Saturday, February 13, 2016

Life, Life, Love

Wood-fired excellence at Petruce et al.

Justin Petruce, co-owner of Petruce et al., at the seven-foot oval wood-fired hearth and grill at the root of the deep flavors at the Walnut Street restaurant.
Justin Petruce, co-owner of Petruce et al., at the seven-foot oval wood-fired hearth and grill at the root of the deep flavors at the Walnut Street restaurant. DAVID M WARREN / Staff Photographer
Justin Petruce, co-owner of Petruce et al., at the seven-foot oval wood-fired hearth and grill at the root of the deep flavors at the Walnut Street restaurant. Gallery: Petruce et al.
Petruce et al. Video: Petruce et al.
About the restaurant
1121 Walnut St.
Philadelphia, PA 19107
Neighborhood: Center City Parking: Street parking only.
Handicap access: Wheelchair accessible.
Hours: Dinner Tuesday-Thursday, 5-11 p.m.; Friday and Saturday, until midnight; Sunday, until 10 p.m. Bar open until 1 a.m.
Reservations: Recommended
Open Table
Prices: $$$
Payment methods:
American Express
Cuisine type: Modern American
Meals Served: Dinner
Style: The primal art of wood-fire cooking meets sophisticated modern interpretations at this inspired new debut from three young talents - the chef brothers Petruce (Jonathan and Justin) and beverage savant Tim Kweeder. This bi-level Washington Square West destination serves seasonal plates meant for sharing, with a wide-palate of influences (from lasagna to kimchi) that always frame fine ingredients. The bar is a destination in its own right, featuring exceptional cocktails and spirits, plus a fascinating list of unusual small-producer wines.
Specialties: Roasted carrots with bagna cĂ uda; sweet potato with tomatillo; chicken livers with rhubarb; beef tartare with mushroom aioli; rabbit terrine; lamb ribs; lasagna; quail; black bass with strawberries; arctic char; chicken and grits; 20- ounce dry-aged sirloin; soft-serve ice cream; rhubarb mousse; roasted pineapple with chocolate mousse.
Alcohol: The wine list is modest in size, but exceptional in its focus on small-producer wines made with "low intervention" techniques that result in earthier, lower-alcohol, food-friendly wines (at relatively fair mark-ups). Highlights include a white Alsatian blend from Binner (aromatic, faintly effervescent), a dry red version of usually sweet aleatico (Alea Viva), multiple Loire choices, and good crisp fino sherry by the glass. There are also excellent ciders (Cyril Zangs), a handful of craft beers (Nebraska IPA), and George Costa's elaborate but expert cocktails are very worthwhile: try the Laphroaig-smoked "Man Man-hattan."
Weekend noise: A noisy 92 decibels in the front, slightly quieter in the rear dining room. (Ideal is 75 decibels or less.)

"I haven't picked up a vegetable peeler since I've been here - and it feels so good."

Several thoughts strike me when Justin Petruce tells me this. Number one: It must be liberating to finally be the boss, as the 33-year-old and his co-chef brother, Jonathan, 32, are in their debut at Petruce et al., the buzzy Center City restaurant where they've partnered with one of Philly's top wine geeks, Tim Kweeder.

Number two: The already endangered technical discipline of classic French cuisine, with its knife-work obsession over perfectly "turned" little veggie ovals, has officially been tossed onto the pyre of the Petruce brothers' roaring wood-fired hearth.

Number three: Do they even still wash those carrots?

More coverage
  • Taking a second look at Pub & Kitchen
  • Paris Bistro approaches fluent French
  • Caleb's American Kitchen still has a lot to learn
  • In fact they do, Justin assures me, gently rinsing the organic soil that still clings from the local farms that supply the restaurant. But it's all elemental once the Petruces tap their inner cave-man culinarians, stoking the seven-foot-wide oval hearth and grill with cherry and oak fires to roast everything from whole, dry-aged quail to crusty, house-made sourdough bread - and also those baby carrots, which are crisped dark and sweet directly over the embers.

    That primal breath of fire is at the root of the deep flavors that make the Petruce brothers' food so irresistible. But the rusticity ends there.

    What emerges from the kitchen in steel casseroles and on taupe-glazed pottery plates are very modern interpretations of multi-culti American cuisine. The carrots come three ways (roasted, pickled, shaved into raw ribbons) and dusted with Japanese seaweed-sesame spice over a Piedmont-style bagna càuda dip of anchovies, lemon, and garlic. Sweet chunks of coriander-roasted crimson beets are paired with a tahini-beet puree and snappy shavings of golden beets spiced with harissa and fermented into sour, crunchy kimchi. The delicately tender quail, mid-rare but its skin glazed dark with honeyed soy, comes over a deeply earthy mushroom broth punctuated by snappy green spring favas, crunchy puffs of wild rice, and tart pink cherry bursts.

    At which point I'm struck by yet another thought with larger implications: that Petruce et al. is the latest gem in the most impressive year for new Philadelphia restaurants I've witnessed. I awarded nine restaurants a three-bell "excellent" rating in 2013, about the average. Petruce is the ninth three-beller this year - and it's only June.

    This may also be the most encouraging because it speaks so clearly of a new generation of rising Philly talents. Most people have never heard of the brothers Petruce, though both have cooked in well-known kitchens. Justin worked at Meme, Fish, and Twenty21 locally, as well as Moto in Chicago. Jonathan did time on the line at M Restaurant, Rae, and Meme, the David Katz bistro where the brothers met their partner, Tim Kweeder.

    Kweeder (a.k.a. the "et al.") is a former longtime Moore Bros. associate who emerged in the past couple of years at as one of a few local advocates trying to make wine cool again in this solidly beer town. His Petruce list isn't yet nearly as deep as the 400-label cellar he built for, but the wine nerd aesthetic is the same - "low intervention" wines from largely unfamiliar smaller producers that emphasize terroir and earthiness. A version of the ancient Pineau d'Aunis grape from the Loire? Check. A refreshingly dry version of frothy purple (usually sweet) lambrusco from Baldini? Check.

    Embrace Kweeder's cut of unusual grapes - aligoté, aleatico, romorantin, and myriad gamays. Try the funky dry Euro ciders (Cyril Zangs, Isastegi.) And indulge intricate but masterful cocktails from bar brain George Costa (I loved the refreshing pineapple-rum Pilar, as well as the "Man Man-hattan," an ode to the local band, touched with Laphroaig smoke.)

    The elements of a complete restaurant here are already in place, most reminiscent in style of Vernick Food & Drink, from the wood-oven cookery to the bi-level layout and sophisticated-casual vibe. And in current fashion, there's something for everyone, with a variety of plate sizes meant for sharing, and flavors that range from daring to homey.

    On the edgier side is a beef tartare, glossed with grill-rendered dry-aged tallow and a mushroom-infused aioli that is like eating umami squared. Chicken livers, cast-iron roasted in the oven, are transformed into a silky Madeira-kissed pudding glazed with tangy rhubarb. Sublimely tender lamb ribs are smoked for hours over fruitwoods and mopped with a sambal-spiced brew of vinegar and sugar. Rabbits are turned into fennel-scented rounds of pink terrine, with char-roasted green garbanzo beans and creamy dollops of cloumage cheese.

    Cracked rice is cooked into congee porridge topped with hot sauce and grilled octopus - although its chewiness was one of the kitchen's few cooking flaws. Too much sticky tapioca binding the brick of pulled pork shoulder, and a huge grilled porgy that was borderline salty with its piquant olive garnish, were the other missteps.

    Those were easily compensated for, though, by the Petruces' many successes. There were inspired vegetable dishes, such as wood-roasted sweet potatoes with the Mexican accent of silky avocado puree, tangy tomatillo salsa, queso fresco, and crunchy crushed corn nuts. There were beautiful fish in striking seasonal poses, such as the arctic char over garlicky almond puree with crisp, frilly shavings of fried baby artichokes; or the black bass with vivid green ramp hollandaise and sweet-tart pickled strawberries.

    But Petruce may well become best known for interpretations of some true basics - such as lasagna, roast chicken, and steak that are instantly among the city's best. The hearty eight-layer lasagna, its fresh pasta ribboned with nutmeg-scented béchamel, is oven-finished to a crunch in cast iron. The simply roasted chicken brings parchment-crisp skin and juicy flesh, with creamy grits ringed by an electric-yellow sauce of slow-cooked yolk thinned by white soy and lemon.

    The huge 20-ounce Niman Ranch strip is meat and potatoes deluxe, a richly flavored slab of 28-day dry-aged beef striped with dusky oregano Argentine chimichurri, and a side dish of sturdy Bibb lettuce leaves glazed in Caesar dressing, beside thick steak-fry "chips" cleverly tanged from a pre-fryer simmer in vinegared broth. As a centerpiece for sharing, it's well worth the $55.

    I worried about the desserts, which on paper sound like typical cheffy sweets - with deconstructed components and the usual savory accents (black pepper soft-serve?). They worked far better than expected. Roasted pineapple was a natural with chocolate-infused coconut milk ganache. A creamy mousse tanged with pink rhubarb, but dusted with exotic fennel and pepper, found perfect preppy harmony with rich green pistachio cake. Whatever black pepper sparkle was in soft-serve ice cream, though, was muted just enough by the sweet ruby drizzles of fresh strawberry compote and buttery crumbles of shortbread cookies on top.

    Which triggered my parting thought: in an already golden year of newcomers, Petruce et al. is one of the best.

    Chef-owners Jonathan Petruce, center, and Justin Petruce, right, discuss Petruce et al. at (Also pictured: partner Tim Kweeder.) 




    Inquirer Restaurant Critic
    We encourage respectful comments but reserve the right to delete anything that doesn't contribute to an engaging dialogue.
    Help us moderate this thread by flagging comments that violate our guidelines.

    Comment policy: comments are intended to be civil, friendly conversations. Please treat other participants with respect and in a way that you would want to be treated. You are responsible for what you say. And please, stay on topic. If you see an objectionable post, please report it to us using the "Report Abuse" option.

    Please note that comments are monitored by staff. We reserve the right at all times to remove any information or materials that are unlawful, threatening, abusive, libelous, defamatory, obscene, vulgar, pornographic, profane, indecent or otherwise objectionable. Personal attacks, especially on other participants, are not permitted. We reserve the right to permanently block any user who violates these terms and conditions.

    Additionally comments that are long, have multiple paragraph breaks, include code, or include hyperlinks may not be posted.

    Read 0 comments
    comments powered by Disqus
    Latest Videos:
    Also on
    letter icon Newsletter