Monday, February 4, 2013
Monday, February 4, 2013
@

Let's take a look at Ackerman's good points

I KNEW ARLENE Ackerman before I met her.

I knew she had devoted her life to teaching and caring for other people's children. I knew she was driven by a faith that her children could access the abundance America offers to the well-prepared through her gift for teaching.

The doctorate from Harvard, the two master's degrees were impressive credentials. Her success in raising test scores when she headed school districts in San Francisco and Washington, D.C., validated her qualifications.

But you had to read her resume backward to really appreciate the sense of mission that drove her. She was raised middle-class in a family that would have supported her in any aspiration. She chose to teach, as her mother had before her. She went to a small teachers' college in St. Louis, even though she had been a national-honors scholar in high school and had earned numerous scholarship offers.

She was an elementary-school teacher in St. Louis. It meant spending hours each day teaching long division, reading, social studies, history and life skills to inner-city children. Half of those children would be marked permanently absent by the 10th grade. But that bleak metric could never discourage the kind of teacher I saw between the lines of Ackerman's impressive resume.

I read between those lines and I knew who she was, or at least who she had been. I have known scores of public-school teachers from similar backgrounds, many from little teaching colleges like Cheyney. They set out decades ago, back when teaching was one of the most-respected professions you could aspire to. Many of them still cling to their faith, even as they are vilified as the most salient symbols for society's failure to fully support inner-city public schools.

She knew what it was to teach. She knew what it was to be a principal in an overcrowded, underfunded school. It helps to have been on the front lines. But it takes more than an educator to run a big-city school district.

From the News Desk
Stay Connected

The children need an advocate in the salons of power, someone willing to go to battle for them, not just on the front lines, but also in the back rooms where power concedes nothing without a demand.

Ackerman wore her disdain for politics like a merit badge. Her previous two superintendent positions had ended in controversy, largely because of her inability or her unwillingness to, as she so dismissively put it, "play the game they want me to play."

In Philadelphia, she started to lose that game early. Her tepid response when Asian students were beaten outside South Philadelphia High cost her and the district much-needed political support.

She set up a series of forums that gave parents and neighborhood stakeholders a say in who would run the reconstituted empowerment schools. But after parents at West Philadelphia High made their choice, she overruled them and claimed that parents had sold their children out to back a company that had paid a pittance to two of them for knocking on doors to invite parents to PTA meetings.

The final straw came after the School Reform Commission had voted to back parents at Martin Luther King High who wanted to have Mosaica Turnaround Partners run King as a charter. But state Rep. Dwight Evans, Deputy Superintendent Leroy Nunery and a Mosaica official met in a back room an hour later. Mosaica withdrew its bid the next day.

For weeks, she maintained that Nunery had not told her about the meeting. Later, she admitted that she had been briefed. But she still played the victim in an Education Week interview, claiming that the SRC had put her on its hit list when she balked at giving the $12 million contract to Foundations, a firm with close ties to Evans. Foundations withdrew when the questionable maneuvers became public.

She floated to a soft landing on a public/private parachute that coupled $500,000 in district money with $400,000 in private funds for her severance deal (nearly all of the private donors later withdrew their pledges). Then she still filed for unemployment compensation. That was the closing act that most people will remember.

But Arlene Ackerman was the real thing, an old-school educator who practiced her faith by funneling district resources to the neediest areas. On balance, children here benefited by her tenure.

That's why I choose to remember her as the dedicated teacher and public-education zealot whom I met reading between the lines of her impressive resume.

 


Elmer Smith is a retired Daily News columnist.

Elmer Smith For the Daily News
email
You May Also Like
Comments  (14)
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 3:05 AM, 02/04/2013
    Her only good point was that she was not a mass murderer.
    orange rhino
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 3:10 AM, 02/04/2013
    Forgot. She also helped western conservation efforts by swallowing a buffalo whole in 2009.
    orange rhino
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 3:36 AM, 02/04/2013
    Great resume, and dedication to education. But, left the PSD more chaotic, then before she came!
    Dadair1
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 4:58 AM, 02/04/2013
    well elemer, it's usually the closing act that is remembered
    joegrink
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 5:39 AM, 02/04/2013
    I don't remember children first, I remember Arlene first. Specifically having so much staff dedicated to HER OWN PR, not for the district or the children.
    Earl J
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 6:00 AM, 02/04/2013
    her finest attribute was her absence
    the lopez!
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 6:14 AM, 02/04/2013
    I think they call it Karma.
    Nitroglycerin
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 6:22 AM, 02/04/2013
    she absolutely played the race politics game.
    her version of reality was that minorities meant only african americans.
    in a racial dispute african american could only be categorized as the victim and not the aggressor.
    the south philly high incident showed how out of touch her racial paradigm was.
    further, she steered a multi million dollar contract to a african american firm.
    ackerman played to her constituents and was disdainful of anyone outside of that group. that was the reason for her downfall.
    the lopez!
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 6:52 AM, 02/04/2013
    She was the local Black face of a national education failure that began a generation or so ago on May 17, 1954 if not July 2, 1964 and has left us (U.S.)today with a Urban AND Rural education failure which partially explains why more and more of our doctors, nurses, engineers and spelling bee champions are born overseas.

    These are the truths that many don't want to hear and explains why this comment section will be deleted by noon.
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 7:04 AM, 02/04/2013
    All American schools are failing both Urban and Rural due in large part to a decline in a commitment to PUBLIC Education that began on May 17, 1954. We are merely looking for a Black face to blame.

    Meanwhile more and more of our doctors (in Urban and Rural America), nurses (in Urban and Rural America), engineers (in Urban and Rural America) and spelling bee champions (in Urban and Rural America) are born overseas.

    As America forgets the spirit of Benjamin Banakker to cast the first stone.
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 10:07 AM, 02/04/2013
    this article was about ackerman.
    vallas and hornbeck (white men)also played to the lowest common denominator and promised massive changes in 5 years. they left before their 5 years were up in disgrace.
    if people are expecting schools take on the role of surrogate parent they will be surely disappointed.
    parents have to believe that education is worthwhile and instill that in their children.
    immigrants from asia(india and southeast) have their children succeed at poor urban schools because they demand excellence from their children.
    no two ways about it, many parents have failed in the roles as the primary source of their children's education.
    the lopez!
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 7:13 AM, 02/04/2013
    May she rest in peace, but: Let's take a look at Ackerman's good points, lend me your microscope!
    STEPHEN1988
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 8:01 AM, 02/04/2013
    Ackerman was on the board of the Broad Foundation, a leading promoter of privatization of public schools, while she was Superintendent of Schools in Philadelphia. She was the first director of their Superintendents Academy.

    http://www.broadeducation.org/news/52.html
    tom-104
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 8:30 AM, 02/04/2013
    Also see http://www.broadacademy.org/asset/839-070308_ackerman_press_release_final.pdf

    http://www.educationupdate.com/archives/2007/MAY/html/spot-drarlene.html
    tom-104