Sam Donnellon: World Series shows it's about time for a timeout on all the timeouts

share
email
print
reprint
font size
comments
52
options
 

Sam Donnellon: World Series shows it's about time for a timeout on all the timeouts

AMID A WORLD SERIES in which records have been threatened, tied and broken, one possible milestone slipped through unnoticed the other night.

An umpire was cheered. Heartily.

Goren
Goren

As Cliff Lee placed his glove in front of his face and began his windup to start the seventh inning of Monday's Game 5, Yankees catcher Jorge Posada raised his hand to ask for time and stepped from the batter's box. The pitch hit the strike zone, home plate umpire Dana Demuth signaled strike and the Citizens Bank Park crowd of 46,178 bellowed a lusty approval.

No one is quite sure when an umpire was last cheered in this manner in a World Series, or whether it had ever happened before at all. No one is quite sure what the World Series record for trips to the mound is either, only that it is annoyingly clear that Posada has eclipsed the single-inning mark, the single-game mark, and already must own the record for the most trips to the mound for a World Series.

And that's counting when they played nine games back in the day.

"I do believe it's a concern on the part of baseball," Fox Sports president and executive producer Ed Goren said yesterday from New York. "I've been around enough baseball people recently to know there is frustration there."

Before I go any further let me say this: Jorge Posada has every right to call as many timeouts he feels he needs to get his signals straight, settle down his pitchers, discuss strategy. Honestly, if you're a Phillies fan, don't you wish Carlos Ruiz had called time on Sunday to discuss covering third base?

Posada is playing by the rules, which is to say there is no rule that limits a catcher's trips to the mound, a second baseman's trips to the mound, even a rightfielder's trips to the mound. A manager or coach can visit the mound once an inning before he must change pitchers, but any of the nine guys on the field can ask for a timeout any time they want, as many times as they want.

In other words, Andy Reid and Donovan McNabb would love this league.

There are a whole lot of reasons for doing this, of course, which the Yankees catcher and his pitching coach are quick to point out. To calm a pitcher down. To go over signs, change them if there is even the thought that the other team is stealing them, which there allegedly is with the Phillies.

And then there is this one, offered after Sunday's game by Dave Eiland, the Yankees pitching coach.

"Sometimes it's a momentum-breaker," he said. "If we feel like they have the momentum we kind of want to take a little momentum timeout and stop it and regroup, and I want to make sure the pitcher's mind is right."

This is so unfair on so many levels. The other night, with two men on, two out, Posada went out to the mound four times with Jayson Werth at the plate. He went to the mound a total of eight times that inning.

Werth stood and waited each time, finally striking out on a 2-2 pitch well out of the strike zone, quashing a Phillies' rally.

Was Werth affected? Probably. Is that fair play? Probably not. Batters don't get the same opportunity. After a few seconds, they are told to step back in. If they call time too often, they suffer the fate Posada did the other night.

Eiland argued that restricting such timeouts would "take away the beauty of the game," but Demuth's called strike on Posada was not about art appreciation. Quite the contrary.

Eiland also said this: "There's no rules against it, and I don't see any rules changing for that. That would be ridiculous."

Really, ridiculous is subjecting fans, both at home and in the park, to such delays - especially on 48-degree nights. Reflecting the blissful ignorance of so many in the game as to who pays their wages, Eiland said, "Don't take 3 minutes between innings. You know how many times a pitcher is standing on the mound waiting for the umpire's call to throw the first pitch?"

Yes. But does he know how many years of his salary the revenue from one of those minutes represents?

Those trips to the mound? They cost the game. If you listen close, you can hear the sound of remote controls across this great land.

Goren treads carefully here. He insists Fox will not pressure baseball to fix this in the offseason, that, "It's their game, we cover sports." But the length of games, he said, which has averaged a humane 3 hours, 25 minutes so far this series, "is an issue for us.

"It's why we moved the start times to 7:57. Because of longer and longer games that were going on to midnight and beyond."

Mike Port, Major League Baseball's vice president of umpiring, told the Associated Press that mound meetings would be a topic among baseball officials this offseason. And that was before Posada wore out the grass between home and the mound in Game 4.

In the meantime, it might be helpful to keep a crossword puzzle handy.

And - crazy as it sounds - be thankful for umpires like Demuth.

Send e-mail to

donnels@phillynews.com.

For recent columns, go to

http://go.philly.com/donnellon.

share
email
print
reprint
font size
options
 
52
Comments   
Posted 05:58 AM, 11/04/2009
Rotcod
I didn't like it either but I'm not whining about it. And I assuredly do NOT have any crossword puzzles handy. I'm watching the Phillies in the World Series!!
Posted 06:50 AM, 11/04/2009
Scorekeeper
I hate it, it isn't fair, but I wonder if I'd be so annoyed if it was my team doing it to go up 3-2 in the World Series.
Posted 06:58 AM, 11/04/2009
scorpio27
This is really in the hands of the umpires.In baseball, you can't "call" time, you have to ask for time. Like the saying goes, "Just say NO".
Posted 07:24 AM, 11/04/2009
LI PhilPhan
Games are getting painful to watch. Watching Pettitte pitch is like watching paint dry.
Posted 07:40 AM, 11/04/2009
Living_Legend
Human rain delay revisited. 1st A-Roid AB Ruiz should talk 2 Pedro after each pitch, drag it out a bit.
Posted 07:51 AM, 11/04/2009
Neal Obstat
The extra time between innings during the playoffs and World Series has got to go too. I know, it's about money. Everything is always about money.
Posted 08:12 AM, 11/04/2009
zdog
Bottom line,this is being done as an advantage for the pitcher, and has to stop. I heard the excuse about the Phillies stealing signs. Regardless, all teams have different sets of indicators and signals if that's the case. Just check out how Moyer gets his signals from Ruiz..it doesn't even involve putting down ANY fingers. Speaking of which, I've got one finger for the Yankees. Guess which one?
Posted 08:15 AM, 11/04/2009
BradCiav
By the way, during that Werth strikeout, Posada was definitely trying to break momentum. There was even a time when he showed no sign whatsoever. Even Joe Buck mentioned it. Then he went to the mound and he and the pither were laughing about it. Sure enough it worked as Werth struckout. I wonder if the book on Werth is to make a lot of trips to the mound to throw off his concentration. Cheap tactics if you ask me. Figures since it's the Yankees.
Posted 08:18 AM, 11/04/2009
moramike
Good point Neal. Fox isn't complaining about the time between innings are they? That's because that's where they are making their money. As for the home plate ump, Posada called time-out well before the wind-up started and that was just one more bad decision by Demuth who displayed many of them with his inconsistent strike zone.
Posted 08:25 AM, 11/04/2009
funnystuff
All I kmnow if the phils were doing it the yankees would be in fetal position at home plate sucking their thumbs screaming like a 3 month old with a dirty diaper. Posada has been doing this all year long and then doesn't even have the balls to admit it, he tries the 'phils are stealing signs'. Yeah posada the phils have been stealing signs for all of your 162 games this year. What else can we expect out of a talentless overpaid new yorker who spends most of his time on his knees.
Posted 08:44 AM, 11/04/2009
longshanks
Oh stop it. All teams do it. What else will we cry about? Every team in the league does this, especially in the playoffs and World Series. The Phillies do it too and can take as many trips to the mound as they want. It's Charlie and Rich's fault that they didn't slow more of these games down like the Yankees did. Stop blaming the Yankees you all sound like a bunch of little bellyaching children. Also stop whining about the strike zone, both teams have gotten questionable calls. It is what it is. The better team will win. Get over it and grow up.
Posted 08:47 AM, 11/04/2009
iladelph
There is no rule that says you cannot hit the opposing team's pitcher. But it doesn't happen because it is an unwritten rule that players RESPECTFULLY follow. There is no rule that says you cannot steal a base when leading by 8 runs in the 8th inning. But it does not happen because it is an unwritten rule that players RESPECTFULLY follow.
Posted 08:54 AM, 11/04/2009
DR Heller
Baseball is timeless. Like a diamond that it is played on. Keep it that way!
Comment removed.
Posted 09:00 AM, 11/04/2009
thefonz37
moramike: The ump doesn't have to give him a time-out, as a previous poster mentioned. Players have to ask for time and the ump is within his rights to say no. Posada had just had a time on the previous pitch attempt as well, not 10 secs earlier. He was clearly just trying to delay the game and throw off Lee's timing. I applaud Demuth for his call.
  • HEADLINES
  • POPULAR
  • BLOGS
Sign up to receive the daily sports newsletter