share
email
font size
options
 
Wednesday, September 24, 2008


Now in their 10th year together, Andy Reid and Joe Banner seem like a part of the furniture around here -- you know, the comfortable chair whose arm you occasionally smash down upon in frustration. It is familiar and comfortable and a little bit battered. You cannot remember what the room looked like without it.

With that, consider the Detroit Lions and the Oakland Raiders.

Consider the costs of the mistakes they have made.

After years and years of stinkification, the Lions finally got rid of Matt Millen this morning as their boss. At least, that is the report on foxsports.com. They did it after the owner's son -- like his father, he is a man named Ford who has run the self-same car company -- went public with his displeasure. The time that franchise has wasted is criminal, and you don't need to tell the people of Detroit that fact. But they picked the wrong guy at the top -- and when you do that in the NFL, you put yourself into a hell that deepens with the day. You cannot get out of it until you get the guy out of it. In the meantime, you just die a little more, and then you die a little more again.

Compare to Reid and Banner. There is frustration sometimes, and anger sometimes, yes. But, honestly.

Oakland is different but the same. Crazy Al Davis continues to do crazy things -- this year's version leaves the Raiders with a head coach, Lane Kiffen, who apparently has to check on an hourly basis if he is still on the payroll. It is a ridiculous situation, with an organization apparently conspiring against itself. Their fans are proud to be insane and Davis apparently is proud to follow them. And the franchise sinks.

Compare, again, to Reid and Banner. I am not going to argue that there never have been political struggles within the Eagles, spoken and unspoken, because that is the nature of organizational behavior. Stuff like that does happen on the margins because, well, it does. But I never have had the sense that these two very powerful guys did not support each other, and that they were working together to try to get it right.

There are probably some of you sitting there saying that it isn't any great accomplishment to be better than the Lions or the Raiders, and that Reid and Banner deserve no special praise for being better than the worst. That's fine and true. But the Eagles had significant problems before Jeffrey Lurie bought the team. When Leonard Tose was the owner, his life was a financial circus -- and it held them back as a franchise. They had a significant split between the football side and the front office side when Buddy Ryan was coach and Norman Braman was owner, and while it made for terrific theater, it held them back again (besides leading to Rich Kotite and the free-agent exodus of Reggie White and the rest).

The Eagles were Detroit. The Eagles were Oakland. We forget.
Posted by Rich Hofmann @ 12:18 PM  Permalink | 20 comments
20
Comments   
Posted 10:32 AM, 09/25/2008
Cant Climb
Matt Millen knows football. He's a smart guy too.......how he failed so miserably is a mystery. Why they ekpt him 7 years is also a mystery. Reid and Banner make carefully thought out decisions.....they will figure it out at some point, but lady luck is also part of the equation.
Posted 09:29 AM, 09/25/2008
craig123
This ownership of Jeff Lurie is easilly the best the Eagles have ever had. Norman Braman, though hated by the press, got things settled and turned around, was a lot better owner then he got credit for. Now, prior to that it was a joke. Lenard Tose drank and gambled the team to the brink of bankruptsy and tried to move it to Phoenix. The clown before him did go bankrupt. Those were some long and dark years. Jeff and his organization have done nothing but win. Isn't that what we want? He and Joe Banner found Andy, and what did he do? Win !! Before Jeffrey moves on this team is going to win more than one Super Bowl and the Eagles will be in the hunt more than not.
Comment removed.
Posted 06:00 PM, 09/24/2008
Bob1
This is a loser's attitude coated with a used car salesman's pitch. We should be happy that we aren't the poor schmucks in Oakland and Detroit, and that we have Banner? We shouldn't complain because 31 other teams didn't win? They have been here for 10 years and there is no Super Bowl Championship. When is it our turn? For true fans, the world championship is paramount. As for Banner, he showed his true colors when he trashed fans on the radio a year or two ago. He is no philanthropist. Rich, I think you should find another way to support your argument, instead of having us consider ourselves fortunate. That doesn't fly for a fan base that hasn't seen a professional football championship in nearly 50 years.
Posted 04:24 PM, 09/24/2008
Skena
mebphila you better say something to 726 as well... his keen grasp of the obvious was negative too... and atleast mine was funny! Where are you? Did your Mom turn off your computer? GO PHILS!!
Posted 04:15 PM, 09/24/2008
takeitdeep
I love how everyone thinks Banner's cheap. They spend up to the salary cap every year. This isn't baseball. All I can say is be careful what you wish for - soo many idiots in this city that would rather see a suffocating D, and sh*tty QB like Bobby Hoying than a consistent winner. I guess it means nothing that you're seeing this team win more than ever before. Again, be careful what you wish for.
Posted 04:05 PM, 09/24/2008
726
The Eagles are too focused on running the "buisness" side - that's more important to them then winning a championship.
Posted 03:21 PM, 09/24/2008
JimG
Good point, Rich. Nice article. Can you imagine a franchise owned by Al Davis (the old, senile version of Al Davis) with Matt Millen as the President of the organization? Yikes, talk about hopeless situations.
Posted 03:09 PM, 09/24/2008
mebphila
yes - I typed poorly, too- it should read "What IS more surprising" - oh well, I'll never win a Super Bowl in Skena's eyes either - lol.
Posted 03:08 PM, 09/24/2008
mebphila
Skena - REALLY? THAT was insightful - I'm not sure what's is more surprising - your "typical negative" comments or the fact that you can somewhat operate a pc...brilliant stuff. Do you lose IQ points when you go to the bathroom?
Posted 03:05 PM, 09/24/2008
mebphila
well said. Sometimes -and boy, are we guilty of it more often than not in Philadelphia - you don't know how good you have it (had it) until it is gone - the so called "gold standard" set by Owner Lurie, GM Banner, and Coach Reid- is just that- gold. FLY, EAGLES, FLY!
Posted 02:31 PM, 09/24/2008
kratos
Rich could not agree with you more. The Eagles organization is doing a great job with their business and I am proud to have them running the ship and give me hope every year. I think people in this city take sports in this town way too seriously. Sports is a recreation only if you have it as your life well you have bigger issues.
Comment removed.
Posted 02:11 PM, 09/24/2008
JACK V
726...THEY HAVE WON ONE NFC CHAMPIONSHIP. FIVE NFC EAST. RICH HOFFMAN, THAT WAS AN EXCELLENT ARTICLE, OPPS, SORRY, BLOG.
Posted 02:08 PM, 09/24/2008
wondo40
Well said GreenBleedin, well said! While that elusive Lombardi trophy has yet to be paraded down Broad Street and placed in our trophy case, we enter each an every season with a legitimate shot of winning it all. And mark my words, IT WILL HAPPEN! Fly Eagles Fly!!!
Comment removed.
Posted 01:46 PM, 09/24/2008
GreenBleedin
I'm not surprised at some of the posts to your story. People who have never run any kind of business or have any leadership experience are always the first to make their snide remarks as if they are the "second coming". If "only championships matter" than 31 teams each year are failures. All Eagles fans want the big one, but to ignore the success of Lurie, Banner and Reid is the height if disingenuousness... or ignorance.. take your pick.
Posted 01:21 PM, 09/24/2008
726
This is a joke, right? Joe "Nickles" Banner? You've got to be kidding me...how many championships has Joe Banner's model won? At the end of the day, that's all that matters.
Comment removed.
Posted 12:45 PM, 09/24/2008
shoeshineboy
Who wrote this? Rich Hoffman or Dave "Spauds" Spaudauro? Whats next? Are you going to tell us that Dan Klecko "plays every down like its his last" and that Michael Gasperson "brings it every day" ?
Latest Eagles Videos
About Rich Hofmann
Rich Hofmann arrived at the Daily News in 1980 for a job whose status was officially designated as "full-time, temporary." A senior at Penn at the time, he was hired to fill in on the copy desk during a staff illness. The notion of him covering the Eagles or being a columnist did not exist in anyone's imagination. It was supposed to be six weeks and out, but he never left. It is only one of the reasons why so many people have concerns about him as a potential house guest. Rich has blogged the postseasons of the Flyers and Eagles.

You can now follow The Idle Rich on Twitter.