Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH

  

TEXT SIZE: A A A A
email this
print this
reprint or license this
The case against T. Milton Street Sr. wentto the jury yesterday. Deliberations are set to resume this morning. Story, B3.
RON TARVER / Inquirer Staff
The case against T. Milton Street Sr. wentto the jury yesterday. Deliberations are set to resume this morning. Story, B3.
RELATED STORIES
 
Milton Street closing arguments: Defense
 
Milton Street closing arguments: Prosecution
 
Milton Street on Paying His Taxes
 
T. Milton Street Testimony Excerpt
 
The indictment (.pdf)
 
Plea memorandum for Matthias Schwabe
SAVE AND SHARE


Federal jury gets Milton Street case

The panel met for an hour yesterday and will return today.

After five days of testimony - including T. Milton Street Sr.'s declaration that he stopped filing tax returns because he no longer believed the income tax was constitutional - a federal jury yesterday began considering whether he is guilty of fraud and tax evasion.

The 12-member federal jury deliberated about an hour yesterday afternoon after getting instructions from U.S. District Judge Legrome D. Davis about how to apply the relevant law to the facts of the case against Street and codefendant John H. Velardi Sr.

The jury is to return at 9 a.m. today to the federal courthouse in Center City to resume deliberations.

The 2006 indictment alleges that Street, 68, of Moorestown, failed to pay taxes on $2 million worth of consulting fees and income not derived from his $30,000-a-year food-vending business between 2000 and 2004. He also did not file a tax return in 2002, 2003 and 2004, the indictment alleges.

In addition to the tax charges against him, Street and Velardi, 54, of Media, are charged with wire and mail fraud in an alleged 2003 scheme to defraud a Vietnamese businessman of $80,000 by selling him the rights to a $3.2 million airport maintenance subcontract that prosecutors say Street and Velardi knew did not exist.

Yesterday morning, the jurors heard three hours of closing arguments by Assistant U.S. Attorneys Anthony Wzorek and Jennifer Arbittier Williams; Street's attorney, Jeremy H.G. Ibrahim, and Velardi attorney Guy Sciolla.

In a brief 15-minute closing, Ibrahim referred to the two hours of testimony Street gave last Thursday, in which he admitted he did not not file tax returns in 2002, 2003 and 2004, cast doubts about the validity of the U.S. Tax Code, and admitted trading on his name and family relationship in 2000 after his younger brother, John F. Street, was elected to his first term as Philadelphia's mayor.

"You may not like everything you have heard when you listened to what Mr. Street testified to," Ibrahim told the jury.

"But this is not a trial about morality," Ibrahim added. "What is before you is whether you believe each element or each count. You must believe with a reasonable certainty that the government has proved its case beyond a reasonable doubt."

Wzorek described Street's new-found identity as a tax resister as a cynical attempt to get around the fact that Street knew he would owe taxes on more than $2 million in consulting fees he had earned.

Wzorek said that Street spent $50,000 on a car, $3,500 on a sport jacket, and thousands more for jewelry and wagering on horse races.

Sciolla told the jury that Velardi, facilities director for Philadelphia Airport Services, the key maintenance contractor at Philadelphia International Airport, was just a "corporate middle manager" caught between Street's schemes and businessman Thanh Nguyen, who desperately wanted to take over an airport subcontract.

Prosecution witnesses testified that Street and Velardi wanted to assign the airport subcontract to Nguyen and his V-Tech Services Inc. to recoup money Street owed PAS.

The government, however, alleged that the rights to the subcontract between PAS and Street's Notlim Inc. were no longer Street's to sell. In June 2003, airport officials had canceled the Notlim subcontract after Mayor Street ordered his older brother to withdraw from the deal because it appeared inappropriate. Prosecutors say the former mayor was not involved in his brother's alleged crimes.

Nguyen testified Feb. 11 that after he paid Street $80,000, the assignment of the subcontract kept getting postponed, and Street and Velardi stopped returning his calls.

Sciolla cited Nguyen's six-figure gambling losses as a motive for seeking the airport deal. But Sciolla also said Nguyen, a trained aerospace engineer, was too savvy a businessman to be the immigrant naif prosecutors made him out to be. "This guy is a rocket scientist. This guy is no dummy," Sciolla told the jury.

Sciolla argued that municipal contracts that rotate with a change in administrations were a fact of life in Philadelphia politics: "It's not illegal. It may be unsavory, but that is the way business is done."


Contact staff writer Joseph A. Slobodzian at 215-854-2985 or jslobodzian@phillynews.com.

 
Spotlight Deal
Holmesburg 19136
Spotlight Deal
Northern Liberties 19123
Spotlight Deal
Old City/Society Hill 19106
Spotlight Deal
Palmyra 08065
ARTS & ENTERTAINMENT
Searing is a great critics' word that must be used rarely and carefully. So much film stuff that's supposed to shock your soul is just special effects that may cook emotions, but doesn't leave them juicy.
NEWS
Kevin Carroll, 50, left the Army in 1979 and became "a slave to heroin." His addiction, he said, took him to low places. He's fished for meals from trash cans, slept on the streets, even curled up inside Dumpsters.