share
email
font size
options
 
Tuesday, March 31, 2009

A name like Gary Sheffield is guaranteed to create buzz, both for and against the idea of bringing him in.  Though the lines of communication are open between the Phillies and the 40-year-old slugger, multiple team sources told the Inquirer that chances of signing Sheffield are, in the words of one official, "very slim."

Ruben Amaro Jr. would only say that the parties had spoken today, and declined to comment whether Sheffield would accept a part-time role.

I posed that last question to Sheffield's agent Rufus Williams a few minutes ago. He said: "As we look for our options over the next few days, we'll decide what the best role will be.  (A part-time role) is not off the table; nothing is off the table."

A few reasons points against Sheffield being a fit with the Phillies:

1. He is not a pinch hitter.

2. He batted .225 last season, albeit with 19 home runs.

3. He is not really an outfielder anymore after playing only six games in the field last season.

4. We have to be careful with character stuff, because sometimes reputations are unfairly assigned. But Sheffield's reputation as a clubhouse influence is not sterling among some in baseball. The Phillies front office values team chemistry very highly, and signed Raul Ibanez partly as a result of this strategy.

Posted by Andy Martino @ 5:44 PM  Permalink | 35 comments
35
Comments   
Posted 05:47 PM, 03/31/2009
smel4727
Andy, When are we going to hear that Moyer or Dubee or spoke with Happ, and Happ totally understands that no team goes through a season with only five starters, and that he is first in line, and the Phillies still love him and the fans are still rooting for him, and he'll have his chance to win games in the bigs?
Posted 06:12 PM, 03/31/2009
KevinRx
Park pitched well in Spring training, great. Happ is young and has a future with this team. He should get the nod.
Posted 06:19 PM, 03/31/2009
JimEisenreich
1. He would be a pinch hitter if the Phils signed him 2. He had a better year than Jenkins 3. And Stairs IS an outfielder? 4. Irrelevant
Posted 06:19 PM, 03/31/2009
philly10
NO SHEFFIELD....HE IS ANOTHER T.O. AND WILL ALSO DESTROY THE TEAM LIKE T.O. DID....THE PHILLIES ARE WORLD CHAMPIONS, WE DON'T NEED SHEFFIELD...GOOGLE "SHEFFIELD CONTROVERSY" AND YOU WILL SEE FOR YOURSELF HOW HE WILL DESTROY THE PHILLIES CLUBHOUSE.
Posted 06:26 PM, 03/31/2009
MD20202020
He's going to stay in the American league as a DH.
Posted 06:33 PM, 03/31/2009
Mark1npt
Sheffield is by far and away a cancer....he is also by far and away the most dangerous RH hitter we could add to our bench. He does scare people and that's what you want lurking in the late innings...you bring him in and the opposing manager is guaranteed to bring in a RP....then the dance begins, lefty, righty until they are all out of LH relievers and our LH pinchhitters blow the game open. He will not be a cancer on this team, he is a small cog and will be respectful of what his teammates have won. He will have to blend in and get along. Cholly and a few other players in that locker room will not tolerate anything else. He isn't a T.O., he can't destroy this Phillies team, and he also wants that 500th HR....what better band box than ours to hit it in?
Posted 06:52 PM, 03/31/2009
CenterCityPhan
I agree with MD20202020 that Sheffield will stay in AL.
Posted 06:52 PM, 03/31/2009
lobstrocities
Ughhhh.... I do NOT want the phils to sign Sheffield. I dont want to hear all the steroid controversey. Plus he seems like a real jerk. Why would they bring a guy like that into such a "team first" lockeroom?
Posted 06:57 PM, 03/31/2009
adman
NO NO NO NO NO!!!
Posted 06:58 PM, 03/31/2009
Wally 24
Mark1npt ... I understand and agree with what you have said. I don't see a need for a righty power hitter on the bench at this point. Our biggest problem last year was not HR production it was a righty with bat control which Cairo seems to be for now.
Posted 07:00 PM, 03/31/2009
Brauny
What has Sheffield done since he stopped juicing? Who needs him? Not the Phils!
Posted 07:02 PM, 03/31/2009
Neal Obstat
Is Sheffield any good without steroids at this ripe old age?
Posted 07:08 PM, 03/31/2009
Charlie Mustgo
Please never use the term "We" in your blogs Mr. Martino. "We" are not carpet baggers like yourself. "We" are die hard Philly sports fans. "We" will question Sheffield's character all "we" want.
Posted 07:08 PM, 03/31/2009
been banned 3 times
"A few reasons points against...", why not just put an S at the end of every word andy?
Posted 07:15 PM, 03/31/2009
AtlanticDJN
Look we all know that Sheff has power and is a decent hitter, but he won't fit in with this clubhouse AT ALL.. He belongs in the AL as a DH and not coming off the bench.. My thoughts: "If it ain't broke, don't fix it"
About Andy Martino
Andy Martino is in his first season on the Phillies beat. A former New York City public school teacher and graduate of the Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism, he previously wrote for the New York Daily News, where he covered baseball and worked with the award-winning investigative sports "I-team."
PHILLIES SCOREBOARD