The National Pizza Index: What’s the average price of an American pie?


The great debate over where to find the best pizza may never end (even though it’s definitely a classic New York slice), but at least now you can rest easy knowing how the price of pizza compares across the country.

Eater compiled pricing data for a basic Margherita pizza (tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, and basil) from every VPN-certified (Verace Pizza Napoletana) pizzerias throughout the continental U.S. to see where the cheapest pies can be found. According to their findings, these precious pies can range from $8.90 to $16 depending on your location.

To be VPN-certified means the pizzeria has received a stamp of approval from the Delegation of the Associazione Vera Pizza Napoletana. In order to be VPN-certified, a pizzeria must meet an extensive list of requirements that include a wood-burning oven, proper ingredients, and even proper technique for dough preparation–simply spinning dough in the air doesn’t cut it.

Kentucky claims the lowest cost pie at $8.90, while New York, Connecticut, Pennsylvania, and the California Bay Area are all tied at the top with $16 pizzas. The average price for a VPN pie in the U.S. clocks in at $13.21.

To find your nearest VPN-certified pizzeria, check this list and see the average prices by city and region below. The closest listed shops to Philadelphia are Massimo's in Robbinsville and Hamilton, N.J.

Eater (Eater)

Continue Reading