Monday, December 29, 2014

Coghlan wins dumb award

Awards are dumb. MVP and Rookie of the Year are particularly dumb. At least the dumb Cy Young Award compares people who do the same job. But in weighing J.A. Happ versus Chris Coghlan versus Tommy Hanson versus Garrett Jones versus Andrew McCutchen, how do you compare a talented outfielder to a talented pitcher, anyway? That is just one of many reasons why I do not, and will never, vote for athletic awards. The news today is that Coghlan beat Happ (and the others) for N.L. ROY. I don’t care, and I don’t recommend that you get bothered over it (caveat--the players care, and there is nothing wrong with that; it always feels good to be recognized, whether or not the award is dumb. Philly.com could give me the Pointless Post of the Day Award, and I'd probably feel all good about myself for a few hours).

Coghlan wins dumb award

Awards are dumb.  MVP and Rookie of the Year are particularly dumb.  At least the dumb Cy Young Award compares people who do the same job.  But in weighing J.A. Happ versus Chris Coghlan versus Tommy Hanson versus Garrett Jones versus Andrew McCutchen, how do you compare a talented outfielder to a talented pitcher, anyway? That is just one of many reasons why I do not, and will never, vote for athletic awards.

The news today is that Coghlan beat Happ (and the others) for N.L. ROY.  I don’t care, and I don’t recommend that you get bothered over it (caveat--the players care, and there is nothing wrong with that; it always feels good to be recognized, whether or not the award is dumb.  Philly.com could give me the Pointless Post of the Day Award, and I'd probably feel all good about myself for a few hours).

But here’s the only important thing for baseball fans: All of these players will likely be fun and interesting to watch for several years.  They are all talented, in different ways.  They are all fun to watch, and they all deserve praise for strong performances in 2009. Why this annual need to categorize people with fuzzily-defined awards?

***
The Phillies did some maneuvering of their 40-man roster today, removing utilityman Eric Bruntlett, RHP Tyler Walker, C Paul Hoover, INF Andy Tracy and RHP John Ennis. All are free agents.

If Bruntlett’s time in Philly is over—and he has seemed headed out of town for a while now--the Phillies Zone wishes him luck. A good guy, and scary smart (he holds a degree in economics from Stanford University, and scored a 1440 on his SATs), Bruntlett kept his on-field struggles in perspective this year, and always handled them with class. 

Now, the Phils continue their search for a upgrade at the utility position—something that is increasingly essential, as Chase Utley and Jimmy Rollins settle into baseball middle age and require more rest. 












 

More coverage
 
High Cheese: Adieu to Bruntlett; Happ 2nd
 
Honoring Harry the K
 
Stats: J.A. Happ
Should Happ have won the award?
Yes
No
About this blog

The place for up-to-the-minute Phillies coverage from The Inquirer beat writer Matt Gelb and columnist Bob Brookover.

Matt Gelb Inquirer Staff Writer
Bob Brookover Inquirer Columnist
Marc Narducci Inquirer Staff Writer
Latest Videos:
Also on Philly.com:
Stay Connected