share
email
font size
options
 
Thursday, July 9, 2009

You know what’s way more important than the silly marketing campaign to elect All-Stars, or trade rumors? Performance-enhancing drugs, both as an issue of public health and competitive integrity.   

If the Manny Ramirez circus has proven anything this season, it is that penalties for steroid use are not nearly severe enough. The guy cheats his way to a big contract, then is cheered in every rehab start and upon his return to the Dodgers. Fox showed a troubling lack of judgement by treating his at-bats Saturday as news events, showing him on a split screen. You know what I’m thinking if I’m Manny? That was worth it.
 
Yet, the AP reports that MLB chafed at legitimate criticism of its program. I thought I’d pass this story along, for those who might be looking for a brief change of pace from the topics du jour, and something else to think about.
 
Of course, the Roy Halladay drama is also quite intruiging and real, so click here for the post on Blue Jays GM J.P. Ricciardi.  And take a nap until 4pm, when this whole ad campaign will be over and, thank goodness, we will never have to hear the phrase "Bran Torino" again.
Posted by Andy Martino @ 1:02 PM  Permalink | 22 comments
22
Comments   
Posted 12:34 PM, 07/10/2009
Dierte
JimEisenreich - you should be suspended from posting on here for having that name...
Posted 11:26 AM, 07/10/2009
CenterCityPhan
Athletes are defacto role models for kids who admire and look up to them. Maybe some don't embrace that role, but it's real. Ask J-Roll and and Ryan; they understand their responsibility. Of course, parents are the main influencers. There also is the affect of cheating on the integrity of the game. It matters.
Posted 10:04 AM, 07/10/2009
smel4727
Addendum on my "role model" comment: Athletes are not role models. And I am the father of a two year old who took his daughter to her first game at age 7-months and who watched the Parade in October. I and her mother are her primary role models. I love the Phillies but athletes as role models? That's my job.
Posted 09:59 AM, 07/10/2009
smel4727
Competitive balance? I want to see the best athletes perform as well as they can. Matt Stairs seems like a hell of a nice guy and I love that he's on the Phils but there's a reason he isn't in the All-Star Game this year. He's not the best. Give me bigger, stronger. This is sports. Athletes are our post-modern superhero-warriors. They aren't role models - they are paid athletes who entertain me with how well they play baseball for which I pay them money in the form of tickets and merchandise purchases.
Posted 08:50 AM, 07/10/2009
Mark1npt
Jason are you 14? WADA is the way to go. Singular punishment worldwide for every offense in every sport should be the goal. Cheaters should be made to suffer mightily, I don't care if TV ratings go down. It's (WADA's policy is) the only true deterrant. Public shame doesn't work anymore, they're all guilty and the public doesn't care. look ar this board......and look at the media for celebrating Manny RAMIREZ the way they did. Pitiful.
Posted 08:44 AM, 07/10/2009
Mark1npt
MrDip, your name fits.....
Posted 07:07 AM, 07/10/2009
spinmeister
To the apologists and proponents of PED use in professional sports: Those who use are liars and cheaters. They diminish the sport they are privileged to play. They provide horrible role models for our youth. The users aren't the victims. Stop defending the cheaters!
Posted 03:55 AM, 07/10/2009
jason14
Criticism of drug policy from WADA is like criticism of communists from Joe McCarthy. And forget the 162 games scenario, JimEisenreich - a truly punitive system (like WADA prefers in bicycling and Olympics) would vacate the Phillies' world championship entirely - perhaps with good reason, because if you truly believe this stuff affects competitive balance seriously. Because it's a fact that JC Romero benefited from a PED, regardless of his intent. I happen to not believe that myself - you certainly can't convince me Manny Rodriguez isn't as good a hitter as there is with or without fertility drugs - so I'll continue to enjoy the championship - and continue to enjoy watching Chase Utley do commercials for a supplement that, while 100% on the up-and-up, is still part of the same impulse and same subculture that burned JC.
Posted 10:40 PM, 07/09/2009
JimEisenreich
steroids arent dangerous if you take them properly...and you seriously want romero out 162 games for what he did? are you insane?
Posted 09:22 PM, 07/09/2009
PSU DEJA BLUE
My suggestion on penalty, keep the current system!! However, ban all guilty parties from ALL all-star games and post-season awards for THREE YEARS. Therefore, Manny wouldn't be eligible to be on the all-star ballot or participate in its activities, and he wouldn't be eligible for MVP and other awards for 2009, 2010 and 2011.
Posted 08:41 PM, 07/09/2009
mrdip
I'm with smel4727, atheletes have cheated since a the dawn of time. I'm still not sure that stroids have really enhanced a ball players ability to compete - help recover/prevent injuries maybe - but most of the increased power numbers have come from smaller hitter friendly ballparks and overall lousy pitching staffs.....
Posted 08:24 PM, 07/09/2009
KMG
I think two years is too severe for a first offense- if you want to increase it, make it 80 games for the first and 1 calendar year for the second. I also agree, no minor league games until the suspension is over- this isn't like rehabbing from an injury.
Posted 08:13 PM, 07/09/2009
catnameddomino
Make it like other sports like cycling. If you fail one time, you get a 2 year ban. Put the same rule in place for all the sports - I don't care. I doubt that Manny or anyone else would think it was worth it then.
Posted 07:39 PM, 07/09/2009
mick314
Castration would work. End of story.
Posted 06:48 PM, 07/09/2009
Lako
Good post, Andy. But what has me upset at this moment is an article I just read that says Amaro is negotiating with Pedro Martinez's agent. To paraphrase Cheech & Chong--are you out of your @#$%^&*()_ MIND???????
Posted 04:48 PM, 07/09/2009
oldecityslicker
Andy, thanks for the comments on the Manny /split screen. It was ridiculous on so many levels. As long as all the people who make money off these guys turn a blind eye, the players will continue to find ways to circumvent the system.
Posted 04:16 PM, 07/09/2009
fly eagles fly
My solution: if you test positive, then your current contract and every contract thereafter becomes non-guaranteed. They can still earn a living, but they give up security.
Posted 04:13 PM, 07/09/2009
danielswolf
Why should MLB have a stricter standard than any other professional sport? In the NFL, you get four games for the first violation even if you've tested postitive for cocaine... 25% of their season. MLB sends you to the clubhouse for over 30% of the season. Where is the outrage over the NFL's weak punishment system? Hypocrites.
Posted 02:55 PM, 07/09/2009
celtic_13
I agree that 50 games is not enough. A season-long suspension for the first positive test. And players should not be able to play in the minors as their 50 game MLB nears an end. They should be able to start their minor league assignment once the 50 MLB games expire and no earlier
Posted 02:10 PM, 07/09/2009
smel4727
I really don't care if players use steroids. From a health standpoint, it's unhealthy but it's their business. I just hate the Bud Selig-glossy "We had no idea in 1998!" spin campaign. Instead, return the pitcher's mound to pre-1968 15-inches and push the outfield walls back to where they used to be. Shibe Park in 1950 was 447 to center field.
Posted 01:28 PM, 07/09/2009
Palestra Jon
Actually, you cannot justifiably increase penalties for performance enhancing drugs until everyone who has done them is outed. It was ridiculous that A-Rod's name was leaked when there are over 100 other names on that list. Once there is full disclosure, then you can institute onerous penalties on anyone who is caught going forward. At this point, the fans simply expect that anyone could be a user and they don't really care. Look at the enduring love in this town for the roided up '93 Phils and the greenied up '80 Phils.
Posted 01:16 PM, 07/09/2009
Dan in Holmesburg
Andy, you should do this type of thing more often which shows your true personality. I think to myself as I read sometimes that you and Murph write about the same thing too often. This is a good way to add something and not rehash the same stuff over and over and over on a slow news day.
About Andy Martino
Andy Martino is in his first season on the Phillies beat. A former New York City public school teacher and graduate of the Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism, he previously wrote for the New York Daily News, where he covered baseball and worked with the award-winning investigative sports "I-team."
PHILLIES SCOREBOARD