share
email
font size
options
 
Thursday, April 16, 2009
Blog Image

The way the Cardinals tell it, they haven't just this week decided to listen to trade offers for receiver Anquan Boldin. They just decided to tell the world they are listening.

Why? Well, they appear to be tiring of the unhappy act they keep getting from Boldin and agent Drew Rosenhaus. Boldin is signed for two more seasons -- at a total of $5.75 million -- but puts his uniform pants on one leg at a time next to Larry Fitzgerald, who makes $10 million a season.

As the coach and general manager point out in the story from the Arizona Republic, their preference is to keep Boldin, but recognize that making him happy might not be possible.

The team has more pressing contract extensions to complete with linebacker Karlos Dansby and strong safety Adrian Wilson, and just shelled out a $15 million signing bonus to quarterback Kurt Warner. Even if the Cards wanted to make Boldin a very rich man, they might not have the cash lying around. Or so they intimate.

What would it cost for another team to lift Boldin from the Cards? He turns 29 in October and has something of an injury history, playing a full 16-game schedule just twice in his six NFL seasons. Last year, if it matters, he also criticized the team and the coach and got into a sideline squabble with the offensive coordinator during the conference championship game against the Eagles, and departed the stadium before celebrating with his teammates. Perhaps that's all a product of the contract unhappiness and would disappear in a new setting with a new deal. Perhaps.

What would it cost? Beat writer Kent Somers, who is very plugged in out there, guesstimated in his blog that a first-round and a third-round pick would probably satisfy the Cardinals. Taking that at face value, would the Eagles make that deal? They hold two first-round picks and 12 draft picks overall, and fully admit they don't intend to use all those picks themselves.

If they did make the trade, they would have to do the contract upgrade, putting Boldin in that 4-year/$40 million range he's seeking. That could have a domino effect on the contract status of Donovan McNabb, who also has two years left on his deal and might think he'd be in line for a bump from the organization before an outsider gets one.

So, do you make the deal for a first and a third to get Boldin? Your thoughts.

Posted by BOB FORD @ 9:48 AM  Permalink | 159 comments
159
Comments   
Posted 10:00 AM, 04/16/2009
Bama
NO. Boldin is not in Fitzgerald's class. He's not worth a first and a third or the $10 million/year.
Posted 10:04 AM, 04/16/2009
cmccdin
No, He can't play 16 games/per yr and he's only getting older. I'd rather take my chances drafting a receiver like Nicks or Britt. A 1st and a 3rd is just to high for a soon to be 29 yr old player with attitude problems.
Posted 10:05 AM, 04/16/2009
cduran1229
Do it. This guy is a top wideout. He'll help open up this offense. Curtis, Jackson, Celek and Westbrook would all benefit from Boldin's ability. They would still be able to go OL in the first round. If they plan on using Herramans or Andrews at LT, they could draft Alex Mack. If they think they need a LT, Oher or Britton may be there. Second round pick on the Liberty RB or try and move up to get Donald Brown. Use your fourth on Pat White or PSU Williams to replace D Jax as your return guy.
Posted 10:06 AM, 04/16/2009
MichaelB
Yes, you do.
Posted 10:11 AM, 04/16/2009
maximus
if boldin is given the contract and mcnabb is upset, trade mcnabb. Im tired of hearing about these children wearing helmuts.
Posted 10:12 AM, 04/16/2009
Arctic16
No way. Totally not worth it. For a 1st and a 3rd I'd rather get Braylon Edwards.
Posted 10:13 AM, 04/16/2009
peteike
He does not have attitude problems, yall are crazy not to want him on our team, would hate to see him on gmen. He would be a huuuuge pickup if you add him with Jackson, Avant and Curtis and McNabb finally has a bevy of weapons. Draft picks are complete guesses anyway and I never understand in the NFL how trades seem cheap in comparison to rolling the dice on draft picks especially on a rec. Good luck guessing which rec to draft. Even Crabtree is an unknown based on the O he ran in college.
Posted 10:14 AM, 04/16/2009
PhillyPhantastico
As I posted before, this is what SI said about Boldin last month: For as productive as Boldin has been throughout his career, it appears he is a descending player at this stage of his career. Boldin's average yards per catch dropped down to 11.7 in 2008, and his number of big plays has steadily declined during each of the past three seasons. His 10 receptions over 20 yards are a career low, and he finished the season with only three 100-yard games. Though some of Boldin's statistical drop can be attributed to the emergence of Pro Bowl wideout Larry Fitzgerald, and to the fact Boldin missed four games due to injury in '08, his declining production raises red flags, and forces you to take a closer look at his skill set in relation to other elite receivers. While Boldin is widely regarded as one of the game's toughest and most physical players at the position, the strength of his game revolves around his ability to make things happen with the ball in his hands. He is an outstanding runner who has the ability to turn short passes into big gains due to his toughness and power. However, he lacks elite speed and isn't explosive enough to run past defenders on vertical routes. Thus, defensive coordinators are not obligated to pay special attention to Boldin with bracket or double coverage. A No. 1 receiver is judged by his ability to warrant double coverage, and Boldin doesn't garner that consideration on a consistent basis in Arizona. Opponents opt to roll their coverage to Fitzgerald and are willing to roll the dice when facing Boldin in single coverage.
Posted 10:14 AM, 04/16/2009
Joyner80
What Eagles fan in their right mind thinks we won;t have to overpay for the #1 WR we been screaming for? I would give up a 1st & 4th for Boldin easy. And that's overpaying enough. But if Braylon is commanding a 2nd + 5th, then Boldin should require much more than that.
Posted 10:15 AM, 04/16/2009
The Roz
I say we go for it, we do not have a good history of drafting WR's, Desean turned out great but everyone else has been a bust or sub par
Posted 10:16 AM, 04/16/2009
joe$
Tough call. I think you do it for a couple of reasons. It would make 5 happy and squash any QB "controversy". I would make their red zone offense infinitely better. Curtis in the slot and Jackson at #2 makes both of them more effective. It would also keep him away from the Giants. They could then still use their other #1 on a RB or OT.
Posted 10:18 AM, 04/16/2009
PAPOOSE
Come on guys i'm starting to think this team will never change the best season they ever had was in 2004 you would think they would try to go back and try to duplicate what they did that year and whats the difference wr the threat of the big play in the passing game this whole thing is mind boggling and you need a backup rb i just dont wont a ok football team how about being a great football team for a change.
Posted 10:25 AM, 04/16/2009
PAPOOSE
Yes get Boldin or Edwards i rather do that then spend money on a unproven rookie you know what Boldin and Edwards bring to the table remember Jerome Mcdougle and Winston Justice.
Posted 10:26 AM, 04/16/2009
horhey
Just what the Eagles need...another head case who wears #81 - let's get Todd Stinkson back here so we can appease Donovan.
Posted 10:28 AM, 04/16/2009
Eagle GREEN Mt State
The Eagles should start with a 1 and a 5 and Reggie Brown or Jason Avant. Hate to give up Avant but he would probable be a good fit in AZ a #3 WR. This would allow the Eagles to keep their 3rd rounder and thus draft RB, TE, and OL with their first three picks. My preference would be to get Pettigrew in the 1st, trade up in the second to get Alex Mack (ship Jamal Jackson out of town) and a RB in the 3rd. By all accounts this draft is deep at the RB position.
Latest Sports Videos
About Bob Ford
Bob Ford has been writing about Philadelphia sports since 1981, and is still trying to figure it all out. A former beat writer covering the Phillies and the 76ers, Ford became a general sports columnist for the Inquirer in 2003, following in and occasionally falling in the deep footsteps of Bill Lyon, Frank Dolson and many distinguished others. He comes to the Philly.com blogosphere after award-winning success as designer/editor of the fabulous Pen & Pencil Club softball blog. Likes: Palestra, inside-the-park home runs, sunny days. Dislikes: phony people, cloudy days, rewrites.