Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH

Religion   

share
email
print
font size
options
 
READER FEEDBACK
Post a comment
RELATED STORIES
 
Stress on military therapists
 
Troubling picture of suspect in Ft. Hood shooting


Faith and furor

Muslims say Ft. Hood gunman does not define Islam.

WASHINGTON - The killings of 13 people at Fort Hood, Texas, allegedly by an Army psychiatrist who also was a Muslim, set off a rancorous debate that once again spotlighted the fear among Muslims in America that they would be collectively found guilty for the actions of one man.

Vitriolic exchanges filled Internet sites devoted to military affairs late last week, with some posters arguing that Muslims should be barred from the armed services.

News reporters deluged the Silver Spring, Md., mosque where the Fort Hood shooting suspect once worshipped, demanding to know what the Quran, Islam's holy book, had to say about such events. One asked if the suspect, Army Maj. Nidal Malik Hasan, who was born in Virginia and has lived his whole life in the United States, spoke with an "accent."

Anita Husseini, who also worships at the Muslim Community Center, said she didn't know Hasan, but she knew that what he was accused of doing would affect her life and those of others.

"My heart cried last night," said Husseini, a hairdresser. "Every time the Muslims try to get up, something goes boom and pushes us back. What a crazy person decides does not define me or Islam."

The mosque's chairman, Arshad Qureshi, said: "They're trying so hard to pin this on Islam. They're working so hard to make it about religion."

U.S. military officials said the motive behind Thursday's shooting remained unclear.

Investigators seized the suspect's computer after news reports said someone named Nidal Hasan had posted messages comparing suicide-bombing missions to Japanese kamikaze pilots.

Lt. Gen. Robert W. Cone, the base commander at Fort Hood, said witnesses to Thursday's mayhem reported that Hasan had shouted "Allahu akbar," or "God is great" in Arabic, as he opened fire on clusters of soldiers awaiting medical examinations and other processes.

The phrase is a traditional Muslim invocation.

Cone and others, however, turned away questions about Hasan's religion, and Cone said there was no evidence that Hasan was part of a wider plot.

There is no doubt within the military hierarchy about the loyalty of Muslim service members, said Maj. Gen. Kevin Bergner, a Pentagon spokesman. The military, he said, will take steps to make sure "everyone is treated with dignity and respect."

Posters to Facebook and participants in chat rooms and popular military sites Friday were less circumspect, revealing a bitterness that Muslims say they have often felt since the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001.

One Facebook page was titled "Against muslims in military! . . . or in presidency" - a reference to the false claims that President Obama is a Muslim.

Muslims make up less than 0.3 percent of America's active-duty military forces. Of the roughly 548,000 soldiers in the U.S. Army, 2,500 say they are Muslims, 1,500 of them on active duty.

By comparison, 105,000 claim Roman Catholicism as their religion, and 99,000 say they are Baptists. More than 1,800 soldiers say they are Jewish, surpassed by the nearly 2,500 who identify themselves as atheists.

More than 101,000 list no religious affiliation. That was the case with Hasan, according to Pentagon officials, though interviews at the Silver Spring mosque make clear he was an observant Muslim who prayed daily - and often in uniform.

Mona Ayad, the administrative assistant at the center, said Hasan would come to prayer quite often, volunteer at the mosque, contribute money for the poor as Islam requires, and answer phones. He stopped coming over the summer, apparently when he was transferred to Fort Hood.

Imam Mohamed Abdullahi Sheikh Mohamed, the mosque's chief cleric, said he knew Hasan from his frequent appearances at the mosque and knew he was a military doctor. But he said Hasan never brought up his work with the U.S. military.

Hasan's religious affiliation was known to his military colleagues and might have caused tensions. His family said he was harassed for his faith, and the Washington Post quoted his aunt Friday as saying Hasan sought legal help in an effort to get out of the Army.

One Army chaplain spoke on the condition of anonymity out of fear that an interview would turn Thursday's shooting into a religious issue.

The chaplain said that some Muslims are conflicted about honoring their duty while fighting other Muslims in Iraq and Afghanistan. In those cases, Muslim soldiers usually prefer talking to a Muslim chaplain, he said. They also more often turn to Muslim chaplains when they feel harassed in the military.

The chaplain said many of the soldiers he talked to felt betrayed mainly because Hasan is a fellow soldier.

"This is not a Muslim issue. It is a soldier issue," he said. "It is a punch in the gut."

In his Friday sermon, Mohamed paid his condolences to the families of those killed. He quoted a Quran verse that says taking one innocent life is like killing humankind.

Over loudspeakers, Mohamed said, "I ask the media people not to relate all the time everything to Islam."

 

Comments   
Posted 09:48 AM, 11/08/2009
dpsteven
This is sad and difficult.The killer...a doctor...was..is nuts. That is the only way to define someone trained to heal who would kill. The question for Islam..is whose flag does a muslum stand under..whose flag does a muslum fight for.Traditionally, nationality means less for a muslum than does relgion. Loyalty is defined by faith, not nationality. We see that whenever someone is caught spying for Israel. A jewish american who defines their religion as more important than their citizenship. Here , with Muslums, we see faith as soul defining in a way that permits a happy eternity when killing non believers. A bigger question happens with the DOCTOR. How did he get through medical school(four years) in seven years..and why? Was he working on a Masters in public health..if so..why did it take so long? Is this the future of american medicine. A government medical school where no one payed attention to WHOM they were teaching, a government internship, a government residency, a government clinic job, a government hospital privilages..and NO ONE paid attention to the man and what he was saying. In ANY private hospital,this man would have been sent to the well being committee and had his privilages suspended. I can't think of any case event where someone like this could have GRADUATED from a private medical school. Ah..now we have this man as an example of what happens when no one listens to what is in a persons heart, what is in a persons mind , or what the PERSON defines as his interpretaion of his religion(even if it has NOTHING to do with fact). THere are many Jim Jones in the world in all religions. There seems too many in islam.
Posted 10:52 AM, 11/08/2009
janann
The actions at Ft. Hood no more define Islam than the Mafia or the IRA define Catholicism. There will always be people (1210's Talk ONLY radio's Dom Giordano) who will make a living blaming Islam for everything,(at least until there is another priest scandal they can energize their base with). They know their base, and will demand Religious leaders to denounce, denounce,denounce. Nothing any of them do will be enough. And a bully with a microphone who how defends his country from an Armchair, when needed and was asked to serve the country he loves did the same thing as Tancredo, Limbaugh, Hannity, Lieberman, Boehner and Cheney..... they Hid in their Daddy's basement.
Posted 11:20 AM, 11/08/2009
bigeastbeast
There is no more Inquisition,but there is jihad.The Religion of Pieces has once again done it's thing.
Posted 11:30 AM, 11/08/2009
bartstorm
Muslims say Ft. Hood gunman does not define Islam. Ya. I believe ya.........
Posted 12:27 PM, 11/08/2009
haneefah22
NOW ME BEING A MUSLIM MYSELF, LETS LOOK AT THE BIG PICTURE HERE. IF YOU HAVE COMMENTED ON HERE AND YOU LIVE IN PHILLY OR SURROUDING AREAS WHERE THE MUSLIM POPULATION IS LARGE, I AM SURE YOU HAVE RAN ACROSS MANY MUSLIMS IN PHILLY WHO DIDNT BOTHER YOU. THEY DIDNT HAVE A BOMB STRAPPED TO THEM AND EVERYBODY HERE DOESNT WEAR GUARB MOST WOMEN WEAR THE HEAD SCARF WITH REGULAR CLOTHING!! BUT WITH ANY OTHER RELIGION YOU HAVE THE BAD APPLES!! WHITES HAVE BEEN KILLING BLACKS AND JEWS FOR CENTURIES!! THEN BURN CROSSES AND SREAM WHITE POWER IN THE PROCESS. WHO USE THE BIBLE TO JUSTIFY THEIR CLAIMS!! SO WHY ARENT ALL WHITE PEOPLE CATERGORIZED AS KKK MEMBERS?? BECAUSE THAT WOULD BE IGNROANT I KNOW ALL WHITE PEOPLE ARENT THE SAME!! AND ALL MUSLIMS ARENT EITHER!!
Posted 12:41 PM, 11/08/2009
CleanupPhilly
This is a laudable article in its intent, but is it accurate? Is it rather more what good people wish to be so, than what is borne out by recent events? In the US in 2009, there have been an unprecedented number of arrests of Muslims who are tied with attacks in the US. After a time, it's difficult to make the case that plotters who invoke the Koran and their Muslim faith as "lone wolves" who "don't represent" Islam. There was even a beheading of a woman who filed for divorce from her husband in NY, and both were founders of a TV station whose mission it was to counter negative stereotypes against Muslims. From Fort Dix to the recent arrest in NY of a strongly-self identifying Muslim who was inquiring about and hoarding explosives, the best advice I could give to Muslims who wish not to be stereotyped is to encourage their fellow believers not to be that stereotype.
Posted 12:42 PM, 11/08/2009
downthemiddle
janann I missed what branch of the service the current leader of this country served in, oh that's right he didn't. The last time I checked, the 19 cowards that killed 3,500 fellow Americans were Muslims! Not Christians, Hindu's, Mormons, they were Muslims. I certainly hope that the next attack doesn't include a loved one of yours, but if it does, we already know who you'll blame it on, George Bush and Dick Cheyney.
Posted 12:47 PM, 11/08/2009
CleanupPhilly
Haneefah, in Philly, the Nation of Islam and other offshoot Muslim movements have a disproportionate number of members who have criminal records, and who go on to commit crimes. Visiting hours on State Road at the Philly Prison System rival the number of women in hajibs and full body coverings as you see in Medina. Why is that? What does your faith teach you about the kufar, or nonbeliever? If a "religion" has been hijacked for violence and crime, is it politically incorrect to say so?
Posted 01:00 PM, 11/08/2009
haneefah22
FIRST OF, "CLEAN UP PHILLY" I AM MUSLIM BUT JUST BECAUSE I AM BLACK AND A MUSLIM DOES NOT MEAN I AM A FOLLOWER OF THE NATION OF ISLAM WHICH I AM NOT. YOU ARE BEING MISINFORMED MY FRIEND!! AND AGAIN, SO WHAT IF SOME MUSLIM WOMEN CHOSE TO COVER THEIR FACE AGAIN, IF YOU HAVE ENCOUNTERED THEM WHAT DID THEY DO TO YOU? NAME ME ONE INCIDENT WHERE YOU PERSONALLY HAVE HAD A BAD EXPEREINCE WITH A MUSLIM IN PHILLY. NOW ON THE OTHER HAND, I CAN GIVE YOU A WHOLE SOTRY OF WHAT I HAVE BEEN THORUGH WITH WHITE PEOPLE. BUT DOES THAT MEAN ALL WHITE PEOPLE ARE THE SAME?? AND AGAIN, IM MUSLIM BEEN MUSLIM FOR 10 YEARS AND I DONT HATE ANYONE BECAUSE THEY ARE A DIFFERENT RACE OR RELIGION AS ME. MY VERY OWN BROTHER IS A NON MUSLIM AND HE IS APART OF THE NATIONAL GUARD!! DO I HATE MY BROTHER BECAUSE HE IS NOT MUSLIM?? HECK NO!! LIKE I SAID EVERY RELIGION AND RACE HAS BAD APPLES IN THEM BUT I DONT CATEGORIZE THE ALL IN ONE GROUP TO BE KKK MEMBERS OR ANY OTHER GROUP!
Posted 01:07 PM, 11/08/2009
CleanupPhilly
I'd like to know why a full day passes before there is any news coverage of the attack in Fort Hood in the Ink and DN, while the other news sites are covering almost nothing else. Why do I have to go to the BBC, for example, to read that the NY plotter James Cromitie, an American-born Muslim, was headed to a meeting of Muslims in Philadelphia while he discussed the plot for which he was arrested? I think it's time to focus less on apologies and more on facts. Here's the BBC link: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/8061269.stm
Posted 01:10 PM, 11/08/2009
CleanupPhilly
I also am referring to other American-Muslim movements above. One are the "Moors" who believe in an apocalyptic version of Islam that believes that Muslims are not citizens of the US, and don't recognize US law. There are others in Philly of that same ilk, that expound that black Muslims are not US citizens and do not have to recognize US law. Do you deny this, Haneefah?
Posted 01:15 PM, 11/08/2009
CleanupPhilly
Haneefah, I'm not "misinformed" by some source, I'm reading a variety of news coverage from every angle, and I'm listening to my neighbors who are members of these various indigenous Muslim groups, and the degree to which they are radicalized, and sympathetic to 9/11 and jihadism is striking. The extremism of Philly American Muslims often outdoes their foreign counterparts. I don't advocate "hate" but I do advocate reporting the facts of what these groups state are their beliefs, and what the members themselves state about radicalism and violence. Why are Philly Muslims so often involved in crime? Why does the "black mafia" in Philly now and in the past so often identify as black Muslim? Why did the paper omit that Islamic radicals have been noted by the FBI going to Philadelphia for meetings, for example? Why have so many of the recent cop shooters been of this local homegrown radical Islamic movement?
Posted 01:42 PM, 11/08/2009
CleanupPhilly
I believe these are honest questions, fair questions, asked in the spirit of good faith and openness. Why am I to be told to accept that Islam is the religion of peace when so many Muslims, including American Muslims, have identified themselves that Islam is the religion of jihad?
Posted 01:54 PM, 11/08/2009
CleanupPhilly
When my own neighbors who are American-born Philly Muslims in these off-shoot movements locally celebrated 9/11 and called it a "fulfillment of prophecy," that was a wake up call for me. When my own neighbors who are American black Muslims state that there will be only Muslims and no non-Muslims after a violent upheaval, that's a wake up call for me. Instead of dismissing what people say, I think it's wiser to listen to them.
Posted 01:59 PM, 11/08/2009
CleanupPhilly
If only people had listened to what the Ft. Hood shooter was saying as he embarked, in his depression and despair, along a path toward violent radicalism, this could likely have been prevented. Let's not make the same mistake in Philadelphia out of an overabundance of political correctness. Let's really listen to what is being preached in the local masjids.
  • Jobs
  • Cars
  • Real Estate
  • Rentals
 
SEARCH JOBS
Spotlight Deal
Center City 19107
Spotlight Deal
Center City 19107
SEARCH REAL ESTATE
Spotlight Deal
East Falls 19129
Spotlight Deal
University City 19104
SEARCH RENTALS
NEWS
In a 39-count racketeering indictment, federal authorities allege that a prominent New Jersey defense lawyer was the leader of a criminal enterprise that used violence, intimidation, and deceit to generate millions of dollars.