PhillyTablet Inquirer Daily News Daily News
email
size
comments
2
options
 
Monday, February 13, 2012

Interesting things have been going on with the nation’s meat consumption.

In December, a U.S. Department of Agriculture livestock report indicated that “another sharp drop in U.S. domestic meat and poultry consumption is coming in 2012.”

It also said the news should come as no surprise, but that looking at the historical context of the past few years, the trend was “rather shocking.”

Their numbers show that, on average, Americans will eat 12.2 percent less meat and poultry than they did in 2007.

A chart shows turkey and pork consumption holding more or less steady since 1960, although both have dropped slightly since 2007.

The chart shows broiler consumption — chicken — rising steadily through 2007, when it nearly equaled the consumption of beef. Beef, on the other hand, has been dropping since the late 1970s. Now, for the first time, the lines have crossed. Chicken consumption is higher than beef.

The report cites growing exports (so less is available here), higher costs and “the fruition of 30 to 40 years of government policy” as factors in reduced meat consumption.

“Add in the efforts of a large number of non-governmental agencies that oppose meat consumption for reasons ranging from the environment to animal rights to social justice and one could conclude that it was amazing that consumption held up as long as it did,” the report said.

Beef, in particular, has certainly been a target in recent years. It seems to have started with health concerns over the fat content more than anything else.

Lately, however, environmental groups have focused on the methane emissions of cows’ digestive tracts. The U.S. EPA counts these overall as the second-highest source of human-related methane emissions, behind natural gas systems and well ahead of landfills.

The other problem environmental groups cite: The “cost” of eating this high on the food chain. It takes many pounds of corn, for instance, to produce a pound of beef.

This has been changing, the industry points out.

A study published in December in the Journal of Animal Science found that raising a pound of beef in the United States today uses significantly fewer natural resources.

Washington State University researchers concluded that each pound of beef raised in 2007 used 33 percent less land, 12 percent less water, 19 percent less feed and 9 percent less fossil fuel energy than equivalent beef production in 1977. Waste outputs were similarly reduced, shrinking the carbon footprint of beef by 16.3 percent in 30 years.

That shrinkage has only continued.

Overall, improvements in cattle husbandry between 1977 and 2007 yielded 13 percent more beef from 30 percent fewer animals.

“As the number of mouths to feed increases and the quality of diets in many areas around the world improves, the demand for nutrient-rich protein like beef will increase,” said lead researcher Jude Capper. “At the same time, resources like land, water and fossil fuels will become increasingly scarce. These realities are like two trains speeding toward each other on the same track. If we listen to alarmists shouting at us to slow down, we could face a head-on collision of epic proportions. The only way to avoid this disaster is to accelerate the pace of progress.”

Since this is Soapbox Monday, we invite you to comment below. Do you still eat meat - beef, in particular? Why, or why not?

Posted by Sandy Bauers @ 3:15 PM  Permalink | File Under: Soapbox Monday | 2 comments
2
Comments   
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 2:46 PM, 02/13/2012
    I'm eating my meat-free lunch while I'm reading the blog, but that doesn't mean I don't eat meat. In fact, my physician keeps asking me to eat more beef (and spinach, and vitamins) to keep my tendency toward iron deficiency anemia at bay. So the lesson here (I guess) is moderation.

    When someone urges me to be a gustatory "original constructionist" and go vegan, I can't help but wonder what wholesale health benefits we would sacifice. After all, living longer and living better is a wonderful thing, right?

    While there is a lot to criticize in modern foodstuffs, there is also a lot of good. Mindful eating, eating only real food, and knowing where your food comes from and what goes into it is vital. This is a golden age for food, and I'm taking full advantage of it.
    Energyflak
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 4:50 PM, 02/13/2012
    I eat meat every day. Several times a day. In cow form, baby cow form, pig form, sheep form or chicken form. I can't get enough of it. I would eat it for dessert if I could. I would wear it as clothes. Wait, I do own leather. I would use it as currency, fuel and as an aphrodisiac if I thought I could. Although mignons have produced some acceptable results.

    Long live meat.
    journalismIsDead


2 comments
About Sandy Bauers
Sandy Bauers is the environment reporter for the Philadelphia Inquirer, where she has worked for more than 20 years as a reporter and editor. She lives in northern Chester County with her husband, two cats, a large vegetable garden and a flock of pet chickens.

GreenSpace - her column about how to reduce your carbon footprint in everyday life - appears every other Monday in Health & Science.

Follow on Twitter

Blog Roll
 
Facts of the Day Former DEP secretary John Hanger
 
WolfeNotes NJ environmental policy expert Bill Wolfe
 
PennFuture Pennsylvania environmental advocacy
 
A Rube With a View NJ wildlife and conservation expert Larry Niles
 
View From the Cape What’s happening birdwise at Cape May
 
Beverly Milestone Maisey Environmental issues and Transition Cheltenham
 
My Plastic-Free Life California’s Beth Terry goes without
 
GreenFaith Interfaith Partners for the Environment
 
LA Times Greenspace blog
 
B’More Green Baltimore Sun’s environmental blog
 
Blue Marble Mother Jones' enviro blog
Websites
 
All about Philly recycling
 
RecycleNOW Philadelphia
 
Next Great City Philly urban sustainability
 
Mayor’s Office of Sustainability
 
Transition Town Media
 
Transition Cheltenham
 
Wissahickon Growing Greener
 
Sustainable Delaware County
 
One If By Land Bucks County Citizen journalism on the environment.
 
PhillyCompost
 
Regional air quality partnership
 
Philadelphia Air Management Services
 
Clean Air Council in Philadelphia
 
Clean Water Action in PA
 
Sierra Club, NJ Chapter
 
Sierra Club, Pennsylvania Chapter
 
Energy Coordinating Agency
 
Delaware Valley Regional Planning Commission
 
Delaware River Basin Commission
 
Academy of Natural Sciences’ Center for Environmental Policy
 
Citizens for Pennsylvania’s Future
 
Pennsylvania Environmental Council
 
PennEnvironment
 
Delaware Riverkeeper Network
 
Philly Rivercast A daily forecast of water quality in the Schuylkill River
 
Environment New Jersey
 
New Jersey Environmental Federation
 
NJ PIRG
 
NJ’s American Littoral Society
 
NJ’s Clean Ocean Action
 
The Nature Conservancy, Pennsylvania Chapter
 
NJ Pinelands Commission
 
Pinelands Preservation Alliance
 
New Jersey Audubon Society
 
Bucks County Audubon Society
 
Valley Forge Audubon Society
 
Wyncote Audubon Society
 
Delaware Valley Ornithological Club
 
Pennsylvania Center for Environmental Education
 
Philly’s Women’s Health and Environmental Network
 
Dumpster Divers of Philadelphia
 
Environmental news and commentary from grist.org
 
National Geogoraphic’s Green Guide
 
Treehugger green living site
 
The Daily Green
 
Green Living from the Natural Resources Defense Countil