Friday, February 12, 2016

Tumult at the top in turbulent times

The rapid turnover of many senior executives is a reflection of the downturn.

Manny, Moe & Jack in September welcomed Michael R. Odell as the fifth chief executive officer in as many years. One analyst said companies tended to change leadership during downturns or upticks — during times of change — but not at the bottom, when they fear that “CEO change might accelerate problems.”<br />
Manny, Moe & Jack in September welcomed Michael R. Odell as the fifth chief executive officer in as many years. One analyst said companies tended to change leadership during downturns or upticks — during times of change — but not at the bottom, when they fear that “CEO change might accelerate problems.” MICHAEL BRYANT / Staff Photographer
Manny, Moe & Jack in September welcomed Michael R. Odell as the fifth chief executive officer in as many years. One analyst said companies tended to change leadership during downturns or upticks — during times of change — but not at the bottom, when they fear that “CEO change might accelerate problems.”<br /> Gallery: Tumult at the top in turbulent times

Even in the tumultuous world of executive recruiting, banker Paul A. Perrault holds an impressive distinction.

Perrault lasted exactly 27 days as chief executive officer of Sovereign Bancorp Inc. - going from lauded to ousted at warp speed.

Now a new CEO heads Sovereign, the $78 billion bank ostensibly headquartered in Philadelphia, but actually run out of Boston with major operations in Reading and a corporate parent in Spain.

Perrault did not spend much time pounding the pavement looking for a new job.

More coverage
  • Top 100 Home Page
  • Feature stories on the Top 100
  • Even the biggest took some big bites
  • Tumult at the top in turbulent times
  • Comcast aims for Net gains
  • Retailers squeezed by new frugality
  • Investment funds tougher to obtain
  • Profiles: Those making the smart moves
  • Guiding Children's Hospital to a $60M budget cut
  • Aramark making schools leaner and greener
  • 'We're doing OK,' Wawa chief says
  • On the front line for US Airways management
  • Small is beautiful for the Subaru brand
  • Interactive charts on Top 100
  • Highest-paid CEOs
  • Local companies by total return
  • Market cap
  • Private and nonprofit employers
  • Photo Gallery: Top 25 highest-paid CEOs
  • On March 16, about six weeks after Sovereign sent him packing, Perrault started his new job in Boston, as chief executive of a smaller banking company, Brookline Bancorp Inc., with $2.6 billion in assets.

    That kind of quick turnaround is unusual, recruiters say. "These positions are few and far between," said Sally Stetson, founder of the executive-search firm Salveson Stetson Group Inc., of Radnor.

    And with the economy in an uproar, boards are subjecting new hires to much more intense scrutiny. "It creates that much more pressure to deliver on results," she said.

    It has been a busy year in executive suites in the Philadelphia area, with some departures reflecting the tough challenges of the economy.

    In April, Charming Shoppes Inc. picked New York turnaround manager James P. Fogarty to replace Dorrit J. Bern, who resigned last summer under pressure from activist investors angry about the company's declining profits and her pay.

    Three money-losing years at Unisys Corp., of Blue Bell, led to Joseph W. McGrath's departure in September. He was replaced in October by J. Edward Coleman, who polished Gateway Inc. for sale.

    In September, as profits declined at the Pep Boys - Manny, Moe & Jack, Michael R. Odell became the Philadelphia company's fifth chief executive since the departure of longtime head Mitchell Leibovitz in May 2003. In that same month, David P. Holveck took over as chief executive at Endo Pharmaceuticals Holdings Inc., of Chadds Ford.

    DuPont Co. picked Ellen Kullman as its new chief executive. She joined the Delaware company in September. Philadelphia's Sunoco Inc. also tapped a seasoned female executive, Lynn Laverty Elsenhans, to replace John G. Drosdick, who retired as chief executive in August.

    The economy has altered the climate for recruiting for executives and for corporate boards, according to experts. Consider:

    Top executives are being kept on exceedingly short leashes, by their boards and by government regulations.

    "There's a lot of scrutiny, and shareholder pressure, and media pressure, and it's a tough environment, and they've lost some control, too," said Judith M. von Seldeneck, chairwoman of Diversified Search Odgers Berndtson, an executive-recruiting firm in Philadelphia.

    One top area financial official confessed to a local business executive that when he goes to parties, he tells people he is a baker, not a banker.

    "When they hear he is a chief executive of a bank, there is all this negative conversation," the local executive said, relating the story. "He's sick of getting all the grief."

    It is too early for female business advocates to break out the champagne, but more women are landing on corporate boards. In 2009's first quarter, 38 percent of the newly nominated board members were women, according to a study by Directors & Boards, a journal of corporate governance based in Philadelphia.

    "That's a jaw-dropping statistic," said James Kristie, editor and associate publisher of the journal.

    "A financial crisis like we are in now will destroy the remaining vestiges of an old boys' club," he said. "I think that creates opportunities at the board level for new kinds of people."

    In January, for example, Acme Markets Inc. president Judith A. Spires joined the board of Met-Pro Corp., a Harleysville manufacturing company.

    Companies are asking their executives to limit their participation on other corporate boards - even though some board participation can provide valuable outside perspective to executives.

    "The desire [to serve] is there," von Seldeneck said. "The real problem is time."

    Even though chief executives bring highly valued expertise to boards, their own boards want them to mind the store at their own companies, especially now that board service is much more demanding.

    "It used to be two hours over lunch," von Seldeneck said. "Now it can be most of a day, or even two days. Busy executives don't have the time. Boards meet more frequently. And it's worse if you have to travel.

    "You have to participate and understand complex financial information," she said. "If you just sit there and play with your BlackBerry, you won't last long."

    Some of the churn in executive turnover appears to be abating, said John Challenger, chief executive officer of Challenger, Gray & Christmas Inc., the Chicago outplacement company.

    Challenger said that fewer changes were made in April than in any month since December 2004.

    "Right now, because the economy is so bad, companies are struggling to survive. They aren't pushing out CEOs. They are battening down the hatches and holding on," he said. "CEO change might accelerate problems.

    "Turnover accelerates during changes in the economy's direction. When things start to get worse or start to get better, new kinds of CEOs are needed. In a down period, you move to financially oriented CEOs who cut costs and who act cautiously," he said. "When the economy starts to improve, you want CEOs who are growth-oriented."

    At the same time, executives are not all that willing to jump ship.

    "It has to be a really compelling opportunity," Stetson said. As daunting as their situations may be, at least the pitfalls are known. "There is so much turmoil in the market," she said. A new company may have hidden, reputation-destroying minefields.

    Indeed, all the scrutiny is making seasoned executives less willing to raise their hands to lead public companies, especially now that compensation is being curtailed, the experts said. Given the intense demands of the job in this climate, chances for success are slimmer.

    "They want to leave when they are on top of their game," Stetson said. "It doesn't feel good to leave when a company is not performing, and they are not performing."


    Contact staff writer Jane M. Von Bergen at 215-854-2769 or



    We encourage respectful comments but reserve the right to delete anything that doesn't contribute to an engaging dialogue.
    Help us moderate this thread by flagging comments that violate our guidelines.

    Comment policy: comments are intended to be civil, friendly conversations. Please treat other participants with respect and in a way that you would want to be treated. You are responsible for what you say. And please, stay on topic. If you see an objectionable post, please report it to us using the "Report Abuse" option.

    Please note that comments are monitored by staff. We reserve the right at all times to remove any information or materials that are unlawful, threatening, abusive, libelous, defamatory, obscene, vulgar, pornographic, profane, indecent or otherwise objectionable. Personal attacks, especially on other participants, are not permitted. We reserve the right to permanently block any user who violates these terms and conditions.

    Additionally comments that are long, have multiple paragraph breaks, include code, or include hyperlinks may not be posted.

    Read 0 comments
    comments powered by Disqus
    Also on
    letter icon Newsletter