Hit mars Flyers' 5-1 victory over Panthers

share
email
print
reprint
font size
comments
29
options
 

Captain Mike Richards received a game misconduct for a shoulder-to-jaw hit that sent David Booth to the hospital last night, casting a cloud on the Flyers' 5-1 win over the Florida Panthers at the Wachovia Center.

The suddenly explosive Arron Asham, who collected a goal for a career-best third consecutive game; Danny Briere (two goals, assist); Simon Gagne; and rookie James van Riemsdyk scored for the Flyers.

Help from the bench is requested as David Booth of the Panthers lies on the ice as a result of a shoulder check to his jaw. The hit was believed to have caused a concussion, and the teams disagreed on whether the blow was clean.
MATT SLOCUM / Associated Press
Help from the bench is requested as David Booth of the Panthers lies on the ice as a result of a shoulder check to his jaw. The hit was believed to have caused a concussion, and the teams disagreed on whether the blow was clean.

Van Riemsdyk's goal - he scored on a late breakaway by putting a backhander through the legs of goalie Tomas Vokoun - was the first of his blossoming NHL career.

But after the game, the focus was on Booth, a 24-year-old left winger who had tied the game, 1-1, with a first-period goal before being injured with 2 minutes, 55 seconds remaining in the second period.

Florida general manager Randy Sexton said that there was no injury to Booth's neck, and that the player would stay overnight for observation at Pennsylvania Hospital.

Booth had feelings in his extremities, said Florida coach Peter DeBoer, adding that the player had been unconscious on the ice.

After carrying the puck into the Flyers' zone, Booth made a pass and was jolted by Richards.

Booth lay motionless on the ice, and there was a seven-minute delay. After getting attention from both teams' medical staffs, he was gingerly placed on a stretcher, having suffered what is believed to be a concussion. As he was removed from the ice, Booth received a tap of encouragement from the Flyers' Chris Pronger and some of his Florida teammates.

The NHL will review the hit, and Richards could be suspended for a few games. The league will concentrate on whether Richards left his feet to deliver the hit. If the league deems he did, he will undoubtedly be suspended.

Flyers general manager Paul Holmgren said that it was a clean hit, that Richards should not be suspended, and that he left his feet only after the collision, not before it.

Sexton disagreed, saying "there is no place" in hockey for the blow that was delivered.

"The league wants to get rid of these shots to the head," he told a Miami Herald reporter.

"It's unfortunate the kid got hurt there . . . but Mike Richards is not a dirty player. He doesn't try to hurt people," Flyers coach John Stevens said. "He was backchecking through the middle, and he has as much integrity as anybody playing the game."

"Everything happened so quickly, it's kind of hard to explain," Richards said. "Obviously, I was not trying to hurt him. I was trying to separate him from the puck, but he moved."

Florida defenseman Keith Ballard was irate over the hit.

"The thing with Mike Richards is he's a good, honest player. He plays hard, but he does bleep like that," he said. "He's done it before . . .. It's a split-second decision, but it's a decision that's been made several times now."

For the first time this season, Briere was playing alongside two big-bodied players, van Riemsdyk and Jeff Carter (11 shots, two assists).

"They are two guys that take a lot of pucks to the net and shoot a lot," Briere said. "I told them to keep doing what they are doing, and I'm going to try and find the loose pucks."

Early in the second period, Asham swatted a bouncing puck past Vokoun to give the Flyers a 2-1 lead. Gagne scored his first goal of the season with 3:58 left in the second period, collecting a rebound off a Richards shot and lifting it over a prone Vokoun on the power play to make it 3-1.

"When you score the first one, you feel like you're back," Gagne said. "You feel like you are able to do a little bit more on the ice. You feel a bit more in control of yourself."

About a minute after Gagne's power-play goal, Richards flattened Booth.

Briere's second goal of the night, a power-play score after a great pass from Scott Hartnell, made it 4-1 with 14:57 left. That came after the Flyers killed a five-on-three Florida power play that lasted for nearly two minutes.

Van Riemsdyk closed the scoring with his historic goal with 2:59 to go. The impressive rookie has seven points in six games.

Pronger had eight blocked shots last night.

 


Contact staff writer Sam Carchidi at 215-854-5181 or scarchidi@phillynews.com.

 


 

share
email
print
reprint
font size
options
 
29
Comments   
Posted 03:59 AM, 10/25/2009
FlyersFan88
Man, I don't know about that hit...see, I guess if you're a Florida fan, you're irritated. But I swear, to me, that hit looked like Booth was admiring his pass, cruising through the middle of the ice, and got crushed. Just like Eric Lindros used to do. I just didn't see that Richards left his feet, and I just thought the hit, while tough, was clean. Other than that: For the first time in a couple of weeks, I really liked how the Flyers played.
Posted 05:11 AM, 10/25/2009
frank martino
I agree with Flyers Fan88,I think Eric got hit with a cheap shot.
Posted 05:50 AM, 10/25/2009
Conshy04
I would expect Richard to get suspended for that...
Posted 07:08 AM, 10/25/2009
wojo255
Scott Stevens got into the HOF with hits like that mostly on Lindros
Posted 08:17 AM, 10/25/2009
Blueliner
I think that it is telling that the officials assessed an interference major. It means that they determined (correctly) that they could not call the hit an elbow or a charge. The interference call, however, was incorrect. NHL Rule 56 states, "The last player to touch the puck, other than the goalkeeper, shall be considered the player in possession. The player deemed in possession of the puck may be checked legally, provided the check is rendered immediately following his loss of possession." Richard hit Booth a split second after Booth released the pass, and before anyone else touched the puck. This was a clean hit that, unfortunately, resulted in an injury. This is the type of hit that would be up on "Hits" section of the NHL's "Plays of the Week" page had Booth not been injured.
Posted 08:39 AM, 10/25/2009
MBFlyerfan
This is yet another instance of the NHL punishing the result and not the hit.
Posted 08:39 AM, 10/25/2009
LarsMendte2
Take the dress off Nancy, this is the NHL.
Posted 08:56 AM, 10/25/2009
Big Ragu
Richards stinks.He should stick to making those horrible BMW commercials! Makes me NOT want to buy a Beemer.
Posted 09:07 AM, 10/25/2009
ritamb13
I predicty 3 game suspension. There was no specific intent to injure but the hit was a little over the top. 3 is the right number.
Posted 09:25 AM, 10/25/2009
joe_1974
The Panther's announcers kept saying Richards hit Booth in the head. If you look at the replay, Booth ran into Richards while Richards was chasing the puck. Richards braced for impact, it didn't look like he purposely threw an elbow. Too bad the NHL will have to suspend him now or Mothers across North America will be outraged.
Posted 09:28 AM, 10/25/2009
yescadog
I thought that was a questionable hit, however, he did not leave his feet to make the hit. Richards is one of my favorite players, but he probably deserves a one or two game suspension for it. On another note, the Flyers played a great team game...even though it was against Florida...it was still a nice win. They beat them like they were supposed to.
Posted 09:29 AM, 10/25/2009
freedomrider
I guess you can say I’m more of a Flyers fan than a hockey fan. But I know that football, hockey and boxing are collision sports. This is where intimidation is a part of the essence of the sport. And the Flyers are now a team of intimidation. I argued with a lot of my friend who called Scott Stevens hit on Eric Lindros and Damond Lankow cheap shots. But, I didn’t see it that way. What I saw was hockey being played the way it should be played. I thought Jersey’s Stevens and Buffalo’s Micheal Pecca were two of the NHL’s toughest hitters and I enjoyed watching them play their game. This Flyers team reminds me of the early 70s team and the Mike Keenan team of the 80’s. The penalty that was called on Mike Richards last night reminds me of the kind of penalty that was called in the 70s and 80s. It’s called a Flyer penalty! The fact is, the Panthers didn’t show up to play hocky, the Flyers did!
Posted 09:52 AM, 10/25/2009
lonewolf 11
MB Flyers fan - great point. The NHL definitely punishes the result more than the actual 'infraction.' In this case, watching it at full speed, Richards commits to the hit before Booth has gotten rid of the puck. And he doesn't leave his feet until after he has made contact. Therefore clean hit, no suspension warranted. But unfortunately the NHL doesn't live in our reality...
Posted 10:03 AM, 10/25/2009
Times Yours
There is no "right number" for a suspension on a clean hit. If the NHL wants to get it right, they need to call it like it is. This is a violent sport, and sometimes players get injured on legal hits. Richie is not a dirty player, and if the league chooses to suspend him, they will be putting a label on him that is not warranted.
Posted 10:08 AM, 10/25/2009
jak55555
I agree with wojo. These are EXACTLY the kind of hits that sent Scott Stevens to the HOF and made the Sports Center highlights everynight in a good way. Looks just like the famous 2000 hit on Lindros.
Latest Sports Videos
Sign up to receive the daily sports newsletter