Below is the first blog entry from Beth Wallace, a registered dietitian at the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, who will be blogging regularly for us on kids and nutrition.
When people meet me for the first time in a social setting and find out I am a dietitian, things generally go one of three ways:
- They say, “Oh, great! You can put me on a diet,” then check my plate to see what I am eating.
- They immediately hide their food and say, “Please don’t look at what I’m eating; I generally eat really well,” then check my plate to see what I am eating.
- They immediately ask me four to seven rapid-fire questions about the latest and greatest diet or new nutrition study, then check my plate to see what I am eating.
The consistent message is that everyone has questions about food — and no one wants to be judged. What people don’t realize is that the last thing my colleagues and I want to do when we walk out of the hospital is evaluate what other people are eating (unless it looks really delicious), and then make a judgment about their weight, their health, or what they must feed their children.
What I would like you to do is to continue to look at my plate. Why? Because I want you to see how simple I make nutrition for myself.
I am constantly surprised by the answers I get when I ask a child: “What does eating healthy mean to you?” I frequently hear “not too many carbs” and “not eating trans-fats.” These complex nutrition ideas are far beyond the cognitive ability of a 10-year-old to understand, let alone put into healthy practice. Yet that is what I hear time after time. As a society, we’ve flooded ourselves with nutrition misinformation and forgotten the simple fundamentals.
What I would really like to hear from someone, someday, is, “Eating to give your body what it needs to do its best.” It is that simple. The good news is that I honestly believe that most people, including kids and teens, inherently know what things our bodies need to function at their best. Just in case, let me help:
- Water. Your body is about 60 percent water and that number is higher in young children. The water in your body sustains life’s functions in your brain, blood, lungs and kidneys. Your body is not made up of fruit punch, energy drinks or soda. It actually needs water.
- Energy. This comes from, believe it or not, carbohydrates. Low carbohydrate = low energy. Try to make them healthy whole grains.
- Fruits and vegetables. In their whole form. Eating them in their natural form maximizes their source of vitamins, fiber and minerals. Please step away from the apple juice, and grab the actual apple.
- Protein. Lean meat, fish, dairy, beans and nuts. You’ve got this one. I know it.
- Dairy (or non-animal substitute). For bone health and an additional source of protein.
If you stop and think, “Does my body need this today?” — and suggest your kids do the same — you can start to simplify the eating patterns for your family without the calorie-counting stress, and second-guessing of ingredients. (And, yes, sometimes your body does need a red velvet cupcake. Sometimes.)
Is that photo showing a dude using his own fork in the fruit tray? Magistra®
I appreciate you trying to make things simple for people, and kids especially, but not mentioning or educating them about fats as an essential component of one's diet is a really big mistake. Energy comes from carbohydrates, yes, but it also comes from fats. Leading dietitians now recommend a third of your calories coming from fat. The body needs fat for energy, tissue repair and to transport vitamins A, D, E and K around the body. The fat-free diet myth has been widely debunked and is now being pointed to as the contributor to many of the health problems we face in this country!
Cutting down on certain types of saturated fats (coconut oil has a lot of saturated fat but is actually good for you) and eating unsaturated fats, found in things like olive oil and avocados, will help. Check out this chart for help in finding your way - http://www.eatingrules.com/2012/02/cooking-oil-comparison-chart/. Good luck to all on your journey to finding the right way to eat. MLHolmes128- MLHolmes128: Jeezeeeee. It's a small blog post. Everything isn't always addressed. Also, there is fat in protein (even lean meat) and dairy soooooo....
- The writer made the following statement "As a society, we’ve flooded ourselves with nutrition misinformation and forgotten the simple fundamentals." And then proceeded to define the "fundamentals". I was simply pointing out that by leaving out Fats as a fundamental is a really big mistake. I don't think that's wrong.
You are right, proteins and dairy do contain fats. But there's a big difference between a piece of meat, milk, cheese, or eggs from an animal that was caged, fed a diet of GMO food/corn, soy, & wheat, and given growth hormones and antibiotics than an animal that was fed a natural diet of grass and not propped up with a bunch of shots. For one, the ratio of Omega 6 fatty acids in the GMO fed animal is a major problem. That ends up in their muscles and primarily in their fat, because fat absorbs more than the muscle does! And then it ends up in our diets. This is not good.
MLHolmes128 - I think you're going down a different path- I'm not debating the benefits of organic vs non-organic. I think any time you can afford to buy meats from a local fresh/organic kinda place go for it. I'll agree that the overabundance of antibiotics is alarming and not just for animal health either.
I agree with you that fats are important. I'm sure we all love really good olive oils and things. I just thought it was a little unnecessary- but as I read over it again- I agree with you. So I take back my original post. - My intention was not to start a debate on the value of organic vs. non-organic. I wanted to add clarity to the statement you made regarding the fat content in animal protein and dairy, that's all.
MLHolmes128
MLHolmes is right! Fat does not make you fat, carbs do. Coconut oil and avocados all the way. Whole grains are NOT healthy carbs. llh169
Frankly if people ate MORE saturated fat and LESS sugar and carbs in general, they would be far better off for the trade-off. People always ate that way until the "experts" decided that everything should be "low fat", and our nation (and the world) has become epidemically obese in the process. ICDogg
I can assure you that my body does not need, nor has it ever needed, a red velvet cupcake, or any other type of cupcake. ICDogg- I think the main take away is to have a balanced diet. I disagree that the low fat craze is the driving force behind the growing obesity epidemic. I would rather point to the consumption of fast, processed meals with larger portion sizes than necessary. A well balanced diet with daily exercise will keep you healthy and happy. And it will let you indulge and have some extra fat every now and again.
I disagree, TeamAwesome... I have dramatically increased my health according to laboratory results, and lost a large amount of excess weight, by eating a very UNbalanced diet with high fat and low carb. I eat more cholesterol, but my LDL is down, my triglycerides are way down, and my HDL is up! My blood pressure is down. My a1c has gone from over 13 to under 6 and I have stopped taking two kinds of insulin AND Avandia in the process. And I haven't been hungry a single day. I'm 67 lbs. down and this is within 4 1/2 months. And I've never had more energy (who says you need carbs for energy?!) in years. So I'm not buying a lot of the advice I'm getting from the dietitian community. ICDogg- ICDogg- that's great. I hear a lot of the same stories. The problem is that if you go back to a "normal" diet that's more balanced you'll gain all of that weight back. Is that because of the carbs only? Probably not. It's probably the balance of your diet before then. I've never been on a high fat low carb diet but by balancing the proper groups and portion sizes I've also seen great improvement in weight and health.
TeamAwesome, for me there is no going back to anything even resembling a "normal" diet. My metabolic system over the years got too screwed up to even consider that. I am just grateful that I have at least partially reversed some of my more serious conditions. It doesn't hurt that I've also cut down my prescription expense from hundreds of dollars per month to about $13 per month with no prescription plan. I can spend some of that money on delicious grass fed beef. :) The way I eat now is pretty much the way I think I'm eating from now on, with only minor adjustments as I need them. ICDogg- I think that's great actually. The willpower to make that kind of adjustment is nice. I think unfortunately not everyone does that and can't really find a proper way to eat. I have a lot of friend who did the high fat/low carb thing and then just stopped. I do think maybe a new way of teaching about food would help- maybe even starting at really young ages so kids can learn the pros and cons of things they eat.







