Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
TEXT SIZE: A A A A
email this
print this
reprint or license this
RELATED STORIES
 
Machine, registration problems in Pa. primary elections
 
Pa. Primary day
 
Yes, we can, and more, Clinton says
 
Election officials gird for a hectic day
 
'It's going to be close,' Obama says
 
At civil rights site, McCain seeks black vote
 
Latest campaign-finance reports show candidates' mixed fortunes
 
First District polling will be scrutinized
 
Democrats stage write-in campaign for Pa. House election
 
Selling the stuff of politics
 
Annette John-Hall: Some words of praise for committeepeople
 
Jonathan Storm: 10 questions for Chris Matthews
 
Jay Paterno's politics causing a stir
 
Editorial: Inquirer Endorsements
 
Editorial: Pennsylvania Primary
 
Chris Satullo: Obama is better-equipped to lead country through change it craves
 
PA Votes '08 Live: Blogging the votes
 
Complete coverage of the Pennsylvania primary
RELATED IMAGES
View gallery
READER FEEDBACK
When did you decide who would get your vote?
Months ago.
Weeks ago.
This week.
In the booth.
Post a comment
SAVE AND SHARE


Clinton wins Pa., keeps drive alive


Stitching together a coalition of blue-collar workers, white men and women, Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton kept her presidential candidacy alive yesterday with a convincing victory in Pennsylvania's Democratic primary.

She was running close to or leading Sen. Barack Obama in the crucial Philadelphia suburbs and was crushing him in southwestern Pennsylvania and the Scranton region.

"Some people counted me out and said to drop out, but the American people don't quit, and they deserve a president who doesn't quit either," Clinton told cheering supporters last night at the Park Hyatt Philadelphia at the Bellevue. "Because of you, the tide is turning."

With the support of Gov. Rendell, Mayor Nutter and much of the Democratic establishment, Clinton had been expected to carry the state, but the better-funded Obama was able to unleash an avalanche of television commercials and shave her lead in opinion polls.

Despite Clinton's win, Obama remains the front-runner for the nomination, with a significant overall delegate lead and a huge financial advantage. She also has few primaries left in which to overtake him.

Still, Clinton's big margins among white working-class voters seemed likely to add fuel to her argument that Obama cannot win the big industrial swing states in the fall against Republican John McCain.

After spending the afternoon in Philadelphia, Obama flew ahead to a rally with rocker John Mellencamp in Indiana, site of one of the next round of primaries May 6. He briefly acknowledged the Pennsylvania results in remarks that focused on Indiana and McCain.

"There are a lot of folks who didn't think we could make this a race when we started," Obama said. "Now, six weeks later, we closed the gap. We rallied people of every age and race and class. . . . We registered a record number of voters, and it is those voters who will lead our party to victory in November."

Voters swarmed the polls, given the chance to have a meaningful say in a presidential nomination for the first time in years.

Commonwealth Secretary Pedro A. Cortes described the turnout as "phenomenal." He said it might reach 50 percent statewide, perhaps eclipsing that of the 1980 primary, when President Jimmy Carter was challenged by Sen. Edward M. Kennedy (D., Mass.) for the nomination.

Hop-scotching the state


Clinton scored her victory by winning the majority of the votes of blue-collar workers, women and white men in an election in which the economy was the dominant concern, according to exit polls. Blacks, more affluent Democrats, and voters who recently registered Democratic sided with Obama.

The same demographic split prevailed in most of the other contests between Obama and Clinton.

With no other contests on the schedule, the candidates hop-scotched across Pennsylvania for nearly seven weeks, spending $20 million on TV advertising - a bombardment that, for example, featured 228 spots a day in the Harrisburg media market. Obama, his campaign flush with cash, was able to outspend Clinton by a ratio of about 3-1 on the air.

A tough turn


In its final days, the campaign turned sharply negative. Obama accused Clinton of practicing the "slash-and-burn" politics that has stymied progress in Washington. She ran a TV ad that featured images of Osama bin Laden, the bombing of Pearl Harbor, and Hurricane Katrina and suggested Obama could not handle the pressures of the Oval Office.

"Who do you think has what it takes?" asked the ad.

Obama has struggled in some states to win over white working-class voters, older voters and Catholics, key parts of the coalition that strategists say a Democrat needs to carry big industrial swing states.

For his part, Obama said that anything less than a blowout win here for Clinton would do little to help her overcome his delegate lead because delegates are awarded proportionally.

Polls showed that Clinton always had the advantage among women, older voters, Catholics, union households, and white voters with high school educations making less than $35,000. Obama was leading among younger voters, African Americans, Democrats with incomes over $75,000, and liberals.

The state seemed demographically tailor-made for Clinton, with higher percentages than the nation as a whole of voter groups that have favored her in past races. Obama was counting on Philadelphia and its suburbs to overcome expected Clinton support elsewhere.

Clinton's campaign had been on the verge of elimination after 11 losses last month before she won popular-vote victories in Ohio and Texas based on her advantage with the working class.

As Obama drew close in Pennsylvania, he hit a rocky patch that analysts said halted his momentum.

There was the disclosure of remarks he made at a fund-raiser, characterizing small-town Pennsylvanians as "bitter" people who cling to guns religion and "fear of people not like them" because of their economic frustrations.

In a televised debate last week, Obama was thrown on the defensive about everything from inflammatory comments by his former pastor to his friendship with a member of the radical Weather Underground, to why he rarely wears an American flag pin in his lapel.

Obama had appeared to weather the storm over the pastor, the Rev. Jeremiah A. Wright Jr., giving a well-received Philadelphia speech on race relations March 19, in which he condemned Wright's incendiary sermons.

For her part, Clinton was caught mischaracterizing her landing under sniper fire in Bosnia on a 1996 visit, a story she was using to establish her foreign-policy bona fides.

The sniper incident and "bittergate" might be examples of the candidates showing the wear and tear from the extended campaign. Clinton began the campaign with doubts about her trustworthiness, but her negative ratings have risen sharply in the last few months.

About a quarter of the voters yesterday told exit pollsters that they made their decision within the last week.

Vashti West, a Philadelphia school teacher, was torn until she entered the voting booth at the City Health Center at Broad and Lombard Streets.

"I didn't want another eight years of Clintons," West said. "This is America. Give someone else a chance. They are not the queen and king of England. . . . It's been kind of fun to see her work for it."

That inspired Emily Kramer-Golinkoff, 23, a researcher. "Hillary has character," she said.

John Drees, 65, a retired from the Temple medical school faculty, said he was fed up with the "obscene" national debt, worrying about its effect on his grandchildren and beyond.

"I think Clinton is more electable," he said.

At stake in Pennsylvania were 158 delegates to the Denver convention, the largest prize left.


Contact staff writer Thomas Fitzgerald at 215-854-2718 or tfitzgerald@phillynews.com.

Inquirer staff writers Andy Maykuth, Michael Matza, Tony Wood, Kia Gregory, and Joelle Farrell contributed to this article.

Comments
04:33 PM, 04/22/2008
I love how people state Hillary has all the experience. Experience at what?? Telling everyone that the world is going to end but if she is elected, she can change that?? She is a big PHONY!!!!
Posted by RMB
05:05 PM, 04/22/2008
RMB read about Hillary in Wikipedia. Do not demonstrate your ignorance by attacking others.
Posted by kadavul
05:08 PM, 04/22/2008
RMB: Dodging sniper fire=military experience. Cattle futures=financial experience. Keeping Bill from being convicted of sexual abuse=social experience. Hunting ducks on Lake Shinola=gun control experience. Reading all those FBI files on opponents=domestic terrorism experience. Combating "vast right wing conspiracies"=political experience. Finding lost Rose Law Firm billing files=administrative experience. Pardoning FALN terrorists=judicial system experience. My, my. She really DOES have a wealth of experience.
Posted by John Kerry
06:13 PM, 04/22/2008
I wonder whether retired Professor John Drees of Temple University, quoted above, had read this: http://www.philly.com/inquirer/opinion/17997244.html
Posted by hgoldman77
06:16 PM, 04/22/2008
Patrick Kerkstra and Sam Wood: Did Geno's change to Gene's Steaks recently? Been in Philly long?
Posted by bousozoku
07:41 PM, 04/22/2008
RMB is right on.
Posted by S.J.
07:54 PM, 04/22/2008
Everybody standing in line at 8:00pm ought to be counted.
Posted by wm18902
08:47 PM, 04/22/2008
Cohabiting with Bill = Mental Health Experience?
Posted by Peter of Manassas
09:10 PM, 04/22/2008
Slow and steady wins the race. By november everyone will be so sick of the other three bought and sold politicians it will be a shoe in for.... RON PAUL ALL THE WAY. A refreshing honest statesman who sees the whole picture and has the most common sense solutions. www.ronpaul2008.com
Posted by foronpaul
10:17 PM, 04/22/2008
What is wrong with you folks in Pennsylvania? How could you vote for this woman? She is a monster. A beast. This country needs Barack Obama!
Posted by DetroitMI
10:31 PM, 04/22/2008
What Obama and his supporters don't understand is that he no longer is thought of as the golden boy. He has been revealed to be a loser, and indeed he will lose the general election since America rejects him.
Posted by JMT
11:23 PM, 04/22/2008
Although your TOP STORY is titled, "Clinton wins PA, keeps drive alive," the photo adjacent is of Barack and Michelle Obama embracing. What is up with that, and your deceptive headline? The Inquirer folks are in the tank for Obama; just admit it. To the Obamabots on this thread, instead of being angry with Hillary, or Pennsylvanians, my question is why can't your guy close the deal?
Posted by sydney77
11:48 PM, 04/22/2008
Thanks for changing the photo; nice to see Mayor Nutter with Hillary.
Posted by sydney77
02:09 AM, 04/23/2008
The Clinton's are showing their strength and this is where race actually does factor in. If Obama was white Senator Clinton would have won the black vote. Black people loves the Clinton's and it's mutual. At this point we need to focus on issues. We need to pay attention to what they say and how they are going to back it up. My guess is mano y mano Clinton will win. You go girl.
Posted by Toni
07:01 AM, 04/23/2008
I am concerned that those white male working class voters who did not disclose a preference in advance knew all along that they wouldn't vote for a black, and will end up voting for McCain in November, even if Hillary were on the Democratic Ticket.....a black man or a woman for president? sorry, unable to disclose what I really think until I get into the voting booth..... We've still got a long way to go to fulfil the promises of 1776: that all men are created equal and are entitled to life, liberty and the pursuit of the presidency.
Posted by soupdragon
17 comments | View All Comments
 
Spotlight Deal
Southwark 19147
Spotlight Deal
Point Breeze 19146
Spotlight Deal
Rittenhouse Square 19103
Spotlight Deal
Chestnut Hill 19118
ARTS & ENTERTAINMENT