Taxes are simply too complicated

DEAR HARRY: I hate the income tax! They have made the tax so damned complicated that even the CPAs have to use computer programs to get it right. Why can't we have a flat tax that has a return with maybe four or five items on a single sheet? That would save most taxpayers a lot of money that now goes toward tax preparation. Or we could go to a national sales tax. Why not start a campaign for simplification?

WHAT HARRY SAYS: Join the club. For as long as I can remember, there have been advocates of your position. Perhaps the greatest problem is the use of the income tax to encourage or discourage certain actions. For example, the charitable-contributions deduction has nothing to do with taxes, but it does encourage giving. Homeownership is given a boost by the interest deduction. And look at this list of credits against the computed tax! You count the ones that are really tax-related: child tax credit, dependent-care credit, earned-income credit, adoption credit, qualified-retirement-savings credit, health-coverage credit, education credits, elderly and disabled credits, foreign-tax credits, residential energy credits, alternative vehicle credit, first-time-homebuyer credit, excess Social Security withholding credit, mutual fund undistributed-capital-gain credit, and there are more. And many of these are limited by tie-ins to taxable or adjusted gross income. On the other hand, both the flat tax and the national sales tax favor the wealthy.

Fairest of all? A self-assessed tax on men based on virility, and on women based on beauty.


Email Harry Gross at, or

write to him at Daily News, 801 Market St., Philadelphia, PA 19107.

Harry urges all his readers to give blood. Contact the American Red Cross at 800-Red Cross.

Continue Reading