share
email
font size
options
 
Monday, April 27, 2009

Interesting nugget in a New York Daily News Giants chat with writer Ralph Vacchiano today.

Vacchiano was asked why the Giants didn't try to trade up for Jeremy Maclin, instead letting the Eagles grab him at No. 19.

Here's what he said:

Did they "try" to move up? I suppose that depends on your definition of the word. I don't know that they made an actual offer, but they made enough calls that they were aware of the asking price. They just decided it was too high and that they were better off staying put. They never wanted to move up that high anyway. And remember, in order to trade up, someone has to want to move down. Would the Browns have wanted to drop all the way to 29? I just don't know. If they weren't willing, then there's no way a deal could have gotten off the ground. I had been told that Maclin was the highest rated WR on the Giants board, even over Crabtree. So I'm sure they gave it some thought as he started falling. It just wasn't ever close to becoming a reality.

Pretty interesting that the Giants reportedly had Maclin rated above Michael Crabtree.

And it appears they were not alone in their assessment.

NFL insider John Czarnecki of FoxSports.com wrote that Maclin was the top receiver on 18 teams' boards. I'm no math major, but even I know that's more than half the teams in the league.

The Giants, meanwhile, picked up North Carolina WR Hakeem Nicks at No. 29. They also picked up big target Ramses Barden out of Cal Poly in the third round and Wisconsin tight end Travis Beckum.

As of now, it looks like Nicks and Steve Smith could be the team's starting receivers. While the team's identity will undoubtedly be a run-heavy offense behind Brandon Jacobs, will those weapons get it done when Eli Manning needs to make a play? And don't forget, Derrick Ward is gone also.

I'll offer my take on the Eagles' draft tomorrow, but the mindset of moving up for Maclin looks even better now than it did when the deal went down.

Note: Thanks to reader/chatter Yahmpy for the link to the Giants chat in the comments section of our last post.

Posted by Sheil Kapadia @ 10:38 PM  Permalink | 12 comments
12
Comments   
Posted 11:23 PM, 04/27/2009
Bonnadn
Good Stuff. Dmac+Jmac=Best QB/WO tandem in the NFL this upcoming season!!! Go Birds....I am pumped for training camp already.
Posted 11:23 PM, 04/27/2009
Bonnadn
Good Stuff. Dmac+Jmac=Best QB/WO tandem in the NFL this upcoming season!!! Go Birds....I am pumped for training camp already.
Posted 12:04 AM, 04/28/2009
yahmpy
my pleasure, sheil. I find a nugget, I put it here.
Posted 12:43 AM, 04/28/2009
bdizzle
Does your new "mindset" have more to do with your own evaluation of the pick, or do you trust the Giant's braintrust more than the Bird's? I heard Pat Gillick was iffy on the Maclin grab, if that change's anything.
Posted 02:22 AM, 04/28/2009
FreeSheldonBrown
Thank God that Al Davis is still running the Raiders! Crabtree or Maclin would have been the pick at #7 for any other team that needed a WR at that spot and the Eagles draft would have been much different.
Posted 08:48 AM, 04/28/2009
yahmpy
apparently, bdizzle is actually Jerry Reese, LMFAO....keep reading the Philly papers, Francis, you might learn something.
Posted 08:52 AM, 04/28/2009
jonnyB
Justin Tuck was on First Take and said, "McCoy was the steal of the draft."
Comment removed.
Posted 10:31 AM, 04/28/2009
GoPhils09
i would have used the first pick on antone davis... jk... this was a great draft... GO BIRDS
Posted 11:04 AM, 04/28/2009
silvereagle1
I hate the stinkin NJ Giants. As a lifelong NJ resident, I'm insulted that they play here and refuse to put NJ on their brain buckets.Move back to NY, Please. As long as my Eagles beat those morons, I'm happy.
Posted 01:07 PM, 04/28/2009
philly57
Maclin seems like a good player - i just feel that Pettigrew would have had more impact in terms of his skill and the Bird's need for blocking (esp. on 3rd, 4th, & goaline situations) and red zone offense.
Posted 11:45 AM, 04/29/2009
PHILLYMARK
F**k the G-ants!
  • Most Viewed
  • Most Commented
About Moving the Chains
Sheil Kapadia is a sports producer for philly.com. His earliest memories as a sports fan include several trips to Veterans Stadium with his dad, most of which turned out disappointing results. He's here to discuss the NFL 365 days a year. E-mail him at skapadia@philly.com or by clicking here

And you can now follow Moving the Chains on Twitter.