A lesson for the Philadelphia Union: why starting a season strong matters in Major League Soccer
Officially, the Philadelphia Union were eliminated from the playoff race at the end of September. Unofficially, we know that their hopes of a second consecutive postseason berth died much earlier than that.
A lesson for the Philadelphia Union: why starting a season strong matters in Major League Soccer
Jonathan Tannenwald, Philly.com
Officially, the Philadelphia Union were eliminated from the playoff race at the end of September. Unofficially, we know that their hopes of a second consecutive postseason berth died much earlier than that.
I've spent a lot of time in recent weeks thinking about the roots of why this year has been so disappointing for Union fans. You can come up with any number of answers both on the field and off it, and I'm sure you all can do just that.
But if I had to pick just one thing to focus on, I'd go with this: a poor start to the season from which the team never had a chance to recover.
This hasn't just been a problem for the Union. Columbus, Montréal, Dallas and Portland also struggled early in the year and couldn't make up for it. Columbus and Dallas came close, finishing just outside the playoff spots in their respective divisions; and Montréal was also in the playoff race for longer than anyone expected.
The Union's lack of results early in the season were particularly significant, though. They played 11 games from March through May, and recorded just one win and two draws. Last year, by contrast, they also played 11 games from March through May, but recorded six wins and two draws.
That's 15 points off the board before Memorial Day. And while the current gap between the Union and fifth-place Houston is more than 15 points, it's hard to imagine that there wouldn't have been an impact if this year had started like last year.
Here's something else that I find striking. Once the 10 teams that qualified for this year's MLS Cup playoffs were finalized. I went to look up the MLS standings on the first weekday of each month of the season. I found that most of those teams have spent a very long time this year in the playoff places.
Although the seedings haven't been finalized in the Eastern Conference, the 10 teams that will participate in this year's postseason are these:
Eastern Conference: Sporting Kansas City, D.C. United, Chicago Fire, New York Red Bulls, Houston Dynamo
Western Conference: San Jose Earthquakes, Seattle Sounders, Real Salt Lake, Los Angeles Galaxy, Vancouver Whitecaps
The breakdown of how the standings looked at the start of each month of the season, from April onward, is as follows:
Monday, April 2: 7 of 10 teams currently in playoff places
Eastern Conference
1. Sporting Kansas City, 12 points from 4 games
2. New York Red Bulls, 6 points from 4 games
3. Columbus Crew, 6 points from 3 games
4. Houston Dynamo, 6 points from 3 games
5. New England Revolution, 6 points from 4 games
Western Conference
1. Real Salt Lake, 9 points from 4 games
2. San Jose Earthquakes, 9 points from 4 games
3. Colorado Rapids, 9 points from 4 games
4. Vancouver Whitecaps, 8 points from 2 games
5. Seattle Sounders, 6 points from 2 games
Tuesday, May 1: 9 of 10 teams currently in playoff places
Eastern Conference
1. Sporting Kansas City, 21 points from 8 games
2. D.C. United, 15 points from 9 games
3. New York Red Bulls, 13 points from 8 games
4. Chicago Fire: 8 points from 6 games
5. Houston Dynamo, 8 points from 6 games
Western Conference
1. San Jose Earthquakes, 19 points from 8 games
2. Real Salt Lake, 19 points from 10 games
3. Vancouver Whitecaps, 14 points from 8 games
4. Seattle Sounders, 13 points from 6 games
5. Colorado Rapids, 12 points from 8 games
Friday, June 1: 8 of 10 teams currently in playoff places
Eastern Conference
1. D.C. United, 27 points from 15 games
2. New York Red Bulls, 26 points from 13 games
3. Sporting Kansas City, 25 points from 12 games
4. Columbus Crew, 18 points from 12 games
5. Chicago Fire, 18 points from 12 games
Western Conference
1. Real Salt Lake, 29 points from 14 games
2. San Jose Earthquakes, 27 points from 15 games
3. Seattle Sounders, 24 points from 13 games
4. Colorado Rapids, 19 points from 13 games
5. Vancouver Whitecaps, 19 points from 12 games
Monday, July 2: 9 of 10 teams currently in playoff places
Eastern Conference
1. D.C. United, 33 points from 18 games
2. New York Red Bulls, 31 points from 17 games
3. Sporting Kansas City, 29 points from 16 games
4. Chicago Fire, 27 points from 17 games
5. Houston Dynamo, 23 points from 16 games
Western Conference
1. San Jose Earthquakes, 36 points from 17 games
2. Real Salt Lake, 32 points from 18 games
3. Seattle Sounders, 26 points from 17 games
4. Vancouver Whitecaps, 26 points from 16 games
5. Colorado Rapids, 22 points from 16 games
Wednesday, August 1: 10 of 10 teams currently in playoff places
Eastern Conference
1. New York Red Bulls, 38 points from 22 games
2. Houston Dynamo, 37 points from 22 games
3. Sporting Kansas City, 37 points from 22 games
4. D.C. United, 33 points from 21 games
5. Chicago Fire, 32 points from 21 games
Western Conference
1. San Jose Earthquakes, 44 points from 23 games
2. Real Salt Lake, 42 points from 23 games
3. Seattle Sounders, 34 points from 21 games
4. Vancouver Whitecaps, 34 points from 23 games
5. Los Angeles Galaxy, 33 points from 23 games
Tuesday, September 4: 9 of 10 teams currently in playoff places
Eastern Conference
1. Sporting Kansas City, 50 points from 27 games
2. New York Red Bulls, 46 points from 27 games
3. Chicago Fire, 44 points from 26 games
4. Houston Dynamo, 42 points from 27 games
5. Columbus Crew, 42 points from 26 games
Western Conference
1. San Jose Earthquakes, 53 points from 27 games
2. Real Salt Lake, 46 points from 28 games
3. Seattle Sounders, 44 points from 26 games
4. Los Angeles Galaxy, 43 points from 28 games
5. Vancouver Whitecaps, 37 points from 28 games
Monday, October 1: 10 of 10 teams in playoff places
Eastern Conference
1. Sporting Kansas City, 58 points from 31 games*
2. New York Red Bulls, 53 points from 31 games
3. Chicago Fire, 53 points from 30 games
4. D.C. United, 51 points from 31 games
5. Houston Dynamo, 49 points from 31 games
Western Conference
1. San Jose Earthquakes, 61 points from 31 games*
2. Real Salt Lake, 52 points from 31 games*
3. Los Angeles Galaxy, 50 points from 31 games*
4. Seattle Sounders, 49 points from 30 games*
5. Vancouver Whitecaps, 39 points from 31 games
* - clinched playoff berth at that point
I realize that this set of data doesn't represent every point in the season, but I think it's a pretty reasonable sample.
What the data show to me, is this: from April on, at least seven of the 10 teams currently in the playoff places were in the playoff places at the points measured as well. That the number was as high as nine of 10 as early as May 1 - and never dropped below nine after July 1 - really shows you something.
The only team that's in the playoffs now but wasn't on May 1 is the Los Angeles Galaxy. The biggest reason why is that at that point in the year, defender Omar Gonzalez was still recovering from an offseason ACL injury. Gonzalez didn't get on to the field until July 4 - against the Union, coincidentally.
In addition, star forward Robbie Keane was trying to avoid getting injured ahead of the European Championships, where he played for the Republic of Ireland
So with all this said, let's come back to the Union. What caused their poor start to the year? There are a lot of possibilities.
Was it Peter Nowak? Was it the offseason departures of Faryd Mondragón and Sébastien Le Toux? Was it Lionard Pajoy and Porfirio Lopez turning out to not be nearly as good as advertised? Was it Danny Califf regressing early in the year after a strong campaign in 2011? Was it Zac MacMath's concussion problems?
You could point to all those things and more besides.
So many things, from success on the field to psychology in the locker room, can come from starting a season well. If you're a Union supporter, you have to hope that 2013 brings better results early on than 2012 did.
If the Union start next season poorly, though, you have to wonder what will happen to the organization, both on the field and in the stands. The Union have struggled mightily in two of their first three years of existence. That doesn't help when competing for fans' attention and money in one of the nation's most ruthless sports markets.
Every MLS team has little margin for error, but the Union's is especially small at the moment. Recent results have brought reasons for optimism, especially Jack McInerney's recent scoring streak.
The hardest work, though - the work that will really get the team where it wants to be next year - is still to come.
Too me it was simply Ownership and Management selling off the teams leadership on and off the field. That won't fly in any city let alone Philly...........— Earl J
Next year, a fresh start after bankruptcy and leaving town. I am sure the Kalamazoo Kangaroos will jump off to a fast start next year.— HappyBob- Good one Happy Bob. Too bad it's like the tenth time you have used that one. I don't know you, but I do...you are the guy who says something he thinks is clever out loud, and then repeats it over and over again until someone acknowledges what you have said...with that cringing uncomfortable feeling because what you said was lame. Yeah...that's you Bob. — emoshg
- Kalamazoo Kangaroos!!!! classic— SJDevilBoy
-1.jpg)
Soccer Blows!!!- The loss of so much before the season began had the most to do with the poor start not just the start itself. They'd just come off of a playoff appearance then Nowak ruins the team under the watchful eye of Sackiewicz and the ownership group. The team was not mentally unprepared to start the season. I'll say this again. This team needs to be built for this top sports market. The youth movement is nice considering it's all that they were left with. However, as one of the largest media markets this team needs to step up the talent during the off season. Don't be fooled by the little run at the last part of this season. If the team relies on the same group of smurfs they will catch no one by surprise next season. McInerney should be a starter but he will need a strong multidimensional scoring threat with him up front to play off of. This of course is only the beginning of what this team needs to do moving forward.— LCBline
- Easy answer to your question, Jon. The season was lost in January when Nowak pulled his LeToux power play and jettisoned one of the core leaders, on and off the field, for nothing. The Union on its team website compared Sebastien/Union to Brian Dawkins/Eagles. He was the heart and soul of this franchise. Now I do not pretend to suggest that Seba was a world class talent. Here he was just a big fish in a small pond. But he meant everything to a team trying to establish itself in the hearts of a major league fan base. The exodus continued afterward as one fan favorite after another was sent packing.
As constituted a year ago, the team was not going to win a championship. But they had a chance to build around core character players and blew it.
The Flyers won 7 years after expansion by adding star players: HOF'ers Clarke, Parent, Barber and players like MacLeish, Flett, Lonsberry, etc. But the core character guys there at the beginning were still here. Van Impe, Dornhofer, Watson, Nolet...were not stars but they provided base upon which the team was built. Sure, no Clarke, no cup. But in year three, who was to say that a Union star wouldn't develop this year or next.
Major League Soccer is anything but major. Watch top soccer on TV and you'll see that MLS is third or fourth tier at best. Still, the Union had a quality product and was developing a loyal fan base and then they dismantled it for no perceivable reason. I will be spending my money elsewhere.— RememberTheMaine - A poor start isn't necessarily the end. Kansas City started last season 1-6-3 while waiting for its stadium to open and won the conference. Of course, it also had players like Jimmy Nielsen, Matt Besler, Julio Cesar, Roger Espinoza, Graham Zusi, Kei Kamara and C.J. Sapong, all superior to their Philly counterparts.— ridgemont
- Nowak doomed this season, both on and off the field.— emoshg
- zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz— Handsome B. Wonderful
- Can you say "designated player?" Apparently the Union can't. Freddy Adu is our only DP. I believe we are the 4th or 5th largest market in the league. Just as in baseball a team must have strength and talent up the middle. That means GK, central defender, playmaking midfielder and pure striker. McInerny can be that striker, but the well is almost dry at those other key positions. Can't we get an EPL or Bundesliga player with something left in his tank to fill one or more of those holes? The season was lost in January, not only because the Doop Dope sent LeToux away but also because the front office did not act during the European transfer window.— lmscdad
Reach Jonathan at jtannenwald@phillynews.com or 215-854-2330.
