Bob Ford: Patchwork D comes up short

share
email
print
reprint
font size
comments
24
options
 

SAN DIEGO - Even though it seems like a risky idea in the heart of an NFL season, it turns out you can take an outside linebacker and make him the middle linebacker on less than a week's notice.

And you can also have two cornerbacks go missing, and, additionally, find yourself forced to start a free safety who might or might not be able to play. There can be players elevated from the practice squad and players signed from somewhere else, and they can all be thrown into the mix. All of that can happen, and the defense can take the field with more patches than the English faculty coat closet.

RON CORTES / Staff Photographer
The Eagles' Brodrick Bunkley shows his frustration after a third-quarter touchdown run of 20 yards by the Chargers' LaDainian Tomlinson made the score 21-6 in favor of San Diego.
1 of 4

You just can't win that way very often.

The Eagles lost to the San Diego Chargers, 31-23, for a number of reasons yesterday, but biggest among them was the first number in that score. Thirty-one points. It was only the third time this season the Eagles had allowed more than 17 points in a game, and those occasions account for three of their four losses.

This isn't a team - despite the offensive weapons available - that puts up a lot of points. Some of that is because the offense loses its super powers in the Kryptonite-laced strata of the red zone. That was probably something that stood out yesterday, for instance.

If the Eagles give more than 20 points or so, they're going to be in trouble. If they give up 31, well, it's probably going to be a loss.

"When you get down to it, we beat ourselves," cornerback Dmitri Patterson said. "We had them in situations and we just didn't get it done."

The members of the defense were most upset about the Chargers' last drive to a field goal. San Diego got the ball with just over seven minutes to play, holding a five-point lead. If the Eagles had stopped the Chargers and given Donovan McNabb back the ball with time to work, who knows? San Diego certainly wasn't stopping him from piling up yards.

"I know we gave up something like 450 yards receiving, but we played a good game," San Diego cornerback Antonio Cromartie said.

No, actually not. The Chargers' defense was merely fortunate that the Eagles couldn't make their layups after the football equivalent of driving the length of the floor.

The failings of the Eagles' defense were quite different. Even though San Diego came into the game with the lowest-ranked rushing offense, and with the rest of the league operating under the assumption that LaDainian Tomlinson was long past his prime, the Chargers ran the ball effectively, with Tomlinson gaining 96 yards. He scored two touchdowns, including a 20-yard run that highlighted the Eagles' inability to get in the right place and make tackles once arriving there.

While the last failure was the most apparent - leaving the Eagles trailing by eight points with no time-outs and just 30 seconds to play - it was no more important than when the Eagles couldn't defend a direct snap on one drive in the first half or react to a well-timed draw play on another. The Chargers scored touchdowns on both of those drives, and added two more in the third quarter.

On the first drive, Asante Samuel had his weekly missed tackle and there was a silly roughing penalty. On the second, a crucial third-and-2 play became an automatic first down when Ramzee Robinson lined up offside at the cornerback position.

You say you didn't know there was a player named Ramzee Robinson on the roster? It would have remained a secret had Ellis Hobbs and Joselio Hanson not been lost last week; Hobbs because of a neck injury, Hanson because he can't digest Kung Pow pork, apparently.

Too many changes all at once was the problem yesterday. There were too many new parts being thrown into the engine for it to operate properly. The bad news it that it might not get better any time soon.

"We can't use injuries as an excuse," defensive coordinator Sean McDermott said. "We have to keep the focus on getting the job done. We've got good football players with a lot of heart and soul."

Yeah, the thing is, so do the other teams. And if you are playing your third- and fourth-string options against the other teams, there will be mismatches and execution breakdowns and more stupid penalties . . . which is quickly becoming an Eagles specialty.

"That was more points than we wanted to give up," said Will Witherspoon, who was moved from middle linebacker to the weak side to make up for the loss of Akeem Jordan. "But we know this is a process. We expect the next guys in line to step up."

That would be nice, but it won't always work that way. Chris Gocong, who played middle linebacker yesterday for the first time since high school, did well enough, but that doesn't mean it was seamless.

"There were times when I had to think about what I should be doing," Gocong said. "For the most part I felt good."

The Eagles don't have time for a slow process, and their desperate situation got worse when Sheldon Brown injured a hamstring and missed the second half. This is not the part of the schedule in which they can coast along and pick up wins without playing particularly well.

"We came up stinking short," said Andy Reid. "But with that kind of fight and that kind of heart, we're going to be OK."

Eventually, the Eagles are going to have to realize this is a test of talent, not personality. Fight and heart are wonderful. Talent would be more useful.

 


Contact columnist Bob Ford

at 215-854-5842

or bford@phillynews.com.

Read his blog

at http://philly.com/postpatterns.

 

share
email
print
reprint
font size
options
 
24
Comments   
Posted 07:54 AM, 11/16/2009
CoolRunnings
If I were Andy Reid, I would think about bringing in someone with a fresh set of eyes and a history of offensive success in the red zone. I would let them evaluate what the Eagles are doing and let them suggest what they think would work. The coaching we have now has locked into a set mentality and will not vary from what they think. There are things not being used that should be, and sometimes all that is needed is a fresh perspective to solve a problem.
Posted 08:15 AM, 11/16/2009
warbird
You have to be able to run the ball when it counts!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Posted 08:48 AM, 11/16/2009
Kenny Junod
Bring back Kylie Eckell
Posted 08:57 AM, 11/16/2009
Earl J
Losing Dawk has proven to be huge on Defense. Reid, Banner and Lurie could have all done somehing but no one wanted to tell Banner to get over losing the chess match and sign him already.......
Posted 10:12 AM, 11/16/2009
FireAndyReid
andy reid is an idiot.
Posted 10:24 AM, 11/16/2009
JLB
Up until now, I haven't been one of the reflexive "FIRE REID" guys, but I think it's time for a change - the drive killing/extending penalties, the poor clock management, insisting on running a system for which his QB is INCREDIBLY poorly suited...it's time for a change. Hopefully, the reason that this contract extension hasn't happened yet is because Lurie's starting to have second thoughts...time to move on, Jeff. Even the best coaches get fired.
Posted 10:57 AM, 11/16/2009
rodney517
Please don't give Big Red an extension...PLEASE DON'T. He has to go somewhere else. Buffalo would love him. is he a good coach..YES!!! but will never win the big game!!!
Posted 11:07 AM, 11/16/2009
wvbillz
Amen JLB...It's almost to the point that I don't even care if they win as long as the Cowboys lose...feels like the 90's again...
Posted 11:15 AM, 11/16/2009
ox
biggest area of concern.................the coaching
Posted 11:35 AM, 11/16/2009
mick
Excuses, excuses, excuses........Reid and McNabb have to go, and the loss of Dawkins proves are defense stinks!!!!!!!!
Posted 11:43 AM, 11/16/2009
U824942
If you don't want to bring ried back, who do the Eagles hire? An experienced coach or an untested coordinator? An what about McNabb - Stay or Go? if so, who do we get to play QB?
Posted 12:20 PM, 11/16/2009
Bobphxville
The lack of a running game and the associated inability of the O-Line to rub block is what absolutely kills the Eagles in the red zone and has the the past couple of years. They can move up and down the field with the passing game, but that doesn't effectively work in the red zone. When they are on the 5 yard line, the offense can't turn on a run game, that was ignored all game. This season was doomed on both sides of the ball in pre-season - when Bradley went down on defense, and Shaun Andrews on offense. They still haven't recovered from those two injuries.
Posted 12:29 PM, 11/16/2009
tnjoe
What don't we understand about this team. There is no pass rush as only 2 sacks show. The Line backers are not quick and really can't stop the run Last but not least Management dosen't care they will make money and this franchise value will increase. I guess we have to get used to the management goal of being in contention and selling tickets and jerseys. Lets face it The birds won't win with this coach and QB. It not the QB fault that the we can't make a yard on a run thats the line coach and Andys read on bringing talent here. It hurts to state that the birds didnot hit as hard as the team from Dallas but if you had to bet are you really going to pick yhe birds to win the EAST?It is give up time and carry signs that" wait till next Year" What I really don't get is the bad play selection and the the QB can't change the play. Oh yea one last note. Andys read on talent shows up best with his bringing in Vick and Trotter!! What for?
Posted 12:33 PM, 11/16/2009
gordy
Of course Gocong felt pretty good, this game was just like any other he plays in. He was a complete non-factor. He is terrible, I don't care how much the eagles try to tell us otherwise. Mikell is a nuce player but he will never be mentioned in the same sentence as Dawkins
Posted 02:50 PM, 11/16/2009
onetimer
andy reid is a slob..
Latest Eagles Videos
Sign up to receive the daily sports newsletter