Carl's Cards owner has hosted more than 600 Philly sports celebs | We the People

Carl Henderson was a stainless steel salesman for nearly two decades before he decided to scrap it all in 1995 to try to make a living out of his childhood hobby — collecting and selling baseball cards.

While trading anything — especially a career — for baseball cards can be tricky, this trade worked out in Henderson’s favor. In this sports-ravenous region, Henderson has made a niche for himself by hosting the area’s biggest sports celebrities at his Havertown store, Carl’s Cards & Collectibles, for autograph signings.

Eagles center Jason Kelce was in Henderson’s store for a signing just one day after his epic Super Bowl parade speech rocked Philadelphia. Charlie Manuel, the manager who led the Phillies to a World Series win in 2008, has stopped by three times. And Bernie Parent, former Flyers goaltender, started it all off as Henderson’s first celebrity guest.

In all, Henderson estimates that he’s brought at least 600 of Philadelphia’s sports stars to his store to meet fans, who often wait by the hundreds in lines that wrap around the outside of his shop.

This scene looks familiar 😊 looking forward to another great weekend!

Posted by Carl's Cards & Collectibles, Inc. on Saturday, February 17, 2018

For a kid who grew up in Southwest Philly going to baseball games with his dad at Connie Mack Stadium, it’s sometimes hard for Henderson, 61, to believe he’s rubbed elbows with Philly’s biggest sports celebrities.

Today, every inch of Henderson’s store is brimming with bobbleheads, helmets, jerseys, baseball cards, hockey pucks, footballs, and every other type of sports memorabilia imaginable. At the center of it all is a giant working Dubble Bubble gumball machine.

“I don’t think there’s an ounce of space to bring anything else in here,” Henderson said.

Camera icon JOSE F. MORENO / Staff Photographer
Carl Henderson tackles the sports memorabilia market in Havertown.

Given that the baseball card market can be volatile and many collectors are searching for vintage cards, Henderson decided to keep items affordably priced and focus on celebrity signings.

“I try not to load the store up with expensive stuff. It’s not a museum,” he said.

It’s the kind of shop where dads take their sons after a Little League game to buy them a pack of cards or where people come just to talk about their favorite teams.

Camera icon JOSE F. MORENO / Staff Photographer
A small sampling of the sports items for sale at Carl’s Cards & Collectibles.

For signings, Henderson will typically pay sports figures a flat fee, say $2,000, for two hours of time. Some celebrities do a “piece deal,” which means they agree to sign a certain number of items for a fee. Henderson then sells tickets to fans in hope of turning a profit.

Henderson said the most expensive fee he’s paid was also the worst signing he’s hosted — former Eagles player DeSean Jackson.

“It didn’t go well, and he was not a very nice person,” Henderson said. “And we paid him a lot of money.”

But Henderson has been blessed with great celebrity visitors, too — like former Phillies player Hunter Pence, who agreed to sign 250 pieces but stayed all night and signed three times as many. Henderson counts his idol, former Phillies pitcher Steve Carlton, among his favorite guests.

“He walked in and put his hand on my shoulder,” Henderson said. “To have him in the store was — it was just beautiful.”

The wildest signing, though, was for Kelce and teammate Beau Allen just a day after the Super Bowl parade in February. Henderson estimated there were 1,000 fans and five television crews.

Posted by Carl's Cards & Collectibles, Inc. on Sunday, February 11, 2018

Posted by Carl's Cards & Collectibles, Inc. on Sunday, February 11, 2018

“There was one guy who had the bed of his pickup truck loaded with Bud Light and he wanted to have beers with Jason Kelce in his pickup truck,” Henderson said. “He’s handing Kelce cases of Bud Light and Jason’s like, ‘I can’t take it, but hopefully one day I can come back.'”

 

Know someone in the Philadelphia area whose story deserves to be told — or someone whose story you’d like to know? Send suggestions for We the People profiles to Stephanie Farr at farrs@phillynews.com or call her at 215-854-4225. Send tips via Twitter to @FarFarrAway.

Want more We the People?

  • Last week’s profile: Carlos Rowland is Rittenhouse Square’s caretaker, keeping the beloved park free of debris and damage.
  • From April 18: Mike Regan can catch marshmallows, with his mouth, thrown from the Ben Franklin Bridge and he’s taking his odd skill on national T.V.
  • From April 11: In a quest to preserve the peculiar, this couple created Bella Vista’s Narnia.
  • From April 4: Sandi Polyakov, the new head gardener at the Shofuso Japanese House and Garden in Fairmount Park, went from forager to de facto cherry blossom expert.
  • From March 28: Antoinette T. Campbell is a forensic scientist who helps bust crimes and stereotypes.

Want even more We the People? Check out the archive here.