Morning Edition: Leave the kid alone
News blogs, sports blogs, entertainment blogs, and more from Philly.com, The Philadelphia Inquirer and the Philadelphia Daily News.
Morning Edition: Leave the kid alone
David Murphy, Daily News Staff Writer
There was an interesting scene in the clubhouse this morning. On the television, the crew at MLB Network was dissecting Domonic Brown's swing, pointing out flaws they feel have contributed to his slow start this spring. Harold Reynolds isn't exactly the most reserved analyst in the world, so much of the clubhouse was watching the critique. Brown was not in the room at the time. Not long after the segment ended, the rookie strolled in and headed to his locker.
"Good timing," one observer said.
After all, imagine if you were an accountant and you were sitting in a room with a bunch of your peers watching so-called experts pick apart your latest spreadsheet on cable television?
This is what it is like to be one of the most hyped prospects in recent Phillies history. All eyes are on you: not only those of the fans and the media, but those of your own coaching staff and your own front office and, to some degree, your own teammates. Baseball is a fascinating sport because it is one of the few in which all eyes in the stadium are trained on one individual: the batter in the box as he swings, the pitcher on the mound as he delivers. At any given time, there are at least nine other individuals on the field. But at the precise moment when an athlete performs his assigned task, he is all alone.
It's why a guy like Harvey Dorfman, who we write about in today's Daily News, was such a valuable resource for so many baseball players. In a remembrance that Peter Gammons wrote about Dorfman, he relays a quote from the late psychologist that captures the situation with an impressive degree of insight.
"They're just like you and me, only more gifted," Dorfman told Gammons once. "They bleed like you and I, only they do it in public."
Which is why being a reporter can sometimes be a difficult position. You are offered a front-row seat to the triumph, but also to the bleeding, and rather than submit to the natural human inclination to help alleviate the pain, your job is to describe it in graphic detail.
Brown's current situation is not nearly as melo-dramatic as the aforementioned paragraph. Yet it provides a good example of the dichotomy you sometimes feel as a reporter. Part of you realizes that people want to read about why Brown is 0-for-12 with eight strikeouts in his first four Grapefruit League games, but another part wants to just leave him the hell alone.
After all, Brown isn't the only player who is off to a slow start this spring. In fact, he has reached base one more time than either Ryan Howard or Raul Ibanez. If Brown goes 4-for-4 in his next game, he'll be hitting .250. Without a doubt, he is struggling to get comfortable right now. Without a doubt, there are some legitimate questions concerning his readiness to take over the vacancy in right field on an everyday basis. But those questions existed long before he went 0-for-12 with eight strikeouts in the first week of the Grapefruit League season, and they will exist even if he goes 8-for-8 with two home runs over the next two days. To a certain extent, they will exist until he has accumulated a couple of years of major league service. Really, the only thing to do is sit back and watch and occasionally check in and not treat every Grapefruit League game as if a career hangs in balance.
Of course, life under a microscope is part of the package when it comes to playing in Philadelphia. And Phillies fans will be happy to know that Brown seems to be handling that part just fine. By all accounts, including first-hand observation, this is a good kid with a good attitude and a quiet confidence and an easy-going nature, and all of that allows him to greet the never-ending line of media members with a relaxed smile instead of a frustrated scowl. It's all part of it, he tells himself, which is the same thing you tell yourself when you think about the fact that the best thing you could do for the kid is just leave him alone.
Paul Hagen writes about the Kid here.
^
Also in today's paper (which is something I'll try to do from here on out, since I've received several emails requesting me to do so):
-Chase Utley's uncertain health could prompt the Phillies to err on the side of an extra infielder when it comes time to fill out their bench. Among the contenders: Pete Orr, Delwyn Young and Josh Barfield, among others.
-Roy Halladay's relationship with Harvey Dorfman began with a chance encounter in a bookstore 11 years ago. It continues today, even after the death of his mentor.
-The Phillies appear to be making progress toward a new deal with Charlie Manuel.
^
Speaking of Brown, he gets a day off today against the Orioles. Roy Oswalt is scheduled to start, followed by Vance Worley. John Mayberry Jr. is in right field. Brian Schneider is catching. The rest of the regulars, aside from Utley, are in the line-up.
Download our NEW iPhone/Android app for easy access to all of our Phillies coverage, plus app-exclusive videos and analysis. Get it here.
Good one Phightin. This is becoming a joke, both on the media and the Phillies.— EL Zorro- Pressure on the kid has to be a factor, but can't understand how he did so poorly in the winter league when he left early due to being non-productive. Don't bring him up too soon and fill his head with grandiose ideas. He'll be fine; kids still young.— dogman5
- You are all a bunch of clowns. Its the first 10 days of Spring Training. I would rather these guys slump now so in April, when it COUNTS, they'll be getting hot. You don't deserve to have this team you front-running, bandwagon, fair-weathered fools.— seaonasdad
Dom was a disapointment at the end of last season.
Dom was a disapointment at Winter ball.
Dom has been a disapointment so far during spring training.
If Dom doesen't learn to hit the curve ball for the Phillies he will be the TOAST of the town.
— Phiggles- It's also what happens when your team wins the division in four consecutive seasons and a World Series in 2008...people pay attention microscopically at that point. I'm sure Orioles and Royals fans couldn't possibly care less if anyone is currently o-fer Spring. Give them time to work it out, it's what Spring is for— chrisc4499
- Why are so many people so down on Utley, Howard and Rollins? They are the heart of the team and the best at their respective postition to ever wear a Phillies uniform. Have they had injuriies? Yes, of course they have. The baseball season is a long nightly marathon. Playiong in the infield is hazardous. Standing in the batters box is hazardous. These guys are all tough hardnosed players who the rest of baseball fears. Yet our opathetic front running loser fans are always all over their backs for some idiotic nonsense. It's is getting way beyond old to see the whioners post all the time. Please support your team or take your lack of support north to Shea where you will find a team that is more worthy of fans like you.— Paul SoTX
- well said Murph— jayflyte
- Sorry everyone. Maybe the point is that he's just not that good.— knebman
- Good article I totally agree. Leave the kid alone! He will be fine.— Jangocat
- Difference is that Raul and Howard have proven it on the big stage, so a slow start in Spring Training means nothing. Question for Brown is if he is struggling so much now, how can he possibly handle it when the games mean something. I say let him start the season in the minors. If he does well and if Francisco struggles, then bring him up later. No need to rush things, especially seeing how well Ben is swinging the bat.— Chicago_Phils_Fan
- Give us a break....He knew that this spring he would get his chance....If he cannot handle the pressure then he does not deserve the job....This is the "bigs" Either he can make it or not......and let's move on.....— nuggett
- While certainly there is a hypocritical aspect to this article, I think the author acknowledges that. To me, this is actually a surprisingly well written article for a Philly reporter. Nicely done.— JustAnOpinion
- He didn't look ready for what the Yankees were throwing last week, and some of those pitchers were minor leaguers. Get him in AAA ball this year and see how he responds.— escapedcamden4monterey
- Worried about Brown?
I'm worried about the lack of offense generally, especially if Utley can't play 100%. Losing Werth is huge, not only for his bat but his glove. He's way better than Brown or Francisco defensively.
Unfortunately this isn't 2007 and we can't rely on JRoll anymore so a big load is going to rest on Howard, with support from Mr. Clutch - Chooch. I don't know if thats going to be enough to hold off Atlanta. NO HELP FROM THE FARM SYSTEM.— Cameiros - It's a LOOOOOONG season. Relax everybody. Send the kid down to AAA and let him get his groove. With this starting pitching, we have time.— Vote for Dickie
