ditto
Posted 10:32 AM, 04/27/2009
FlyersFan88
Preach that, Rich! Sheldon Brown's already GOTTEN PAID, with that signing bonus, and has, what, four years left on that deal? Who says the Eagles have to do anything? If Brown cries, so what? If Brown plays poorly, well, OK...how is that any different from when Plaxico Burress would dip him in butter and call him toast everytime the Iggles played the Giants? Bottom line: There are too many years left on Brown's deal for the Eagles to cave. That is the absolute bottom line.
Posted 10:56 AM, 04/27/2009
Ticow021
A crowded secondary is a good problem to have. However, this Brown situation may get ugly. Good point about not moving him until someone can prove they can play. I have a feeling he'll be in Green all year.
Posted 11:00 AM, 04/27/2009
mick314
Maybe he can understudy Butchie who sez he wants to retire.
Posted 11:28 AM, 04/27/2009
Scoop
I do not understand Banner's dogmatism re: not renegotiating contracts (until he initiates the renegotiation, typically with one or two years remaining on a contract.) If he can initiate, why can't the player? If Banner's preference is to give an up-front bonus and not renegotiate up to current market value unless it's his option, then his business tactic is faulty. If Brown is tne 10th best corner but is currently being paid much less than that, then Banner needs to renegotiate, otherwise, as players wise up to his tactics, unhappy players (i.e. always proven performers) will sprout up like weeds: not a formula for success. Renegoted increases can be net of the up-front. That's fair for everyone - much moreso than the one-sided take-it-or-leave-it dealing from a position of power that is overly expensive, and sub-optimal, in the long run. Banner should not be so myopic. A willingness by ownership to renegotiate can be a powerful player incentive. Share the wealth you depend upon these players to produce for you, as they produce it, not years later or never (in the case of injury or retirement.)And if a player does not produce up to their negotiated rate, cut your losses. You know how to do that, right? As opposed to ethics, they do teach risk remediation in all the best business schools.
Posted 11:32 AM, 04/27/2009
OKC_EAGLES
Rich is dead on here. I think this is insurance in case we trade Brown or for some crazy reason he holds out. It is odd that the Pats only wanted two 5th rounders. Does anybody know if they plan to use 'Macho' the CB from Virgina Tech as a CB or SS?
Posted 11:36 AM, 04/27/2009
Tom98786
Wait until training camp to trade Brown. Somebody's starting corner always blows a knee and the Eagles can trade him then.
Comment removed.
Posted 11:48 AM, 04/27/2009
furio
Scoop, are you kidding? The player agrees to a contract on his own free will, takes a huge signing bonus, knowing that he could end up not living up to his potential or getting hurt 3 games later, and then decides that the contract is no longer good. The Eagles can change any contract they want bc they are the owner, but they don't have to, and if Brown didn't want to be in this position, then he shouldn't have signed the long-term contract. There is a reason why players have agents/lawyers when they sign their deals, so ne excuses. Besides, it's not like players give the Eagles $$ back when they don't live up to their potential. If Brown wanted to see how things went in a few years after he signed his contract, he should have added in a players option, but he didn't want to do that since it would likely reduce his signing bonus.
Posted 11:55 AM, 04/27/2009
Reddgie Noble
Keep him till training camp and hope that a need opens up with another team (i.e. an injury or a guy someone thought would be good isn't), then trade him when he has an increased value for another pick on 2010. On the draft, looks good initially, not sure what level of talent was picked up with all of those later picks, hopefully there is another Trent Cole in the bunch.
Posted 12:08 PM, 04/27/2009
Reddgie Noble
Scoop: The front end loaded contracts benefit all parties involved, especilly the player. They get their money earlier, and have more time to make it work for themself through investing, etc.. It gives the team payroll flexibility to improve the team in the upcoming years, giving the player a greater chance of meeting team oriented bonuses (playoff victories, super bowl appearances). The FO's strategy only backfires when the player suffers from short term memory loss and forgets that they got paid before they had completely earned it.
Posted 12:08 PM, 04/27/2009
Reddgie Noble
Scoop: The front end loaded contracts benefit all parties involved, especilly the player. They get their money earlier, and have more time to make it work for themself through investing, etc.. It gives the team payroll flexibility to improve the team in the upcoming years, giving the player a greater chance of meeting team oriented bonuses (playoff victories, super bowl appearances). The FO's strategy only backfires when the player suffers from short term memory loss and forgets that they got paid before they had completely earned it.
Posted 12:25 PM, 04/27/2009
DR Heller
Cause he has a Contract and the Eagles management doesn't reneg contracts??? Thats why he'll stay here and be the new Back up for the guy Management just traded for. that makes ALOT of sense!!!! What a joke!
Posted 12:34 PM, 04/27/2009
PhillyPhantastico
I am all for renegotiations if you bring the goods to the table, but really, other than being an average CB, what has Sheldon proven?
Posted 12:46 PM, 04/27/2009
SkipinWV
By trading, the iggs get a starter and Brown no longer can say he deserves a raise, Plus he has four years left,,,,nobody put a gun to his head when he signed, remember the Quote "I'm set for life", I didn't know his life was only two years long....he can afford tweezers now, for the splinters he will get on DA BENCH!
  • Most Viewed
  • Most Commented
About Rich Hofmann
Rich Hofmann arrived at the Daily News in 1980 for a job whose status was officially designated as "full-time, temporary." A senior at Penn at the time, he was hired to fill in on the copy desk during a staff illness. The notion of him covering the Eagles or being a columnist did not exist in anyone's imagination. It was supposed to be six weeks and out, but he never left. It is only one of the reasons why so many people have concerns about him as a potential house guest. Rich has blogged the postseasons of the Flyers and Eagles.

You can now follow The Idle Rich on Twitter.
Get it now
Archives
 
April
 
April
 
March