How many top-100 players do the Eagles have?
Philly.com, Inquirer, and Daily News coverage of the Eagles
How many top-100 players do the Eagles have?
Sheil Kapadia, Philly.com
NFL Network is currently counting down its top 100 players for 2011.
In the past two weeks, they've run through players 81-100. The voting was done by current NFL players, and it's not about a guy's body of work, but rather his value for next season.
So far, no Eagles have made the list, but a few former Birds have. Donovan McNabb just made the cut at No. 100. Terrell Owens beat him at No. 91. And Jason Babin came in at No. 85.
NFL Network is not the only outlet to go through these top 100 rankings.
Pete Prisco of CBSSports.com released his annual list last month. Six Eagles made the cut: Michael Vick (No. 22), DeSean Jackson (No. 34); Asante Samuel (No. 48); LeSean McCoy (No. 64); Jason Peters (No. 78); and Trent Cole (No. 91).
Prisco had the following quarterbacks ahead of Vick: Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, Aaron Rodgers, Drew Brees, Philip Rivers and Ben Roethlisberger. Aside from Rivers, every QB ahead of Vick has a Super Bowl ring.
Jackson was the fourth-ranked wide receiver, behind Andre Johnson, Larry Fitzgerald and Calvin Johnson.
Nnamdi Asomugha, Darrelle Revis, Tramon Williams, Charles Woodson and Champ Bailey were the cornerbacks ranked ahead of Samuel.
McCoy, Peters and Cole all ranked in the bottom half of the top 100.
Meanwhile, Pro Football Focus released their own list, and they've got only four Eagles in the top 100. Perhaps most surprising is Cole coming in at No. 4 overall, as compared to No. 91 by Prisco:
Cole got some press this year for his performances, but he still doesn’t get the credit he’s due. People will note that he’s an impressive pass rusher (he’s beyond impressive) but they rarely give him his due for his all around game (I suspect because of his size.) The 28 year old is one of the most active players in the NFL; always doing something to influence the play. He destroyed so many tackles that it’s more noteworthy when he didn’t (Week 16 being the only game he graded negatively for pass rushing.)
It should be noted that this list is based only on 2010 performance.
PFF has long been Quintin Mikell's biggest fan, and they rank him as the second Eagle on their list at No. 28:
The biggest secret in the NFL is just how good a player Quintin Mikell is. After living in the shadow of Brian Dawkins, you would have expected him to emerge, only it’s never really happened. Why? I’m not sure, because his performance over the past two years (especially 2010) has been on another level from all other safeties. Makes plays on the ball in coverage and makes plenty of defensive stops, but it gets lost because Mikell just isn’t a highlight reel type of player.
I like and respect the work that Pro Football Focus does, but as someone who has watched and re-watched every snap that Mikell played last year, I think that's just way too high. He's a good player, but based on what I've seen, not elite. We'll see what the rest of the league thinks once free agency begins.
The other Eagles to make their list are Vick at 63 and Samuel at 74.
If you missed my weekend posts, I wrote about the possibility of using the franchise tag on Kevin Kolb and then trading him after 2011. I also took a look at the Eagles draft trades, guessing what it would have taken for them to move up and draft Nebraska cornerback Prince Amukamara.
You can follow Moving the Chains on Twitter or become a fan on Facebook.
But how many 5th, 6th, and 7th round picks have made the roster? Isn't that what matters? The Eagles have not addressed their defense yet. Unless you're waiting for 2013.— GreenWing- Don't you worry GreenWing, the accounting office of Banner, Roseman and Reid have made all of the calculations and they are ready when free agency opens to grab the greatest players coming off knee injuries available. The Tonner sleeps soundly at night knowing this regime, which has forgotten more about football than the Tonner will ever know -- invented the game in fact, has a can't-miss plan for the 2011 season. It's a slam dunk, Don't waste another moment thinking about it.— hunglikeaton
- McNabb = lol— TVGuy22
Comment removed.- Mikell made plenty of highlight clips last year, just not Eagles highlight clips.— skak
lmao mikell the 28th best player in the NFL!?!?!!??!?!? you may respect the work they do, but now i NEVER will.— MPatt24- Comment removed.
- How great a coach is Reid? You answer it in part without realizing you are talking against your own point. A GREAT coach picks, develops, and keeps good players - yet Reid has only 4. Also, he started McNabb for 10 years, "...a QB that couldn't pass!'. He comes up small in making adjustments, especially against good teams and coaches. He won't ever win a SB for this town, or any other. — Dr Bri
- Please, Reid is terrible. Only 4 you say. Well there are 32 teams so the average league wide is 3.12. So the Eagles have 0.88 more players make the list then the average and if he had a clue how to draft we would have at least 6. — Eagle GREEN Mt State
- Mikell = Toast— NC Eagle Fan
- It just all goes to show that rating systems are inherently flawed. They're all based on judgement and personal likes/dislikes.— dlscholt
- Strange lists. It's hard to believe McNabb is 100 and Owens is 91, although I don't have all day to think of 100 or 91 others to put ahead of them. I don't know where the love for Jason Peters comes from, and I'd put Cole higher than 91 (and Quixote, I blame McDermitt's "Cole in pass coverage" schemes for the drop off). Mikell at 28 is silly, and even sillier that he's ahead of Vick and Samuel.— T
- @ T,Does anybody care what Pete Prisco of CBSsports has to say? Mikell is on the PFF and who cares about that seriously? This article is poorly written since it starts off talking about the NFL Network top 100 when it isn't even done yet. And for all you Jason Peters haters, suck it.
— beerflow - Am I the only one that thinks Shady McCoy doesn't belong on that list? He has had so few 100 yard games in his career. I don't see how you can rank him in the top half of running backs, let alone the top 100 overall players.— MattPSU
- He had 8 games with over 100 Total yards. The same amount of games with over 100 total yards as MJD, Chris Johnson. 1 more than Michael Turner. In this offense, you have to account for receiving yards. Westbrook never had a ton of 100+ yard games, yet he was one of the most feared RBs in the NFL. — PHTNPHLS
Follow
Sheil on Twitter. And become
a fan of Moving the Chains on Facebook.
Download our NEW iPhone/Android app for even more Birds
coverage, including app-exclusive videos and analysis. Download it here.
