It was a misunderstanding, not a dustup, Myers and Hamels say

share
email
print
reprint
font size
comments
18
options
 

It was a misunderstanding, not a dustup, Myers and Hamels say

NEW YORK - There was no confrontation between Brett Myers and Cole Hamels after Game 5 of the World Series, according to Myers, Hamels, and several witnesses.

"There's no problem," Hamels told The Inquirer from aboard the Amtrak train that carried the Phillies to New York yesterday afternoon. "There's never been a problem."

Cole Hamels arrives at Penn Station in New York after the team took the train from Philadelphia yesterday. He and Brett Myers denied arguing.
JASON DeCROW / Associated Press
Cole Hamels arrives at Penn Station in New York after the team took the train from Philadelphia yesterday. He and Brett Myers denied arguing.

An Internet report early yesterday morning suggested that Hamels and Myers had a clubhouse confrontation after Game 5 on Monday night.

Both Phillies pitchers - and other eyewitnesses - said that reports of tension were greatly exaggerated.

Fox Sports' Ken Rosenthal witnessed the nonevent, and wrote an account that supported the players' version.

"I saw the whole thing," Rosenthal wrote. "I was standing maybe five feet away. I thought Myers was joking, and did not even consider writing about it in my accompanying column about Hamels."

"There was no confrontation whatsoever," Myers told The Inquirer yesterday morning.

The Phillies' director of baseball communications, Greg Casterioto, said he saw the entire exchange. He called the idea of tension between Myers and Hamels "ludicrous."

Hamels admitted that a Myers comment initially struck a nerve. But Hamels went on to say that he later realized that it was an innocent comment, and there were no hard feelings between the two teammates and friends.

"We're always joking around, always laughing with each other at the field or when we ride in together," Hamels said. "We're a couple of wiseasses. We're having dinner tonight."

Hamels had drawn criticism for a comment that he made after taking the loss in Game 3 of the World Series on Saturday. After that game, he talked about wanting a chance to redeem himself in Game 7, if the Series extended that far. Hamels explained that he was eager for a chance to end a season that had been personally disappointing with a good feeling.

He was then asked: "You talked about the possibility of a Game 7 leaving you with a good feeling. If this ended up being your last start, with the way this whole season has gone, what feeling would you be left with?"

The pitcher answered: "I can't wait for it to end. It's been mentally draining. At year's end, you just can't wait for a fresh start."

Hamels' comments did not play well with the public. He was criticized for giving up on his team in the middle of the World Series.

Hamels later said that he chose his words poorly, that he wished he had answered the question differently. However, he has maintained that his comments related specifically to his personal struggles and were taken out of context. Reporters at the interview, such as Leslie Gudel of Comcast SportsNet, also have said the comments were taken out of context. Hamels never said he was quitting on the season.

Enter Myers after Game 5. Hamels said he was preparing to meet with manager Charlie Manuel to explain his post-Game 3 comments when Myers walked by and said: "I thought you quit."

That expression, Myers and Hamels said, is Phillies clubhouse code for "I thought you had left for the night."

Hamels, his emotions raw after being criticized for his remarks after Game 3 and not sleeping well after the fallout, said he did not immediately make the right translation.

"He thought I left. He said, 'I thought you quit,' " said Hamels, who responded to Myers with a profanity. "He didn't know what had been in the papers. It was a random coincidence. It's what he says every day, but because of the situation, it hit a nerve. He totally apologized. He said the wrong thing at the wrong time. He had no idea what was going on."

Myers said he was unaware of Hamels' comments two days earlier. "I had no idea there was even a story going around about this," he said. "We're friends. There is no problem."

Moments later, Myers "apologized and we were laughing," Hamels said. "He didn't mean anything by it."

Manuel brushed off the incident yesterday.

"That was Brett being Brett," he said. "He likes throwing that jab. They're friends.'"

Hamels and Myers often share a ride to the ballpark.

"I called him this morning to see if he wanted a ride," Hamels said. "He already had one. I think our wives are going to New York together.

"We're good friends. We understand each other well. We were both young guys who came out of high school and got up here quick. We both had some success and some struggles. We can really relate to each other."

Hamels laughed.

"And we've both been in bar fights," he said.

Hamels said he was not amused by the events of this week.

"It shows you how people will believe whatever they hear," he said. "It's not amusing. I don't want to be the guy who takes away from the team. I don't want to be the guy in the spotlight. We have an amazing team. That's what should be in the spotlight."

Hamels said that the possibility of starting Game 7 did not come up in his chat with Manuel after Game 5. The lefthander said he wanted to explain the remarks he made after Game 3 to his manager.

"It was about my character," Hamels said.

As for the possibility of pitching a seventh game?

"Of course I want it," he said. "It would be a great opportunity. It's something you live for, to be the deciding factor. But first we have to win Game 6. Nobody will be rooting harder than me."

 


Contact staff writer Andy Martino at 215-854-4874 or amartino@phillynews.com.

 

share
email
print
reprint
font size
options
 
18
Comments   
Posted 05:50 AM, 11/04/2009
dfrancis1958
nice job of SOMEONE IN THE MEDIA, totally blowing something out of porportion
Posted 07:54 AM, 11/04/2009
Russ
Probably blown out of proportion to create dissent and foment trouble in the Phillies clubhouse. Stay focused, Phillies, ignore all this noise and go out and win game 6.
Posted 08:06 AM, 11/04/2009
iladelph
The Media's attempt to write off Hamels backfired. WHEN Game 7 does happen Hamels will get the W.
Posted 08:12 AM, 11/04/2009
SayHello2MyLittleFriend
Andy Martino, a Yankee$ fan continues to work this story. Hey Andy, if you keep writing about it, maybe it will become true. NOT!!!
Posted 08:20 AM, 11/04/2009
kjuggs77
Winning cures all...
Posted 08:25 AM, 11/04/2009
Kenny Junod
thw wifebeater is quite the pranster
Posted 09:05 AM, 11/04/2009
The Pack Leader
Anyone else think that Myers might be a negative influence on Cole? Perhaps spending more time with Clifton or J.A. would do him some good...
Posted 09:16 AM, 11/04/2009
montco1
Hey, a Phillies version of the "Odd Couple". Go Phils.
Posted 09:24 AM, 11/04/2009
JRadek
And Mr Junod is quite the speller....
Posted 09:39 AM, 11/04/2009
furio
I wouldn't mind having Brett punch Kenny J right in the face
Posted 09:41 AM, 11/04/2009
taylor/rojas/callison/allen
Stop the hype on Cole Hamels. He is only 25 and has the ability to be a good pitcher for the Phillies for a long time. All this focus and challenge of his temperment, mental toughness, and manhood is unwarranted - he pitched brilliantly in the 2008 post-season. If you or I were under this scrutiny at age 25 most of us would have blown up or run for cover. I don't want to chase Cole out of town like we did to others.
Posted 09:52 AM, 11/04/2009
Palestra Jon
Actually, this makes clear that the original Yahoo Sports report was true. Cole admitted here that the comment "struck a nerve." The first Inquirer story said the dustup report was totally false. Clearly, Hamels said something to Myers and it was not appreciative. It may not mean anything in the long run---players often have tiffs in clubhouses, but there is no reason to criticize the original report. That is bad journalism.
Posted 10:12 AM, 11/04/2009
neddyflanders
The guys wife is playing around with his head.
Posted 11:46 AM, 11/04/2009
76er
I was a misunderstanding, but it did occur. Some of the Philadelphia journalists have become all too close with the players and PR guy Greg C. So they donwplay something that actually did happen.
Posted 11:56 AM, 11/04/2009
KGKoons
It could be that next season, these friends will be parted because Brett might not be back but Cole will be after some deep emotional counseling! LOL
Latest Sports Videos
Sign up to receive the daily sports newsletter