share
email
font size
options
 
Tuesday, November 10, 2009
Brent Celek's touchdown was one of the few bright spots for the Eagles Sunday against the Cowboys. (Yong Kim / Staff Photographer)

A player-by-player breakdown of the Eagles' offensive performance against the Cowboys:

Donovan McNabb - He just looked out of sorts all game. McNabb probably should have been picked off on a bad throw intended for DeSean Jackson on the first series. Did the Eagles have protection problems? Yes. But even when McNabb had time, he was off-target. In the fourth quarter, he had Jackson wide open and threw behind him. The couple bright spots were when he bought time and made plays -- on the screen to LeSean McCoy that went for 45 yards, and on the touchdown to Brent Celek. McNabb's 61.4 QB rating was his lowest of the season.

Michael Vick - We'll keep this one short: a 2-yard carry in the first and a handoff to McCoy later in the game. If the Eagles felt Vick could help them, they would be using him more. Consider it a failed experiment until you see proof suggesting otherwise.

LeSean McCoy - There were some real bright spots for McCoy, and also a couple mistakes. He broke a tackle and had a great individual effort on a 17-yard run in the second quarter. Overall, he did a decent job as a blocker. There was one play where he was supposed to get in DeMarcus Ware's way before going out into his route, but McCoy didn't do enough, and Ware forced a McNabb incompletion. The normally sure-handed receiver also had a couple dropped passes. He did take a screen 45 yards in the third quarter for the Eagles' biggest offensive play of the game. And as I said yesterday, he missed a chance to convert in short yardage in the fourth quarter. Overall, 13 carries for 54 yards and five catches for 61.

Leonard Weaver - Solid game for Weaver. Eight carries for 33 yards, and some punishing blocks. He showed great athleticism on a 17-yard reception in the first quarter, but it was called back because of a Todd Herremans penalty.

Winston Justice - Not his greatest performance of the season, but Justice did an OK job. He was overpowered by Cowboys defesive end Stephen Bowen on a third-down McCoy carry in the second. Justice also had some problems in protection, although he did not give up a sack. He false started on a 3rd-and-7 in the fourth quarter for his second penalty of the season.

Stacy Andrews - Nightmarish game for Andrews. He gave up a sack to Jay Ratliff in the first quarter and a second on 3rd-and-9 in the second. Andrews completely missed his block on Ware during Vick’s 2-yard run. And he forced McNabb to escape the pocket after getting beat by Jason Hatcher. Andrews came in during the third possession and stayed in at right guard once Jason Peters went down. I don't believe he returned though after Peters came back in. I have to double-check though. He did make one nice block on Ratliff to open up a hole for a 5-yard McCoy run in the second.

Nick Cole - He had some serious problems in pass protection, particularly with Igor Olshansky. Cole moved over to left guard when Todd Herremans slid to left tackle. He went back to right guard once Peters returned. Hatcher beat him to sack McNabb in the fourth, but holding was called on Dallas away from the line of scrimmage.

Jamaal Jackson - Jackson had some trouble with Jay Ratliff, who really impressed me as I re-watched the game. Ratliff was disruptive in the interior all game. As analyst Cris Collinsworth pointed out, Jackson should have snapped the ball on 4th-and-1 when the Eagles had the Cowboys offsides in the third.

Todd Herremans - As I mentioned, he moved to left tackle when Peters went down. It was actually an interesting scene at the Linc. King Dunlap started to come on to the field as Peters came off, but was waved away. The Eagles gave him help with Ware on most plays, but when he was left by himself, Herremans had serious problems, which was to be expected.

Jason Peters - He was probably the offense's biggest bright spot. Peters completely neutralized Ware, both early on, and then later when he re-entered the game. Peters often pushed Ware upfield, past McNabb. Really an impressive performance. The one downside was the false start on 4th-and-1 in the third.

Brent Celek - Three catches for 39 yards, including a touchdown (his fourth of the season). The Cowboys moved Ware around, and Celek found himself on the losing end of a one-on-one battle with the Pro Bowl defensive end on a run play in the first. He made a nice block on Anthony Spencer during McCoy's 17-yard run. Celek had a drop on the Eagles' final drive.

Alex Smith - The throw from McNabb in the first quarter was high, although Smith had a chance at it. His blocking was not very good. Smith got beat by Spencer in pass protection in the third, leading to a McNabb incompletion. He didn't get the job done during the Eagles' short-yardage failures in the fourth quarter. Smith had an 11-yard grab in the third, picking up a first down.

DeSean Jackson - The Cowboys were successful in shutting him down and making other players beat them. Jackson had just two catches for 29 yards. He did deliver a good effort as a downfield blocker on the 45-yard screen pass to McCoy.

Jeremy Maclin - He and McNabb were not on the same page all day. On the first offensive play of the game for the Eagles, he looked up for the ball about a full two seconds after it had sailed out of bounds. The first interception is on him. If you've watched McNabb for years, that wasn't even close to his fastball. Maclin has to make that catch. Chalk it up to rookie growing pains. It was encouraging to see McNabb still go to him in the fourth quarter. Overall, three catches for 44 yards.

Jason Avant - He made a very nice catch for 23 yards on third down in the second. Avant caught the only other ball thrown his way. On the downside, he picked up a 15-yard penalty for unsportsmanlike conduct, helping Celek celebrate after his TD.

Reggie Brown - Yes, Brown was on the field at times. Nothing else to really say about him though. No balls were thrown his way.

Posted by Sheil Kapadia @ 10:39 AM  Permalink | 24 comments
24
Comments   
Posted 10:58 AM, 11/10/2009
Lemur
You would think they would have went out and got a TE that is just known for blocking instead of getting Alex Smith who is another receiving TE which we already have
Posted 11:34 AM, 11/10/2009
Philly_Guy
Maybe they should stay away from tight ends named Smith.
Posted 11:46 AM, 11/10/2009
The Manager
This team is just clueless most of the time. They lack passion, fire, discipline and leadership. They will always be bridemaids but never a bride. With the talented players they have you would think they'd play better on Sunday's. All I ever see is they can "sometimes" beat bad teams but very rarely a not so bad or good team. Being an Eagles fan really sucks most of the time.........
Posted 11:55 AM, 11/10/2009
tony_daysog.at.alum.berkeley.edu
At one point, I actually wanted my team to get Vick . . . but if you knew what he did to animals . . . it was just waaaaay too horrific. What did he do? He and his friends threw live dogs into a pool and then electrocuted the pool. The electrocuting dogs tried to save themselves by swimming to and then climbing the pool wall to get out of the pool, no avail. To this day, there are hundreds of CLAW marks against the side of pools where dogs tried to save themselves. I believed that people deserve a fair break -- but what he did is/was soooooo atrocious, I am unusually livid against him. NOW . . . he's quoted in Yahoo Sports as whining about playing in the NFL? Apparently, what he did to get back in was all a rouse and everybody's been fooled by him. Nothing has changed. The underlying arrogance that led him to kill, slaughter, terrorize, and TORTURE animals . . . that underlying arrogance is still there. It's still there. Philly . . . do the right thing. NFL . . . do the right thing. http://sports.yahoo.com/nfl/blog/shutdown_corner/post/Michael-Vick-doesn-t-sound-so-thrilled-about-bei?urn=nfl,201166
Posted 12:02 PM, 11/10/2009
jakster
As an offensive team there were no bright spots and the coaching and game management were even worse. The defense played okay until Brown got toasted by Austin. Mammoth College is in NJ......no Eagle scouts knew this kid was hiding out there? They were having cheesesteaks with Andy.
Posted 12:06 PM, 11/10/2009
CarpGuy
A couple of sideline shots of McNabb showed an expression and body language of a guy who just didn't want to be there. "Out of sorts" is one way to put. Sometimes he can compensate for his erratic passing (10 years in the league and still has trouble with mechanics???), with passion which leads to playmaking. Not this Sunday. I think I'm about ready for the steadiness of a Kolb.
Posted 12:24 PM, 11/10/2009
massfan
I support #5, but I still don't like all the grinning and smiling unless the job is getting done!
Posted 12:27 PM, 11/10/2009
philharmonic55
As long as Cap'n Andy and D-Mac run this team, expect more of the same every game:Up and Down. Why has the offense been so inconsistent over all these years (especially with the coaching "genius", Q-back, and offensive stars we have) while the defense plays steadily and competitively without the same level of talent?
Posted 01:41 PM, 11/10/2009
craig123
The O-Line has been a mess since the first day of camp. If it could go wrong, it has. I don't care what anyone says, it takes a full year, after you get back, to recover from ACL surgery. Andrews will improve as the year goes on. I'm sure Herremans and his broken foot are not 100%. Nick Cole and Winston Justice are first year starters. Peters had a leg inury during camp and is just now getting a feel for playing with this team. This line plays well together at times and other times they don't. Looked great against the Gaints and bad against the Cowboys. Donovan is in his 30's now and can't dance like he used to and disrupting his rythum (poor blocking up front) is how you can beat him. This is going to take time people, get used to it. The last time a defense tried to take Jackson out of the picture, Maclin had a great game. He's a rookie, he's going to have off games just like Jackson did last year. McCoy is a stud, but a rookie too, so he's going to make mistakes. Remember, he's getting a lot more playing them due to Westbrooks injuries. Bottom line, this is a really good team that is only going to get better and more consistant with time. Blame Andy and #5 all you want, but this is a very young team with new faces (O-Line) at key positions. Injuries have been a nightmare so far on both sides of the ball. Hell, we have 3 new LB's that didn't play for us last year due to injuries. Give this team a little slack.
Posted 02:08 PM, 11/10/2009
bow
REID AND MCNABB MAKES MY BLOOD BOIL
Posted 02:13 PM, 11/10/2009
Shabba Rommel
Eagles stink...and are the Gold Standard of mediocrity.
Posted 02:45 PM, 11/10/2009
JerryS
Only bright spots that I saw wer the lights ontop of the stadium shinign down on a bumbling Big red and anerratic despondetn Donnie boy. bring back Kolb and give us a season!!
Posted 05:17 PM, 11/10/2009
scars73
Do you guys just recycle the same stuff every day and give it a new title?
Posted 07:04 PM, 11/10/2009
RoastedBird
OHHHHHHH NOOOOOOOOOO; McNabb misfired on a few passes; what's new..I've never seen a QB that goes 100% in games. I see Brady, Ben and others make bad throws...saw a few last night....also have seen some WR's make UNBELIEVABLE catches....point: McNabb is solid; how about a few more PRO LEVEL catches where passes don't have you hit you in the chest to be considered a good pass...i.e. THE GROWN MAN CATCH J. Avant made....maybe the TEAM needs to MAN UP..including coaches so you can stop using McNabb as your whipping boy....I played WR in HS and College...here is the rule: The ball touches your hands-YOU CATCH IT-YOU MIGHT ACTUALLY HAVE to dive, jump or change directions....that's what make you a PRO!!!
Posted 07:16 PM, 11/10/2009
Bill1966
Ha ha ..a wasted decade of smiling laughing and losing. The only bright spot is that there is light at the end of the tunnel in Kevin Kolb. Goodbye Fatnabb , keep smiling as you stole 100 million from us.
Latest Eagles Videos
About Moving the Chains
Sheil Kapadia is a sports producer for philly.com. His earliest memories as a sports fan include several trips to Veterans Stadium with his dad, most of which turned out disappointing results. He's here to discuss the NFL 365 days a year. E-mail him at skapadia@philly.com or by clicking here

And you can now follow Moving the Chains on Twitter.