Tuesday, February 9, 2016

"Football on trial": America's pride or America's shame?

Last night, the College of Physicians of Philadelphia hosted a round-table discussion on concussions in football and what they mean for the game's future.

"Football on trial": America's pride or America's shame?

Dr. Paul Butler voted to ban football in his New Hampshire school district, while Dr. Doug Swift won two Super Bowls before turning his attention to medicine.
Dr. Paul Butler voted to ban football in his New Hampshire school district, while Dr. Doug Swift won two Super Bowls before turning his attention to medicine. Robert Senior / Philly.com

On Tuesday night, three accomplished doctors from three very different backgrounds convened at the College of Physicians of Philadelphia to discuss the issue of head injuries in football.

The talk, entitled “Football: America’s Pride or America’s Shame?” featured Doug Swift, MD, who won two Super Bowls with the Miami Dolphins of the 1970s before turning his attention to medicine as an anesthesiologist; H. Branch Coslett, MD, professor in neurology at the Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania; and Paul Butler, MD, a retired surgeon who gained fame—or notoriety, depending on your stance—by voting to end football in his local school district, where he served as a board member.

The title of the talk “America’s Pride or America’s Shame?” didn’t seem to leave much room for a middle ground, but in the end the highlight of the presentation was its non-judgmental approach to accepting that there is a large gray area in the entire discussion. Football players, coaches, doctors, even opponents of the sport were able to walk away saying they’d learned something, and hopefully with a greater understanding of the other side of the debate.

Each presenter gave an individual presentation lasting about 15 minutes, with Dr. Coslett leading off. He spoke at length about Chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE) and what we’ve learned about the condition since it became widely associated with retired football players. His answer? We haven’t learned enough.

Dr. Coslett offered an opinion that the condition is ‘grossly underdiagnosed’, showing a statistic that some 50 percent of retired boxers present signs of CTE. But the statistics led to the most interesting portion of his talk.

“Why those 50 percent, and not the other 50 percent?” he asked. “Well, we don’t know just yet. That’s the next step—the work that will go into finding the risk factors for CTE, and who might be at greater risk for developing CTE.”

Only then will people be able to make more informed decisions about football on an individual basis. “Should you play football? Maybe, maybe not,” concluded Dr. Coslett. “But if we could see the probability of that person developing CTE, that decisions becomes much easier.”

Dr. Doug Swift’s talk began with a proclamation from George Stade, a great admirer of the game of football. “Among sports, [football’s] mode is violence, and violence is its special glory.”

Throughout his talk, Dr. Swift’s love and fondness for football—both as a whole and for his own career—was evident. But his skepticism was also apparent, as he admitted that the question of why someone should play football was “hard for me to answer.”

Dr. Swift did, however, speak of the role football played in helping him to pursue other goals in life. “It helped me get into college, and I feel that playing in the NFL helped me when it came time to apply to medical school,” he said. “For me, football and education went hand-in-hand.”

Dr. Paul Butler is another former football player—albeit one who holds a different opinion on today’s game. While he never played in the NFL, Dr. Butler spoke of his love for the game before declaring, “Football is on trial.”

Throughout the presentation, the current controversy was compared to the early 20th century, when President Teddy Roosevelt led a crusade to clean up the game of football after some 19 player deaths plagued the 1905 college season.

However, Dr. Butler chose to focus on the past 12 years or so, starting with the death of former Pittsburgh Steeler Mike Webster in 2002. Webster’s brain tissue would be examined by Dr. Bennet Omalu, and Webster would become the first football player diagnosed with CTE.

In 2012, Dr. Butler garnered attention by proposing to ban football in his New Hampshire school district. “Unlike other sports, you cannot take the head out of football,” he declared. “To do so would be to reduce the game, essentially, to flag football. It would be fine with me, but I think many fans romanticize and watch for those big hits.”

Dr. Butler has two sons in their early 40s, and said he would have actively encouraged each to pursue football as a youngster, had they been so inclined. “But that was years ago, the early 1990s,” he clarified. “Today, I would do everything in my power to encourage them otherwise.”

Perhaps the overall tone of the talk was captured in the final comments from Dr. Coslett in response to an audience member’s question whether he would encourage someone to play football. “People are now aware of the risks,” he reasoned. “Now, it’s up to each person to decide what they want to do with that awareness.”

Read more Sports Doc for Sports Medicine and Fitness.

We encourage respectful comments but reserve the right to delete anything that doesn't contribute to an engaging dialogue.
Help us moderate this thread by flagging comments that violate our guidelines.

Comment policy:

Philly.com comments are intended to be civil, friendly conversations. Please treat other participants with respect and in a way that you would want to be treated. You are responsible for what you say. And please, stay on topic. If you see an objectionable post, please report it to us using the "Report Abuse" option.

Please note that comments are monitored by Philly.com staff. We reserve the right at all times to remove any information or materials that are unlawful, threatening, abusive, libelous, defamatory, obscene, vulgar, pornographic, profane, indecent or otherwise objectionable. Personal attacks, especially on other participants, are not permitted. We reserve the right to permanently block any user who violates these terms and conditions.

Additionally comments that are long, have multiple paragraph breaks, include code, or include hyperlinks may not be posted.

Read 0 comments
comments powered by Disqus
About this blog

Whether you are a weekend warrior, an aging baby boomer, a student athlete or just someone who wants to stay active, this blog is for you. Read about our growing list of expert contributors here.

J. Ryan Bair, PT, DPT, SCS Founder and Owner of FLASH Sports Physical Therapy, Board Certified in Sports Physical Therapy
Brian Cammarota, ATC, PT, DPT, CSCS Physical Therapist at Good Shepard Penn Partners, Partner at Symetrix Sports Performance
Desirea D. Caucci, PT, DPT, OCS Co-owner of Conshohocken Physical Therapy, Board Certified Orthopedic Clinical Specialist
Michael G. Ciccotti, M.D. Head Team Physician for Phillies & St. Joe's; Rothman Institute
Julie Coté, PT, MPT, OCS, COMT Magee Rehabilitation Hospital
Peter F. DeLuca, M.D. Head Team Physician for Eagles, Head Orthopedic Surgeon for Flyers; Rothman Institute
Brittany Everett Owner, Grace & Glory Yoga Fishtown
Joel H. Fish, Ph.D. Director of The Center For Sport Psychology; Sports Psychology Consultant for 76ers & Flyers
R. Robert Franks, D.O. Team Physician for USA Wrestling, Consultant for Phillies; Rothman Institute
Ashley B. Greenblatt, ACE-CPT Certified Personal Trainer, The Sporting Club at The Bellevue
Jon Herting, PT, DPT, CSCS, HFS, USAW Physical Therapist, Partner at The Training Room
Eugene Hong, MD, CAQSM, FAAFP Team Physician for Drexel, Philadelphia Univ., Saint Joe’s, & U.S. Lacrosse
Brian Maher, BS, CSCS Owner, Philly Personal Training
Julia Mayberry, M.D. Attending Hand & Upper Extremity Surgeon, Main Line Hand Surgery P.C.
Gavin McKay, NASM-CPT Founder/Franchisor, Unite Fitness
Heather Moore, PT, DPT, CKTP Owner of Total Performance Physical Therapy, North Wales and Hatfield, PA
Justin Shaginaw, MPT, ATC Athletic Trainer for US Soccer Federation; Aria 3B Orthopaedic Institute
Thomas Trojian MD, CAQSM, FACSM Chief of the Division of Sports Medicine at Drexel University
Robyn Weisman, ACE-CPT B.S., Exercise Science & Physiology, Certified Personal Trainer, Fitness and Lifestyle Coach
Sarah M. Whitman, MD Sports Psychiatrist; Clinical Assistant Professor, Drexel University College of Medicine
Latest Videos
Also on Philly.com:
letter icon Newsletter