Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
share
email
print
reprint
font size
options
 
READER FEEDBACK
Post a comment


Former students file suit against nursing school

Sabrina Whitaker had one semester left at St. Joseph's Hospital School of Nursing before she could graduate and achieve her dream of becoming a registered nurse.

But in November 2008, she was abruptly dismissed from the program without warning, Whitaker said.

"They told me my grades were not acceptable and that I was unprepared," Whitaker said. "I knew I was passing prior to my final exam. But I was told very rudely that I had failed."

Whitaker, 39, wasn't alone. Ten other students were booted from the program for similar reasons, she said. It was too late for any of them to get refunds on the $22,000 each had paid in tuition.

Whitaker said she appealed and asked to see her graded final exam.

"They said no," Whitaker said, and told her to consider becoming a practical nurse instead.

Today, Whitaker and four of the former nursing students filed suit against the school in Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas, alleging breach of contract and fraud.

The group's attorney, Vivienne Crawford, said the school lacked qualified instructors and consistently ran out of supplies as basic as latex gloves and needles.

Crawford also said school administrators never told students that the program had not been accredited. The lawsuit also claims that the state told the school to close its clinical training due to a low pass rate and was placed on provisional status in April, 2008 for failing to comply.

School officials did not return several calls seeking comment.

"They knew we weren't getting the education we were paying for," Whitaker said. "They didn't do what they said they were going to do, which was teach us to be nurses."

The students who filed suit are all African American and describe themselves as members of the Liberation of Students Rights Group of Philadelphia.

Twenty of the school's first class of 30 students graduated in 2007, according to the school's Web site.

The school, based at Girard Medical Center in the city's Francisville section, was placed on provisional-approval status in spring 2008 by the State Board of Nursing because of its low student pass rates, Dean Carole Baxter told The Inquirer in July.

Baxter said the school is well-equipped and has an able faculty. She also said it was "not uncommon" for the accreditation of a new school to take years.

The 12-month program, which prepares students to take certification exams to become registered nurses, was established in 2006 with financial help from the state, said Crawford, the students' attorney. It was designed to increase the number of registered nurses who would then work in North Philadelphia's underserved community.

Since her dismissal Whitaker, the mother of two children, has put her studies on hold and is looking for a job.

She still owes $22,000 in loans she took out to pay St. Joseph's tuition.

Crawford said the lawsuit seeks unspecified damages.

"The price tag for each student is different," Crawford said. "Some are single mothers who put their entire lives on hold. It's been a horrendous nightmare. They did not know until the second semester that the school was not accredited."

Whitaker would be happy to recoup the tuition, she said, but said the suit is not just about money.

"Ideally, we want our dreams to become registered nurses to come true," she said. "We've put in the work and done everything we've been required to do."


Contact staff writer Sam Wood at 215-854-2796 or at samwood@phillynews.com.


Comments   
Posted 03:41 PM, 10/28/2009
Could.It.Really.Be...ColonelAngus
A "The 12-month program, which prepares students to take certification exams to become registered nurses" sounds too good to be true. It's a shame but this looks like a scam. Anybody graduate and earn an RN?
Posted 04:07 PM, 10/28/2009
PhillyPhan12
Sounds like a scam to me ... they prepare students to take a certification exam which will help them to take another exam (called the nursing boards) to be an R.N. They are just preparing you for a test... and not the right test!
Posted 04:20 PM, 10/28/2009
djdekok
I thought that RN's needed a four-year degree (BSN); am I wrong?
Posted 04:22 PM, 10/28/2009
Philly_Mommy
Ever been to St. Joe's Hospital? I wouldn't send a dog there to die, let alone go there for nurse's training.It is a Diploma program, where you can earn your RN, and if the person I think is still the director, it's not a good one at that.And telling them they should try and be a practical nurse after failing out of RN school is a slap in the face to LPN's
Posted 04:39 PM, 10/28/2009
gadels
djdekok...No, you don't need a BSN to be an RN. A two year accredited degree with proper exams will do. I have four nurses in my family (wife, both sisters-in-law, and daughter).
Posted 04:45 PM, 10/28/2009
kristamarie814
djdekok, an associates degree (two-year degree) is needed to be a registered nurse. Colonel, I too am interested to hear if anyone graduated from there and earned their RN. That statement sounded like a scam to me too the first time I read it. Two years ago when I was shopping around for an assoc. degree nursing program, I had briefly looked into them and I'm thanking myself that I didn't put too much consideration into them and found an accredited program. How sad for these students, both those in the program and those who were kicked out. Best luck to you all.
Posted 04:50 PM, 10/28/2009
Hal
Sounds like a real rip off. This should be investigated
Posted 04:52 PM, 10/28/2009
JerryEveryday
I'll have to agree with Philly_Mommy. I would rather go to a Community College were the courses and program is accredited. $22,000 for a 12 month program? That's ridiculous.
Posted 04:52 PM, 10/28/2009
CityIdiots
DJ, you are wrong. RN's are a two-year degree. BSN's are a four-year degree, and is a different level nurse than an RN. There's also an MSN, a master's degree in nursing, which is 6 years.
Posted 10:04 PM, 10/28/2009
catsrule
As an RN who has practiced for 40 years, I have some difficulty with equating the 'desire' to be a nurse with the actual ability (intellectual and otherwise) that is necessary to have the lives of patients in your hands. I don't know if St. Joe's is a rip-off or not, but I do know that nursing is a priviledge,not a right. There are more than enough nursing schools in this area -- I don't know why hwe needed another one.
10 comments
NEWS
Paul Domowitch: On a night when the Eagles turned the ball over three times, committed another bushelful of penalties and converted just four of their first 11 third-down chances, they managed to maximize their other two red-zone opportunities and pull out a 24-20 come-from-behind win over the Bears.
LIVING
John-Hall: An urge to preserve a rich family legacy is the genesis behind a new book: "Aunt Sarah's Recipes for a Long and Spirit-Filled Life." It's equal parts historical, inspirational and spiritual guide, sprinkled with tasty soul-food recipes, like peach cobbler and hoecakes.