Why not Plaxico? Let's count the ways
BETHLEHEM, Pa. -- Andy Reid said today that he had no immediate plans to acquire a wide receiver after Riley Cooper fractured his collarbone on Saturday. But that didn't stop a segment of Eagles fans that want the Eagles to sign Plaxico Burress from voicing their desire to me and other reporters on Twitter and elsewhere.
Why not Plaxico? Let's count the ways
Jeff McLane
BETHLEHEM, Pa. -- Andy Reid said today that he had no immediate plans to acquire a wide receiver after Riley Cooper fractured his collarbone on Saturday. But that didn’t stop a segment of Eagles fans that want the Eagles to sign Plaxico Burress from voicing their desire to me and other reporters on Twitter and elsewhere.
It’s understandable. Many Birds fans look at the 6-foot-5 Burress and see a big target that the team has sorely lacked over the years and one that could help them in the red zone. They see Burress and remember the receiver that often used to have his way against the Eagles secondary as a member of the New York Giants.
But that Burress – now 34 -- is long gone. After his two-year hiatus away from the NFL, Burress joined the New York Jets last season. He was fairly productive, catching 45 passes for 612 yards and eight touchdowns.
But there’s a reason why he’s still out on the street, and it doesn’t have much to do with his checkered past. NFL scouts saw a receiver that was either spent by the end of last season or didn’t give a full effort as the Jets’ playoffs chances went up in smoke. Burress caught only eight passes for 100 yards and one score (against the Eagles) in the final four games of the season.
"He takes too long to get off the line," said an AFC scout. "And even when he gets going there is no straightaway speed."
To be fair, Burress may have run out of gas because he still didn’t have his legs under him after being released from prison only months earlier. But there were also reports out of New York that it was Burress who had gotten in the ear of receiver Santonio Holmes, who had probably the worst season of his career and who had become a major distraction on and off the field.
Burress has said on numerous occasions that he wants to play for the Eagles and with his childhood friend Michael Vick. He said it again on Saturday during an interview with 97.5 The Fanatic. He said that Andy Reid and he had spoken recently about the possibility.
Reid, though, had said as recently as the spring that Burress wasn’t in the Eagles’ cards. Times change, of course, and now the Eagles are without their fourth receiver and their biggest target in the 6-foot-3 Cooper.
Cooper’s importance isn’t necessarily his use in four-receiver sets. The Eagles rarely go four wide. Cooper, who spent all of last season as fourth on the depth chart, is important because of what he brings to the Eagles’ special teams and his readiness should DeSean Jackson or Jeremy Maclin miss time. Cooper started three games last season and caught 13 passes for 240 yards and a game-winning red zone touchdown against the Giants. Those are pretty good numbers. He did have a few drops in those games including one that fell into the hands of a Seahawks defender for an interception.
On special teams, Cooper played on both cover and return units. The Eagles rank their special teams players by compiling their tackles, blocks and other such plays, and Cooper was fourth last season among non-kickers and place holders, behind Colt Anderson, Akeem Jordan and Owen Schmitt.
Burress has not played much special teams in the NFL, if at all.
Cooper will have surgery on his collarbone and will be out for approximately six weeks, Reid said. The season starts in exactly six weeks. Reid said Cooper being ready for the Sept. 9 opener at Cleveland will be a close call. If he is not, the Eagles have six weeks to get his replacement ready. Rookie Marvin McNutt, a sixth round draft pick, would be the obvious replacement based on his size (6-foot-3). But he never played special teams at Iowa and he projects as more as a slot receiver than flanker.
There are a handful of other receivers in camp and Reid said that he wants to use this time to see if they can perform. Bringing Burress or another veteran in that this point would take snaps away from those guys. (And remember, this is a fourth receiver we're talking about.) If Cooper’s recovery takes longer than projected, and if McNutt or some of the other options in camp don’t impress Eagles coaches, than perhaps Reid may add a veteran like Braylon Edwards (who recently worked out for the Dolphins) or Mike Williams.
Or maybe Burress, although I don’t see it.
Yes Andy Pandy he did'nt have a good year! But did you just happen to see what his QB did for the year? MORON!— losteagle- I would call 8 TD's better then ok! He is far and away a much better WR then Copper….period and to keep Coppoer for special teams assumes someone else couldn't fairly easily take Coppers place on special teams like OJ or 3rd S for instance. Copper, Hall, Anderson, Schmidt are sort of wasted roster spots IMO as they are sub par at their designated positions.— connorjr
- I thought senility had begun to set. 8 TDs! If the man catches only 20 passes and 8 of them are TDs, he's worth signing.
We passed on this guy 4 times now. Yeah, he's had/has some baggage, but he's also got some bling. - Burress has said he wants to play for the Eagles... Burress has said he would love to play for the Panthers... Buress has said he would love to play in Miami... Burress has said he would love to return to the Giants... Burress will play for anyone who offers him a contract...— GJK3161
- so,,,, watching what a 6'2 rookie WR can do is more important than bringing in PB with a full training camp and experience in catching the endzone fade pass? yep!! sounds like a plan to me!! duuuh— osi is hurt boohoo
- Yes, because a young, promising rookie probably has more upside than a soon to be 35 year old with his best years behind him. As mentioned, there are reasons why he's still a FA.
— phillychaos - 8TDs with a short off season? yea he's FAR from the old plax we come to know..lol I love these writers. 4 years and not one playoff win and yet we're quick to dismiss a proven 6'5 clutch receiver that demands double coverage. Really not sure what depth some of you reporters and fans see. Cooper deserves to be on Special teams. McNutt is a rookie! Desean can not be the number 1 receiver if he cant even fight double coverage and is ranked 4th in the entire league in dropped passes. But yea here's all the reasons we dont need a superbowl winning WR who had more TDs than our Top receiver last year. He had more TDs that visanthe too! Its the Head Coaches responsibilty to put that best players on the field that will make the most plays. Plax was a model teammate last season and produced.— Yes_General
- agreed — defroe
- Dear Jeff McLane:
Thanks for shooting this BS down before it got started.
— p-diddy - I was for bringing in Burress into camp earlier and just seeing what he could do. Why not? It seems when the Eagles bring in another punter or are looking at other TE(s), it's all about " healthy competition ". That's the thing that is soo confusing about this team to it's fanbase. Wouldn't a 6'5" 232 pound veteran wide reciever bring in some " healthy competiton?" As compared to some 5'11" rejects from other teams like the Rams? They even brought in a receiver from the area football league for a look see? Just like Vick before, starting Burress off on a full offseason/training camp...his second season after being released from jail would have been good just to actually see for ourselves what he had left in the tank. You can't believe what you hear out of the Jets' camp about Burress. After all those distractions with the team in the lockeroom and on the field? That team was as dysfunctional as the Jackson family last year. Rex Ryan had no control. And now they bring in Tebow??? For the punt team? Point is...you can't believe all the stuff you hear..esp. if it's coming from up north. Bring the guy in and see for yourself. If it dosen't work out fine...cut him! But at least you could say you checked him out for yourself.— tony b
- Good post. I agree. That's what training camp is all about. — 1republican
- Wait, wait, wait. Call a time-out. I can't think fast enough. Times yours? What?— mccloudmj
- You don't need reasons for bringing Burress here. Just say NO.— Homersez
- Andy probably remembers that when Plaxico left college he was invited to a tryout with the Eagles, but passed up his tryout because somebody gave him a ticket to a basketball game at his alma mater (U of Michigan). I remember it too, and I still don't want him in an Eagles uniform.— still love randall
- LOL. Just another reason why Birds fans get looked down upon...Plax went to Sparty, not UM. But glad you remember it so vividly! — marley66
- Blah Blah... He went to Michigan State, not UofM... Who cares? Nice way to pump yourself up, marley66. — Cr0we
- is Obama out of office yet?— chilenos
- say what you want about his 8 TDs, but if he was any good he'd already be on a team. its pretty simple— leeal02
- This is a setup for Vick to fail!!!! I mean this is a complete joke we don't have 1 competent big body receiver and we think we are to good to check this guy out lol!!!! Man dang this hurt so bad, the eagles are so stupid!!!!— shaad
- Considering how "stellar" are red zone offense is, and how "bad" Plaxico plays in the red zone, it wouldn't make sense to bring him here.— Geno D
- Actually, at this point in their respective careers, I think Mike Williams would be the better option over Plaxico.
I love the fact that AR wants character guys on his team as a model for successful team, but given the talents of these two receivers - and the Eagles' needs - I don't see the harm in bringing either of them into camp and seeing what happens. Doubt very seriously they would do anything to disrupt the chemistry of this Eagles team...and if it doesn't work out, then move on.— Reality Speaks - Sorry chilenos,, Obama is still here and here to stay. If that bothers you follow your boy Mitts jobs and leave the country.— phillyroni
- And in the red zone its All about getting off the line and apperantly he cant anymore.Besides who wants another felon ,I really dont want to become the east coast Raiders!— greensob
- If the Jets are blaming Plax for Holmes issues its only bvecause they have too much money invested in Holmes and will probably try to trade him and his contract watch this year Holmes is going snap. The Eagles need Plax no way Vick can miss him in the redzonbe— Snisters
- This isn't one of the many examples of Reid acting like he's smarter than everyone else --- everybody else is staying away from PB too!— yobill626
- HEY ANDY Remember U didn't have a good year & he had 8 TD's & 600 plus yds .. i like Riley but how productive was he ??— suptom
- It won't work. You can't have 2 convicted felons (Vick) on the field at the same time!!! It would violate their paroles.— vietnamvet1969
- It's not like the Eagles are the only team allowed to sign Plaxico... He's unemployed! 31, 30 who didn't win the Super Bowl, other teams have looked at Plaxico (cause it's their job to know about everyone) and have decided that they just don't want him. Perhaps he can still play, and perhaps not, but if he is even rumored to be a locker room distraction, Reid doesn't have the luxury to take that chance. TO jacked things up for Plax. I'd rather see the Eagles find a competant back up RB and TE then signing an old, controversial, 4th receiver. It's not worth it.— macd41144
- If another WR goes down (God forbid) or a prospect fails to measure up, watch Reid grab PB fast. Even if he's only used in red zone situations or a third and short when they need a quick sideline pass and don't want to waste McCoy, PB is worth a shot.— 1republican
They need him and they know it. It will happen. And all of you who point your wayward fingers, look in the mirror. You are not perfect. Actually, you just suck at life and that is your own fault.— pritter
