share
email
print
font size
options
 
Saturday, June 27, 2009
Donovan McNabb was the only Eagles player among the top 50 in the NFL on one writer's list. (AP / Mark Stehle)

Before we know it, Super Bowl predictions are going to start emerging from publications across the country.

And judging by the national reaction to the Eagles' offseason moves, several of those are going to have the Birds going to Miami.

But one national writer doesn't seem to think too much of the Eagles' individual talent. CBSSports.com's Pete Prisco put together a list of the top 50 players in the league, and no Birds player is listed among the top 48. Donovan McNabb squeezes in at 49:

He bounced back from his benching to have a big season in 2008 and a very good postseason. With a lot of weapons on board now, plus a big line, I think he will be even better in 2009.

The QBs listed ahead of McNabb are Peyton Manning (1), Tom Brady (2), Drew Brees (5), Ben Roethlisberger (10), Philip Rivers (20), Carson Palmer (26; that one I really don't get) and Kurt Warner (29).

No Asante Samuel? No Brian Westbrook? Well, they make Prisco's 'Just Missed' section. Jason Peters doesn't get a mention at all.

CBS' Web site displays Prisco's list from the past three seasons. In 2008, Westbrook was listed at No. 20. Quite a difference a year can make, huh? Samuel was at 37. Shawn Andrews at 38. And Peters, then obviously with the Bills, at No. 27.

In 2007, Andrews was the top Eagles player listed at No. 31. McNabb made it at No. 39. And Westbrook just missed.

And finally, in 2006, it was McNabb at No. 32. Brian Dawkins, otherwise not mentioned, was on the 'Just Missed' list.

***

ESPN.com has named its All-Decade Offense and Defense, and despite the Eagles' success during this recent stretch, they only had one player, Troy Vincent, on either list.

Eagles defensive coordinator Jim Johnson did get recognized in a tie for best assistant of the decade with the Steelers' Dick LeBeau.

In the All-Decade power rankings, the Eagles came in at No. 4, behind the Patriots, Colts and Steelers.

No Eagles players made the list of top 25 players of the decade. If you're wondering about McNabb, five quarterbacks are ranked ahead of him: Brady, Manning, Warner, Roethlisberger and Brett Favre.

Posted by Sheil Kapadia @ 1:31 PM  Permalink | 44 comments
44
Comments   
Posted 12:00 PM, 06/27/2009
tonygreeneagle5
Must be a Cryboy,Pinkskin or Midget fan...
Posted 01:39 PM, 06/27/2009
Nothing but the truth
That make lists like this just to rile up people and to bring attention to their site or show. How many times has Phillip Rivers underachieved? Carson Palmer doesn't make any sense. I keep seeing these lists with him as a top 5 QB but he had only 2 good years and last year wasn't one of them. Since they are in the business to promote Qb's with failed talent in the top 50 why isn't Daunte Culpepper included as well?
Posted 02:29 PM, 06/27/2009
ttmanage
whoever made that list is a complete idiot, how do you have Phillip River Better than Mcnabb and the guys has one anything. He didn't even put Ray Lewis on the list.
Comment removed.
Posted 03:32 PM, 06/27/2009
pdditty
Brian Westbrook belongs on that list
Posted 05:08 PM, 06/27/2009
Tybee Jim
Where was Dawkins on the list?
Posted 06:07 PM, 06/27/2009
p-diddy
Brett Favre is ranked ahead of McNabb for THIS decade? Based on what?
Comment removed.
Comment removed.
Posted 08:18 PM, 06/27/2009
Big Earn
Wow, no Ray Lew on the list? Uhhh, WHO made this list and why was it published? Well, I know who actually made it....but you get my point.
Posted 09:24 PM, 06/27/2009
oldBird
who cares some guys have 3 -4 rings and are not on that stinking list
Posted 09:56 PM, 06/27/2009
didderbops
Philip Rivers and Carson Palmer ahead of McNabb? Give me a break, this guy doesn't know Diddley.
Comment removed.
Posted 09:11 AM, 06/28/2009
sheek2109
What in the blue hell... This dude is a idiot!
Posted 09:32 AM, 06/28/2009
Theo1980
who cares? im so tired of lists they dont mean jack.
Latest Eagles Videos
About Moving the Chains
Sheil Kapadia is a sports producer for philly.com. His earliest memories as a sports fan include several trips to Veterans Stadium with his dad, most of which turned out disappointing results. He's here to discuss the NFL 365 days a year. E-mail him at skapadia@philly.com or by clicking here

And you can now follow Moving the Chains on Twitter.