Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH

  

TEXT SIZE: A A A A
email this
print this
reprint or license this
It looks bad to Michael Stahl-David and Odette Yustman, but the shaky shock-umentary camera-style of "Cloverfield” is having an unsettling effect on some movie-goers, too.
Sam Emerson
It looks bad to Michael Stahl-David and Odette Yustman, but the shaky shock-umentary camera-style of "Cloverfield” is having an unsettling effect on some movie-goers, too.
RELATED STORIES
 
'Cloverfield' Web site; includes a trailer
SAVE AND SHARE


The nauseating side-effects of ‘Cloverfield’

After paying $9 for diet soda and chewy pretzels nuggets with slimy nacho sauce, you'd think nothing could make you more nauseated.

But some moviegoers have found the megahit Cloverfield tough to stomach, saying that it made them headachy, dizzy or distressingly nauseated.

At the Loews theater complex in Cherry Hill, a ticket-counter sign warns that the film can create a sense of motion-sickness.

It's not the quality of the monster mash-up, it's the shaky shock-umentary camera style – with tilting and even sideways views, vertigo-inducing ups and downs, and in-focus/out-of-focus effects.

"When the jerkings lasted a while, that's when it was uncomfortable," said Ken Wunsch, 46, of Camden, who said he felt dizzy during the film.

As if that's not enough, what the camera sees and hears – supposedly shot by a normal guy as Manhattan comes under attack - is also quite gut-wrenching. Crashing, screaming, running, horror and oblivion. Wait. Calm for a moment or two. Catch your breath. Then more crashing, screaming, running, gasping, panting, smoke, "Oh my God! Oh my God!"

Hay Huang, 14, of Camden, has seen the movie twice – even though it gave her a headache, which made her a little sleepy. "I sat there, but I had to look away," she said.

Mark Defeo, 17, of Haddonfield, part of a group of teens who'd just seen the film, said he felt dizzy, especially at the beginning, when partygoers were running downstairs from a rooftop. Afterward, he gradually got used to the roaming camera, he said.

A half-dozen pals, though, said they weren't bugged a bit. Chris Colameco, 14, of Haddonfield, joked that he never gets motion-sickness, probably because "my mother went on Gravitron" – a whirling Ocean City ride – "when she was pregnant with me."

Some people are predisposed to motion-sickness, while many others aren't, explained Steven Galetta, director of neuro-ophthalmology at the University of Pennsylvania Medical Center.

"I got sick watching the trailer," he said. "I'm not going to see the movie, in fact, because I know I'll get sick from it."

In tracking objects, our eyes use five different systems, including the inner ear's vestibular system that's tied to our sense of balance, he said.

So sharp camera movements – especially coupled with bursts of light and sudden sounds – can be disturbingly disorienting.

"They're making you shift through all these systems, very rapidly, and that's what is causing visual confusion," he said.

What's more, the auditory and vestibular systems share nerve pathways, creating a kind of "excessive feed into the brain stem," resulting in nausea.

As for those who felt headachy, "they probably got motion-induced migraine," he said.

Migraines can make people feel faint – as can gore. So even as terror escalates heart rates, gruesome graphic scenes can have the opposite effect, he said.

"So you're getting a sensory barrage of emotional, auditory, vestibular and visual information, and some of it sounds like it's deliberately contradictory."

Al Blunt, 44, of Lumberton, was glad that he only got a headache. The similarly "jittery" Blair Witch Project bothered him much more. "I was sitting in the second row and I got really sick, nauseated," he said. He even had to leave the theater for a few minutes until he felt settled again. This time he sat toward the back.

Janine Blunt, 42, said she was fine. "It was annoying at first. I had to look away a little, but I got used to it," she said.

The Body Wars ride at Disney World bothered Rob Gill, 35, of Cherry Hill, but not Cloverfield. "I felt the adrenaline rush, yeah," he said, but otherwise felt fine. After all, unlike during the ride, his seat was not shifting underneath him.

"I loved the movie. I had no physical reaction to it," said Chip Swain, 36, of Mount Laurel. He actually liked the jumpy camera work, even though it reminded him of the amateur videos of the 9/11 terrorist attacks.

In Cloverfield, New York is under siege again, and building collapses abound.

"You probably couldn't do this movie five years ago, because it's too fresh," said Gill.

Janine Blunt agreed, saying the camera work made it all seem more real.

"You could imagine being there," she said.


Contact staff writer Peter Mucha at 215-854-4342 or pmucha@phillynews.com.

  • Jobs
  • Cars
  • Real Estate
  • Rentals
 
Spotlight Deal
Northern Liberties 19123
Spotlight Deal
Center City 19107
Spotlight Deal
Center City 19107
Spotlight Deal
Bensalem 19020
find an event
We
Jul 9
Th
Jul 10
Fr
Jul 11
Sa
Jul 12
Su
Jul 13
Venue search: - by name
- by cuisine
- by venue type, e.g. "movie theater"
Location search:
- Philadelphia, PA
- 19101
- Center City
Venue search:
- by name
- by cuisine
- by venue type, e.g. "movie theater"
Location search:
- Philadelphia, PA
- 19101
- Center City
Date search:
Select which day you would like to search events, or select Search all days
Event search:
Type in the name of the event, or event type, e.g. 'live music'
SPORTS
After winning four straight games, the Phillies have now lost four straight. Home runs from Rick Ankiel and Ryan Ludwick spoiled an otherwise strong night for Cole Hamels, who gave up only three hits and struck out eight.
OBITUARIES
John Marks Templeton, 95, an investor and philanthropist of deep faith and inexhaustible intellectual curiosity, died yesterday at his home in Nassau, Bahamas.
Philadelphia Inquirer
Hunger lined up, quiet and orderly, in the summer heat of a Delaware County day. Suburban women, many looking a decade older than their ages, awaited their turn to collect strawberries, bananas and bread being distributed by Philabundance, the hunger-relief agency, at a Delaware County Housing Authority building in Woodlyn.
IT'S CALLED "pay as you throw." The Nutter administration is researching whether to charge residents for trash collection, according to city officials.