Posted: Monday, September 22, 2008, 12:46 PM | 23 comments |
 
options
 

Should the Eagles sit Brian Westbrook or play him Sunday against the Bears?
Play him. They're just not the same team without him.
Sit him. It's a long season, why risk further injury?
Wait and see how he feels later in the week.

Brian Westbrook was limping around the Eagles practice facility Monday morning, but without the crutches that he used to exit the Linc on Sunday night following the ankle strain he suffered in the win over the Steelers, Eagles coach Andy Reid said.

Westbrook was injured early in the second quarter when he fell awkwardly over offensive tackle Tra Thomas.

It will be "a race to get him ready for Sunday," Reid said at his day-after news conference.

"We'll see how he does. It is literally a day-to-day situation," Reid added.

Reid said an MRI exam this morning revealed a strain but nothing torn or damanged in the ankle.

"I think we can manage it," Reid said.

Westbrook will likely spend a lot of time in the training room this week in an effort to be ready for the game at Chicago on Sunday night. If he cannot play, Correll Buckhalter would be the starter.

Reid said he expected fullback Tony Hunt, who suffered a concussion, to be ready. Reid said that means the Eagles are not looking to make a roster move. (Reno Mahe fans are inconsolable. Film at 11.)

Quarterback Donovan McNabb also had an MRI that revealed a contusion on his upper chest. Reid indicated he thinks McNabb will be less sore as the week continues, and will play in Chicago.

Wide receiver Kevin Curtis (sports hernia surgery) will get a "little work this week," Reid said, as Curtis attempts to recover from a sports hernia. He will work on the scout team initially. "We'll see how he feels after that."

Guard Shawn Andrews remains sidelined with back spasms. Reid said Andrews' condition will be a "day-to-day situation." But Reid acknowledged that Andrews doesn't feel much better than he felt when he was injured last Monday night at Dallas, so Max Jean-Gilles could be looking at a second successive start this week.

Reid did not have a report on tight end L.J. Smith's back injury. He said Smith was "in the process of getting it checked."

*

As Eagles fans everywhere await word on the status of Brian Westbrook's injury ankle, the one statistic that stands out is this: 3-4.

That is the Eagles' record since in games that Westbrook has not played because of injury since he became the starter in 2004. His replacements have included Dorsey Levens, Ryan Moats, Bruce Perry and Correll Buckhalter.

The good news is that Buckhalter had the most successful turn as a replacement with 103 yards on 17 carries in a loss to the Giants last September. That game, of course, will be remembered less for anything that happened in the running game and more for the nearly dozen sacks that Donovan McNabb endured (Winston Justice, anyone?).

That things get much tougher should Westbrook be out for an extended period goes without saying. Week after week, you hear opposing players talk about Westbrook as the most important player on the Eagles offense. No matter how much depth you try to build when assembling your team, an injury to a star player is often the difference between success and failure.

So, Westbrook waits, the Eagles wait and so do all Eagles fans ...

Posted by Daily News staff @ 12:46 PM  Permalink | 23 comments
23
Comments   
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 9:14 AM, 09/22/2008
    Initially diagnosed as an ankle strain including negative xrays...obviously the MRI will reveal more today, so if the MRI is negative (I am crossing my fingers), I would hope to see Westbrook back on the field after the bye week...Eagles record during those 3 games without him will be 2 - 1.
    joey2times
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 10:23 AM, 09/22/2008
    Sam Donellon picked the Eagles to be 7-9 this year.
    rockinrob
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 10:32 AM, 09/22/2008
    worried about buckhalter blocking. he was responsible for at least 2 of those sacks in the giants game last year. he wiffed yesterday and mcnabb was sacked. booker was also responsible for a hit on mcnabb yesterday. westbrook is one of the best blocking rb's in the league. it's a huge loss in so many aspects of the game.
    mikeb
  • Comment removed.
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 11:59 AM, 09/22/2008
    I appreciate McNabb's willingness to play with pain, but the type of injury sustained in Sunday's game should have put him on the sidlines for the remainder. The Eagles are still in desperate need of a Fullback who can block. Their running game will continue to suffer until that is accomplished. Without a stellar defensive effort yesterday, I doubt the Eagles would have won. You have to be able to run the ball to hold the lead and eat the clock. Trading touchdowns doesn't work in the long-run, ie Dallas!
    empiricist
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 12:25 PM, 09/22/2008
    Well it could have been worse. I'm really worried about BWest. He's my boy and I want him to be okay and healthy.
    bd1979
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 12:55 PM, 09/22/2008
    The Birds owe the BEars after last year's home loss. Even w/o BWest, no way we lose this game.
    Bake McBride
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 12:57 PM, 09/22/2008
    BREAKING NEWS!!! Westbrook listed as day to day...an MRI this morning revealed no ligament damage and xrays yesterday revealed no fracture...this is a great sign that we could see Westbrook back on the field sooner rather then later.
    joey2times
  • Comment removed.
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 1:08 PM, 09/22/2008
    empericist seems to have nailed it. Buck is adequate for running and catching passes, but his blocking is not up to snuff. Booker is just a disaster on blocking, and my grandson(14) could take him down with an arm tackle. Having said that, I would rather see B-West not go if it means his ankle would get worse with the playing time. Let him heal up .
    TBear
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 1:16 PM, 09/22/2008
    Can Klecko go back to fullback if Hunt cant go?
    TomEBoy
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 1:59 PM, 09/22/2008
    Sit him against the bears. The Eagles D will score more TD then the Bears O!!!!
    cusoraider
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 2:05 PM, 09/22/2008
    Injuries to McNabb and Westbrook are serious, no doubt, but a lot of folks were spelling doom for the Eagles vs. Steelers earlier in the week and I thought they acquitted themselves very well, given what they were up against. Say what you will about Andy's in-game management (he's mediocre at best) but he gets his people ready to play as well as anyone. I like the Igs on Sunday, and I think this is a better team than most expected. I'm looking forward to the rest of the season.
    andrewfrombrooklyn
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 2:28 PM, 09/22/2008
    Not worried about the Bears. Our "D" will eat them for lunch.
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 2:28 PM, 09/22/2008
    Empiricist said:(Without a stellar defensive effort yesterday, I doubt the Eagles would have won. You have to be able to run the ball to hold the lead and eat the clock. Trading touchdowns doesn't work in the long-run, ie Dallas!) Andy Reid himself said that he toned things down on offense in the second half. Do you really think that if the D wasn't playing as well as they were, he would have done the same? Besides...we did win! So your point is moot.
    extremebeat


View comments: 1  |  2
About Eagletarian Blog
Les BowenLes Bowen has covered the Eagles for the Daily News since 2002. Before that, he spent nearly 13 years covering the Flyers. It took Les only a few seasons after the switch to figure out that there was no penalty box at the Linc, and that the time really wasn't his, despite what Andy Reid kept saying. Les came to Philadelphia and the Daily News from Charlotte in 1983. In the intervening years, he has pretty much lost track of NASCAR, and his accent. He, his wife Barbara, and their two sons live in Haddon Township, New Jersey. E-mail Les at bowenl@phillynews.com and follow him on Twitter.

Paul DomowitchPaul Domowitch has been with the Daily News since 1982. He has spent most of his nearly 3 decades with the paper covering the Eagles and pro football. For the last 10 years, he’s been a selector for the Pro Football Hall of Fame. A native of Wilkes-Barre and a graduate of Wilkes University, Domo started his career in Texas, working first for the Midland Reporter-Telegram (1976-78), and then for the Fort Worth Star-Telegram, where he covered some god-awful Texas Ranger baseball teams. His first beat at the Daily News actually was boxing, which he covered just long enough to lose 2 sports coats to blood spatter before moving on to football. Domo and his wife Shelley, a University of Oklahoma grad who still hasn’t gotten over that Fiesta Bowl loss to Boise State 5 years ago, have 2 terrific daughters -- Allison, 28, who is an attorney in South Jersey, and Amy, 25, who works in administration for a professional baseball team. E-mail Domo at PDomo@aol.com and follow him on Twitter.

Download our iPhone/Android app for even more Birds coverage, including app-exclusive videos and analysis. Get it here for iPhone or here for Android.

Join on Facebook   

Latest Eagles Videos