Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH

  

share
email
print
reprint
font size
options
 
Backers of Cardinal Dougherty High School gather Sunday at the Basilica, where they prayed for a change of heart among Archdiocese officials who plan to close Dougherty and North Catholic in June.
RONNIE POLANECZKY
Backers of Cardinal Dougherty High School gather Sunday at the Basilica, where they prayed for a change of heart among Archdiocese officials who plan to close Dougherty and North Catholic in June.
READER FEEDBACK
Post a comment
RELATED STORIES
 
The lesson from the streets: Big money is not the answer
 
Pointless search for Fort Hood massacre's 'real reason'
 
Letters: My father & the Phillies
 
Michelle's family tree is multi-hued


Ronnie Polaneczky: Supporters of Dougherty & North find a frustrating parade of Q's withoutA's

BEFORE MASS began this past Sunday at the Cathedral Basilica of Ss. Peter and Paul, a seminarian asked the congregation if we'd consider supporting St. Charles Borromeo Seminary with a financial gift.

When he finished, it was the church cantor's turn. She explained that the magnificent cathedral is in constant need of upkeep. Perhaps we'd consider supporting the Basilica parish with a monetary donation?

As we waited for the organist to start the processional hymn, I heard a heavy sigh from Steve Schmidt, sitting behind me.

"Ironic, isn't it?" he whispered, leaning over the pew. "We're here today because of money. And what do they ask us for, before Mass even begins? Money."

Schmidt was among dozens of supporters of Cardinal Dougherty and North Catholic high schools who'd traveled to the cathedral not to protest the Archdiocese decision to shutter the venerable schools, but to pray for a change of heart among authorities who decided that the beloved institutions were no longer viable.

The church has cited falling admissions, and it's true that enrollments at the schools have declined. But, Schmidt and others point out, enrollment is at a trickle at sprawling St. Charles, which remains open. Ditto for membership in the cathedral's parish.

Yet there is no talk of closing either place.

So, why mothball Dougherty and North, wondered those who lingered in the brilliant sunshine after Mass. They were as bewildered as when the closings were announced.

"We've looked at this from every angle," said Schmidt, ad hoc leader of the Dougherty supporters. "The only conclusion we come to, every time, is that the Archdiocese has decided that the children of the inner city don't matter to them."

The Archdiocese disagrees.

Dougherty and North students, church leaders say, may transfer to archdiocesan high schools elsewhere in Philadelphia, assuring uninterrupted access to Catholic education.

But Dougherty and North supporters counter, correctly, that the schools aren't as interchangeable as, say, one Target store is with another.

I wrote a few weeks ago about the wonderful information-technology academy housed within North Catholic. It provides students with training and certification that could help them land good jobs after high school. Indeed, some parents enrolled their sons at all-boys North Catholic specifically for the new and growing IT program.

What will happen to the students whose training will be interrupted by the closure?

No one knows.

Dougherty offers a well-regarded Medical Careers Academy, in which 82 students are enrolled. They don't know whether or how their training will continue elsewhere.

Also housed within Dougherty is Our Lady of Confidence, a program for mentally disabled teens. Its 39 students are taught life and job skills to prepare for independent living, and their future is now up in the air. So is that of several legally blind students who enrolled at Dougherty because of its excellence at adapting its curriculum for the visually impaired.

"I could go on forever about how special this place is," said parent Tina Crowley, whose daughters Jaklynn and Erin turned down admission to more prestigious private schools to wear Dougherty's garnet and gold uniform. "You can't just switch one school for another. They're not all the same."

Most frustrating to staff and parents alike is how slow the Archdiocese has been to offer any solid information about how transfers would work.

Dr. Teresa Hooten, a Dougherty science teacher, said that the Archdiocese' high-school fair last week offered no answers about some issues of real concern.

Would her honors-track students be accepted into the honors programs elsewhere?

No one could tell her for sure.

Would students' class ranks follow them to new schools? If so, how? Ranking is a big deal on college applications.

Good question, she was told.

Would students retain scholarship money?

We have no idea, she heard.

"When the leaders in an organization make big decisions, they're supposed to know which way the dominoes will fall" as a result, said Hooten. "In this case, the people making the decisions don't even seem to know that there are dominoes."

What a sad and frustrating game.

E-mail polaner@phillynews.com or call 215-854-2217. For recent columns:

http://go.philly.com/polaneczky. Read Ronnie's blog at http://go.philly.com/ronnieblog.

Comments   
Posted 08:15 AM, 11/10/2009
cosrivron2
Catholic schools are no longer cost feasible. In the city, parents send their kids to Catholic schools because of the danger and poor quality of city schools. Not so out in the counties. There the public schools are superior in all respects.
Posted 09:07 AM, 11/10/2009
billyo516
Catholics schools are absolutely feasible and compete very well with the suburban schools, in both standardized test scores and college placement rates, and offer a sense of family and community that do not exist in public schools. The advent of the charter school option has hurt the city parochial schools. Still, some are thriving. Father Judge has full classrooms and excellent athletics and academics.
Posted 09:39 AM, 11/10/2009
Ben Dover
is it surprising that this religious cult who abuses young boys wants more money from thier members? lawyers cost money and the pope doesn't want to have to change his life style, but he wants you to change yours so they can continue without any sacrifices from themselves.
Posted 12:06 PM, 11/10/2009
RudeyObnoxious
Typical reaction from someone named Ben Dover.
Posted 12:25 PM, 11/10/2009
anti-tax
Closing schools... Putting low income housing and ex-offender housing in those schools... This ruins neighborhoods. Then they have the audacity to ask for money from the very same people whose schools they're closing. IF YOU LIVE IN THE CITY IGNORE THEIR PLEAS FOR DONATIONS! Give to your local parish only if the donation stays local. Let the Archdiocese sell its multi-million dollar portfolio of real estate to fund its suburban fantacies. Stay away from their glossy brochures and filmstrips explaining their need.
Posted 01:44 PM, 11/10/2009
birdswinbaby
ronnie are you and and your friend steve serious? you are members of a parish and you dont get even by this late date that its all about money? it always has been...where have you been? dont worry though. since people are "praying" to keep the schools open you dont have anything to worry about....prayer always works! just keep attending classes there. pray your way past the locked doors and empty classrooms. when the bulldozer shows up, its okay....pray :)
Posted 01:45 PM, 11/10/2009
JoeMammas
If the priests weren't molesting little kids, the money being spent on court cases could have been spent on keeping the schools open.
Posted 02:17 PM, 11/10/2009
karbase8
Joe Mammas, Ben Dover and anti-tax you are all exactly right. It has nothing to do with charter schools so called "family values". The Archdiocese is paying high priced lawyers and pr firms to protect themselves from lawsuits. It all trickles down to the school closures. They will let these buildings sit empty and rot the neighborhoods so then can say they have no assetts. There pet project in Royersford is going to fail miserably. It's all big business. My son proudly goes to public school and has school teachers that were Catholic school teachers. They offer small class sizes and a better education. My nephew gets one hour a week of religion in Catholic school and they never take him to church, maybe once a month if that. This has nothing to do with your faith. This has to do with the shady politics and business practices of the Archdiocese. They have plenty of money to keep these schools open but their interest lies in the suburbs.
Posted 02:19 PM, 11/10/2009
CCcomment
This is a socio-economic crisis for the Church. The Diocese must come to understand that without a middle class, Catholicism in the United States will change. It will be about spiritual entertainment for wealthy Catholics as opposed to the mission to help working class Americans that has always made me proud to be a Catholic. Middle class communities such as the one that is now deteriorating in Northeast Philadelphia have always been the heart of the Church in the United States. The Church has aggressively supported U.S. political conservatives and their economic policies that have all but wiped out the middle class by depressing income growth among the working class and making education and health care more expensive. This leaves parents outside of the upper middle class unable to afford Catholic school tuition. What a shame that the Church told its parishoners on Sunday to oppose health care reform, a reform that would help many, many Americans shore up their bank accounts and live with greater security. And what a shame for the future of the Catholic Church in America! All of this in the name of abortion? I hope the Church wakes up!
Posted 02:25 PM, 11/10/2009
mokey1057
they asked for money twice before Mass even started! Come on folks, it isn't about you and your children, it's about guilt and how much they can get you to give using it. Find a nice non-denominational church and go and praise God and Jesus. Leave the money out of it!
Posted 02:29 PM, 11/10/2009
Stringer Bell
I have no sympathy whatsoever for the Catholic Church---they've done this to themselves. There'd still be a market for Catholicism if they were about spiritual guidance and community outreach, but they're much more concerned with the almighty dollar and covering up their most recent child sex abuse scandals. And praying for a resolution to this mess? Please. Two hands working are more productive than a thousand clasped in prayer. My only sympathy in this mess if for the alumni and current students and teachers of the schools.
Posted 02:30 PM, 11/10/2009
yawns
Keep praying because the catholic church in the US has been on a spiral crash since the early 80's. Refuse to modernize your policies and become obsolete..
Posted 02:45 PM, 11/10/2009
rgreen72
You people are nuts. Liberals are nuts. Go do something with your life other than put people down. Stop it and get a life. Ted Kenedy killed a woman and you still worship him why cant Catholics be left alone?
Posted 02:47 PM, 11/10/2009
former Mt.Airy Kid
Dougherty was huge back in the mid 70s and 80s when I lived in Philly. I suggest if you want to get the diocese's attention, you stop dropping those envelopes in the basket on Sunday and write "Dougherty" on them. I have a feeling a meeting will happen real quick..
Posted 02:53 PM, 11/10/2009
Ricky Gehlhaus
yawns is dead on.
  • Jobs
  • Cars
  • Real Estate
  • Rentals
 
SEARCH JOBS
Spotlight Deal
Rittenhouse Square 19103
Spotlight Deal
Collegeville 19426
SEARCH REAL ESTATE
Spotlight Deal
Manayunk 19127
Spotlight Deal
Norristown 19401
SEARCH RENTALS
Daily Headlines
Subscribe now! Daily Headlines Newsletter

Philly.com news columnists