Prognosis for Cliff Lee's return

The Phillies announced pitcher Cliff Lee was heading to the 15-day disabled list due to what have become the two most feared words in Major League Baseball—“elbow strain.”

Recently, a long list of pitchers have headed to the disabled list with similar ailments, only to be diagnosed with the dreaded ulnar collateral ligament (UCL) tear, the condition that leads to Tommy John Surgery.

Fortunately, that’s not the case for Lee, who went as far as to specify that his injury was “not a Tommy John thing.” What Lee has is a grade 1/2 left elbow strain, a condition that will likely have him out a little longer than the 15 days he’s required to sit.

“A Grade 1 or 2 strain indicates a muscular issue—not a ligament,” says Brian Cammarota, M.Ed, A.T.C., C.S.C.S., C.E.S. of Symetrix Sports Performance and OAA Orthopedics.  “On the inside of the elbow you have four muscles—he likely strained those muscles, which is fairly common.”

So it’s a sigh of relief for Phillies fans, right? “Every situation is a little bit different, so there are no guarantees,” cautions Cammarota. “But when you hear elbow strain… if I had to choose, this is the injury you would want him to have.”

That said, any injury to a pitcher has to be taken seriously. “Shoulder, elbow—any time you’re feeling pain in these areas, your body is telling you something,” says Cammarota. “It could be as simple as fatigue. I know he’s thrown a few starts since the problem started, so that tells me they’ve been trying to manage it, but things haven’t improved.”

Indeed, Lee initially felt discomfort more than a month ago while pitching against the Atlanta Braves. He has continued to pitch with the aid of anti-inflammatories since that time, but now will take a full week off from any type of throwing before starting the process that the Phillies hope will see him back on the mound by mid-June.

“For a Grade 1 strain, a week off is the first cut-off to use,” adds Cammarota. “After five, six days you re-evaluate and if there’s no pain, you can begin a throwing program and try to progress from there.”

“But if he’s taking a week off from throwing, I would think it will be at least three weeks until he returns to game action.”

Read more Sports Doc for Sports Medicine and Fitness.