Just got this nice e-mail from reader Milton Trachtenburg, a therapist who spent his career helping abused women and who wrote a few books in that field. Tarchtenburg liked today's column about former state welfare department appointee Robert Patterson, who believes that the best-raised chldren are those with a stay-at-home mom.
Not that there's anything wrong with stay-at-home moms. A woman's choice is no one's business but her own. But what's with the vilification of working moms?
Anyway, with Milton's permission (and with my thanks), here is his Milton's personal perspective on having a wife who worked while their kids were growing up.
Hit it, Milton!
"Dear Ms. Polaneczky:
"I loved your skewering of Mr Patterson and his 14th Century views of motherhood, women's rights and sperm utility.
"I'm just contemplating where my wife and I would be today if it weren't for the contribution her teacher's pension makes to our overall financial welfare. It certainly wouldn't be in Miami Beach with a view of the ocean to stimulate us to live longer than the view from the hovel we would have been able to afford without it!
"Our son must have suffered the tribulations of Hell in a youth which "forced" him to learn how to cook, be a latchkey kid and make independent decisions from an early age---as his father also did in his misanthropic youth in a two-parent working family. Our son was so badly destroyed that he pursued his dream of becoming an entertainer and raising his daughter the same way so that she is now an independent 18-year old with her own band, Supercute!, which performs internationally.
"My wife, defined by a superlative professional work history, gave the two of us more to talk about than how many bon-bons she consumed watching soap operas. She never did need an antidepressant because her life was fulfilling at work and at home, as was mine. Now in early retirement, she got the itch to do more professionally so she opened a little tutoring practice and was asked to consider a part-time job in one of the elite private schools here in Florida. So much for the fulfilling life of a retiree. Volunteering or serving time in "women's" organizations with a bunch of former housefraus whose whole life is showing off pictures of their children and grandchildren or giving "organ recitals" about their latest medical incursions, are not her idea of a fulfilling life, even in retirement.
"She has taught three generations of children how to read and has worked successfully with some of the most difficult problems that no one else seemed able to solve as well as written one of the seminal articles in her field which has been quoted in dozens of textbooks as recently as one written in 2010. Before we moved to Florida in 2010, she constantly had adults approach her in restaurants or stores to thank her for what she did for them years earlier and still has dozens of teachers contacting her to help them resolve current problems.
"Had Mr Patterson had his way, this remarkable woman would have spent her life doing nothing of value. We managed to complete all the chores somehow amongst us and that is what they were---chores. I wish for Mr Patterson exactly the kind of wife he wished upon the rest of us men: Someone who demonstrates no brains, no confidence, no independent will and he can rot in the hell he created by doing so.
"Again, thanks for casting a light upon a particularly dark and ugly corner of our so-called civilized society."
"this remarkable woman would have spent her life doing nothing of value"...."how many bon-bons she consumed watching soap operas"...."serving time in "women's" organizations with a bunch of former housefraus whose whole life is showing off pictures of their children and grandchildren". This guy is a total jag off. I suspect a lot of stay at home Mom's would have an issue with these profiles. jimmymack
Comment removed.
Wow..... I read your column on Mr. Patterson and I though you did a nice job all on your own refuting his positions. Deciding to add this letter to reinforce your position was a mistake. I am sure Mr. Tarchtenburg's wife is every bit the wonderful woman he describes. I would also venture a guess that even she would shudder at the condescending stereotypes of stay-at-home moms laced throughout his letter. It is a shame that for all his education - Mr Tarchtenburg couldn't just praise his wife without heaping scorn on those who choose (for whatever reason), to remain at home and care for their children on a full-time basis. You ripped Mr. Patterson for his positions...... this guy's letter deserves the same treatment. oddball63
This guy is a therapist? He sounds like he needs a therapist and his disdain for those who sacrifice so their kids can be the focus of their lives, as they should be for their first 18 or so years, is palpable. This guy needs to take his head out of his tuchus and see the world around him. This guy is trying to be taller by stepping on others, which is never the right thing. Stay at home mothers provide an irreplaceable experience but this guy seems to have put his comfort above those of his latchkey kid. bgpoppapump
- Ronnie Polaneczky columns from the Daily News
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- December 2011
- November 2011
- October 2011
- September 2011
- August 2011
- July 2011
- June 2011
- May 2011
- April 2011
- March 2011
- February 2011
- January 2011
- December 2010
- November 2010
- October 2010
- September 2010
- August 2010
- July 2010
- June 2010
- May 2010
- April 2010
- February 2010
- January 2010
- December 2009
- November 2009
- October 2009
- July 2009
- June 2009
- March 2009
- February 2009
- January 2009
- December 2008
- November 2008















