Eagles-Steelers Rewind
Philly.com, Inquirer, and Daily News coverage of the Eagles
Eagles-Steelers Rewind
Jeff McLane
Here are some observations and notes after re-watching the Eagles’ 16-14 loss to the Steelers on Sunday:
ON SECOND THOUGHT
LeSean McCoy’s strong effort against the Steelers was another example of why statistics, especially in football, can be overrated. If you were just looking at the running back’s numbers on Sunday – 16 carries for 53 yards and four catches for 27 yards and touchdown – it could be surmised that McCoy had just a so-so day. In actuality, he turned in his most gutsy performance of the season.
McCoy’s most impressive moments came in the fourth quarter during the Eagles’ 17-play, 79-yard drive that briefly gave them a 14-13 lead. He ran off right tackle on the first play for five yards. Andy Reid and Marty Mornhinweg had been running McCoy more to the right this season, but on Sunday he had seven carries to the right for 17 yards (2.3 avg.), eight to the left for 32 yards (4 .0 avg.) and one up the middle for five yards.
On the Eagles’ first fourth-and-one conversion, McCoy and center Dallas Reynolds were the heroes. Linebacker Lawrence Timmons met McCoy at the line when there was initially no room for the running back to run right. If Timmons didn’t leave his feet, he probably makes the tackle. But McCoy slipped him and bounced back to his right. Waiting there was Keenan Lewis. The cornerback unwisely went high and McCoy powered two yards behind Reynolds, who held his block for a long time.
Five plays later, McCoy took another handoff on a fourth-and-one play designed to go right, but this time he didn’t have to dance. He plowed straight ahead behind guard Danny Watkins. McCoy’s longest tote of the day was 10 yards. But he consistently churned out the tough yards and ran for six first downs.
McCoy displayed his open-field moves, as well. As the “hot” receiver after the Steelers blitzed in the third quarter, he took a short pass from Michal Vick, pivoted left and scurried past linebacker Larry Foote for a 15-yard touchdown. Foote is 32 and may be excused, but later, McCoy juked 27-year-old safety Ryan Mundy out his jock on a six-yard run.
REWIND THE TAPE
There were many plays the Eagles could look back upon and say, ‘What if?’ But the Steelers’ third-and-12 conversion on their game-winning drive was perhaps the most frustrating because it wasn’t properly executed. The Eagles were in a “Tampa 2” zone defense with both safeties deep. They pass rushed only four. Defensive end Jason Babin got around right tackle Marcus Gilbert, but he was little deep. Babin slapped an arm across the Ben Roethlisberger’s thigh as Gilbert pushed him to the ground, but the quarterback merely stepped up in the pocket to avoid the pressure.
The Eagles did not have significant push up the middle. Cullen Jenkins rushed from the left defensive tackle spot. Fletcher Cox ran a loop from the other tackle position as defensive end Trent Cole rushed inside. Steelers running back Isaac Redman helped his lineman with a chip block on Cox. Jenkins and Cole were contained.
Meanwhile, down the field 20 yards wide receiver Antonio Brown slipped in between cornerback Brandon Boykin and linebacker Mychal Kendricks. It wasn’t clear after the game which player had ultimate responsibility for Brown, but it was Boykin, who was supposed to stay with receiver.
IN THE SPOTLIGHT
1. Nnamdi Asomugha did not have a strong game. He was targeted seven times, per Pro Football Focus, and surrendered six catches for 58 yards. The one incompletion was the Roethlisberger throw to Brown in the end zone that he should have caught before the half. Asomugha’s struggles did not mean Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie was perfect at the other cornerback spot, nor should one expect as much at an under-the-spotlight position. But he was very good for most of the game and contributed to Mike Wallace catching two of eight targeted passes for 17 yards. Roethlisberger threw at Rodgers-Cromartie six times, but the intended target only caught three passes for 28 yards. If there was one quibble with Rodgers-Cromartie’s play it was when he backed off of Brown on a third and seven late in the first half. He was more than ten yards off when the receiver caught an 11-yard pass on a slant route.
2. The Eagles offensive line, for the most part, acquitted itself against a tough defense in difficult playing conditions. But each lineman had breakdowns, perhaps none more so than Danny Watkins. The right guard continues to have issues in pass protection. The most egregious example occurred in the third quarter when Vick dropped to throw from the Steelers 49. He had no time to throw because Watkins flat-out missed his block on Steve McLendon. The nose tackle sacked Vick and forced another fumble. Watkins, nearby and not doing much, was able to recover the fumble.
3. Even though he played the least amount of snaps among the defensive tackles, Cedric Thornton was the most active of the group. He recorded three tackles – one solo and two assists – and drew two of Steelers guard Willie Colon’s four holding penalties (one was offset by an Eagles penalty). On both holds, Colon had to tackle Thornton to the ground because he had beaten him so badly. After coming out like gangbusters in his first four games as a pro, Fletcher Cox had a quiet fifth game.
STAT SHEET
In the first four games of the season, the Eagles run defense was especially nasty in the second half. Opposing running backs gained only 115 yards on 44 carries (2.6-yard average) after totaling 176 yards on 42 tries (4.2 avg.) in the first half. But the Steelers run game wore the Eagles down on Sunday. In the first half, Pittsburgh running backs rushed for 26 yards on eight carries (3.3 avg.). After the break, they ran for 96 yards on 20 totes (4.8 avg.).
THIS AND THAT
-- Even though Brent Celek caught only three passes for nine yards – and a pretty important touchdown – it wasn’t because he was asked to stay in and block more than usual. Reid said that the Steelers played particular attention to limiting the tight end’s effectiveness over the middle.
-- The officials should have called pass interference on the second quarter bomb Vick threw to DeSean Jackson. The receiver was double covered, but cornerback Ike Taylor draped his arm around Jackson just before the ball hit his one hand.
-- To be fair, the Eagles got away with a few no-calls. Safety Nate Allen made contact with receiver Emmanuel Sanders before he was credited with a pass breakup in the second quarter. Linebacker DeMeco Ryans decked a pressured Roethlisberger after he threw a ball out of bounds. The quarterback was out of the pocket which may have been why the referees swallowed their whistles.
-- Tackle Demetress Bell had what could accurately be described as an up-and-down game. He kept Steelers linebacker James Harrison in check for much of the game. But Bell missed several blocks and did very little to help tight end Clay Harbor on the screen pass that advanced the Eagles to the 2-yard line in the fourth quarter when he was the lead blocker.
-- Jason Babin was credited with tipping a Roethlisberger pass near the goal line before the half when it was really Kendricks that got his hand on the ball.
-- Safety Ryan Clark will likely be fined for leading with his helmet when he hit Celek in the third quarter. He made no attempt to wrap Celek up and was clearly using his helmet as a weapon.
-- Kendricks sprained his ankle when Brown took a screen pass 14 yards. After tight end Heath Miller blocked Asomugha to the ground, Kendricks got tangled up with Miller’s foot.
POINT AFTER
There’s a chorus of fans that don’t want to hear it, and in some ways it’s understandable considering Vick’s 11 turnovers in five games. But there’s no way Reid should go to backup Nick Foles at this point.
Besides the unknown, Vick’s improvement over the last two weeks against the blitz is more than enough reason to keep the rookie in the garage for now. Vick completed 11 of 16 passes for 123 yards and two touchdowns when the Steelers sent more than four pass rushers, according to PFF. Vick was also sacked twice.
His two touchdown passes against the blitz were perfectly executed -- hitting McCoy as the hot receiver and then standing in the pocket, under intense pressure, and delivering a two-yard strike to Celek.
If only Vick can figure out that fumble thing.
How many people miss JJ? Look how bad our defense has gone since he passed. What a joke of a DC we have. Eagle football is all about our D, it's been that way for 30 years and now we have this joker ruining this team. I can't even watch this team anymore. No one even makes a big hit on this D. They're soft just like their coaches. And Marty another joker, how about more screen passes, a draw or maybe some trickery with a reverse to Jackson or wide receiver screen? something for petes sake. They make it so easy for the opposing D the way they play so vanilla— kchaz- Nnamdi allowed 6 receptions for approx 9 yds a catch, and DRC allowed 3 catches for 7 yds a catch, and no touchdowns, how is either of those games in the NFL not outstanding? What team would not take those results from there Defensive Backs every game? When the Game was hanging in the balance, Pittsburgh didn't pick on either of those guys to get the yards they needed in the clutch, I wonder why.
That's as ridiculous as some of the writers blaming the lose on Vick who lead the Eagles to a touchdown to go ahead on the teams' final drive.
— Dexter - I cannot watch another EAGLES game until VICK and REID are gone!!! Please call me when that happens.— i.dislike.sue.e.martin.brogan.endress
- Re...joeman...ok vick has been shaky,but TRADE VICK,FOR OMO..??? really dude?...that would never,ever happen.tell u what....u trade yourself to dallas.vick has been shaky,but never ever,trade him to dallas..........daym dude they 're the worst of our hated teams here.— t_darb_56
- the worst thing about these vick fumbles is that the ball is just falling out of his hands the instant he has ANY contact.
and his "whatever will be" attitude about it afterwards made me do a huge WTF?— bloodymess - Football is a team sport. I have stopped stressing over who did what at which point in the game. Vick fumbled in the red zone. Then he fumbled again but what I like about him is he doesn't give up and he keeps his cool and keeps you in the game. Now with that said we can be happy when the Defense holds the Steelers from scoring after the turnover, but do they get a bye because we lost by a few points when all they needed to do was stop them from going from the 18yd line into field goal range with no time on the clock? Or does the Special Teams get a bye for giving them a short field on kickoff returns? what about the coaches who called for Vick to run the QB sneak knowing he's going to take a beating all day already? or the coach who won't call for a blitz all day just to keep Ben from getting comfortable in the pocket? No it's a team sport. You win as a team and you lose as a team. Each person does his part and if they fail in their assignment the team picks them up and continues the mission of win at all cost. I'm going to enjoy the games each week because last time I checked the Eagles still have time to improve, gel, make adjustments and have playoff potential and aspirations. What more can you ask for in this season. Forget about the last one it's gone. And next year isn't promised. All you have is the shot this year.— Jsfulmore1
- Wow, stay positive Philly!! Reid does need clock management 101, and MV needs to hold onto the ball. That being said if mistakes can minimized and some players can wake up, this team can win enough games to get us to the post season. BELIEVE PHILLY.— igonzo0311
- "LeSean McCoy’s strong effort against the Steelers was another example of why statistics, especially in football, can be overrated."
A better way to say this is why the wrong statistics can be overrated. There is a statistic that measures Shady's production from yesterday well, success rate. It's used on many popular stats sites, like footballoutsiders and advancednflstats. Why start your column taking a swipe at "statistics", then filling the rest with stats from PFF and conventional run stats? I like your column for the mix of tape review, advanced and conventional stats, and common sense. Please don't play to the cheap seats with cliches like "statistics, especially in football, can be overrated." Gut reaction, especially in football, is almost always overrated.— Behan01 - My wife knows very little about football but I can sit with her and she can tell if they are running or passing. Nothing crative about this offence anymore.— joemani28
- Nnamdi is Nigerian for "bust."— coloradoeagle
- The Eagles wanted a corner who was physical at the line. They unfortunately did not take into account that Nnamdi is not as strong once the ball is in the air. This would not be a problem if the Defense is designed to bring maximum pressure to the QB disrupting the pocket. The Eagles don't blitz anymore. So Reid got a guy who would have been awesome in the Jim Johnson system because there was a constant blitz thus disrupting the timing routes. It's all about the system you play in. — Jsfulmore1
- Eagles should hire my wife, she is the only on Earth who is dumber than Reid— sammydelphia
- Sucks to be your wife. Any man who would make such a comment should be kicked in the nuts and divorced. I am hoping your wife reads these posts. — Rhese
- One of the knocks against Ryan Howard and Greg Luzinski was their poor defense. However, their production at the plate outweighed their defensive issues. Right now, I'm not seeing any offensive production out of Vick that outweighs his turnovers. And his apparent confusion and indecision does not lead me to believe that he will start producing. I'm not sure Foles is the answer...but Vick doesn't seem to be the answer either. The sooner the eagles realize that the better.— flex
- I found Vicks statements after the game both weird and appalling " if it was meant to be it was meant to be" what the hell is that? Has there ever been a q.b. with more redzone turnovers, seriously I certainly never witnessed it and I have watched football for over 35 years. I am not sure if it is arrogance or stupidity that doesn't allow him to learn from his mistakes— yourdaddy!
- When was the last time we were surprised by an Eagles play call? I can't remember when!— PhilliPhanatik
- I would trade Vick for Romo in a heartbeat. Romo is 10 times better than Romo. Oh and one more thing Vick and Andy need to go. If you lined up all the QBs in the NFL, you would have to place Vick between 22-28. I'm tring hard to find more than 3-5 that are worse. Andy coaching has went downhill for the last 6 years. Its getting to the point where opposing players know whats coming before the Eagles line up. I can call about 75 percent of the plays from my couch.— joemani28
- Correction: Romo is 10 times better than Vick. — joemani28
- I'm looking forward to November 11. Tony Romo vs. Michael Vick: The Turnover Bowl.— SedatedManiac
- The over/under should be 7. — coloradoeagle
- The 2012 Philadelphia Eagles: The Greatest Fraud on Turf!— SedatedManiac
- Vick needs to move better in the pocket. Watch Brady, Rothesberger, Luck, and Manning and they are as immobile as they come but they seems to make little moves forward or to the side and can avoid the rush making their lines look great. Vick seems to get a bit panicky and runs into the coming rushers quite a bit.— connorjr
- Your right about those other Quarterbacks. Think of it this way. Vick is the equivalent of Allen Iverson looking for a passing lane through all those other taller people in front of him. If he slides left or right it's probably going to obstruct his view further. On top of that he's throwing to smaller receivers. I believe he was dropping back much further in 2010 on passing plays which helped him see the field better, and also by time against the rush. Remember the Giants comeback game, the Giants D was gassed from rushing up field all day trying to sack him in the pocket. I thought they should have gotten Plaxico since they knew Cooper their tallest receiver was not going to be ready for half the season. It would have helped in the red zone. — Jsfulmore1
- "Rewind" "Second thought"
Don't need any further ANALysis at all. Just can't keep giving the ball away!
GOOD GRIEF! Is there something unfathomable about that idea?— BEMiller - Celek...watch the replay, Steelers knew his routes, and Eagles did not adjust. There were plenty of holes for Celek to slip into open if he adjusted the route.— camasbud
