In NYC, a $185M tunnel that leads nowhere, for now
The 800-foot-long, 35-foot-deep concrete trench could someday lead to two new commuter rail tunnels under the Hudson River to New Jersey, if the billions of dollars needed to build them ever materialize.
The access tunnel is being built now because the massive Hudson Yards development with six skyscrapers, the tallest being 80 stories, will soon be built on top of it. Trying to dig such a huge trench through the bedrock after those buildings are completed, officials say, would be an engineering and financial nightmare.
U.S. Sen. Charles Schumer (D., N.Y.) was among the lawmakers who pushed Congress to approve Hurricane Sandy relief money for the planned flood-resistant access tunnel, calling it mitigation to protect infrastructure from future storms. But he argued that it would have to be built now because the skyscraper developers could not be delayed indefinitely.
The access tunnel is expected to be completed in fall 2015.
Currently, there are two tunnels, opened in 1910, between New York's Penn Station and Newark, N.J., and they are unable to accommodate any more trains. They also flooded during Sandy in 2012.
Any kind of breakdown or glitch in the tunnels can lead to huge delays for the 250,000 people who use Penn Station every day to ride NJ Transit and Amtrak.
"There's an urgent need to expand capacity between New York and New Jersey," said Craig Schulz, spokesman for Amtrak, whose trains serving the Northeast Corridor between Washington and Boston are often packed, with ridership growing.
Mitchell Moss, director of the Rudin Center for Transportation at New York University, said new rail tunnels under the Hudson must be built and it was important to build the access tunnel now. "Sen. Schumer has made a wise and timely investment in obtaining federal funds to support a new concrete trench for future tunnels," Moss said.
The rail debacle once had a solution: a new tunnel called ARC, or Access to the Region's Core. But in 2010, Gov. Christie killed the $8.7 billion project, saying he feared his state would bear overrun costs.
Prospects for two new tunnels are unclear at best. Amtrak is working with $45 million in federal money it is receiving over three years for planning and preconstruction work.