Tuesday, May 21, 2013
Tuesday, May 21, 2013

One domino down

The Giants deal for Carlos Beltran puts pressure on the Phillies and will change the complexion of the rest of the 2011 season. And postseason.

59 comments

One domino down

POSTED: Wednesday, July 27, 2011, 4:13 PM
Filed Under: Phillies
Blog Image
Carlos Beltran is moving straight up to the defending champs, not the NL runners-up.

Should the Phillies trade Domonic Brown for a veteran righthanded hitter?
Yes.
No.

If it goes through, this Carlos Beltran-to-the-Giants trade is going to change the complexion of the rest of the 2011 season and postseason.

Last week, you may recall, I wrote a column saying the Phillies should part with some of their future in order to obtain Beltran. That’s just what the defending champion Giants reportedly did, trading away 21-year-old pitching prospect Zack Wheeler. Wheeler is five days younger than the Phillies’ prized Jarred Cosart, as well as more highly rated by Baseball America. (Beltran has a no-trade clause but is expected to approve the deal.)

The trade raises the temperature on Phillies general manager Ruben Amaro Jr. to do something before Sunday’s deadline. It also blasts holes in two of the rationales that were floating around for the last week.

Many media types and readers argued the Phillies shouldn’t help the Mets for the long term by taking on free-agent-to-be Beltran as a three-month rental. Well, now the Mets have Wheeler, who has every bit as much chance as developing into a legitimate ace as Cosart. And the Giants – the team that eliminated the offensively challenged Phillies in the NLCS last October – would be a much more balanced team.

Last year, the Giants chose not to make a major move, adding only the released Cody Ross and a couple of middle relievers around the trade deadline. That has been used to support the idea the Phillies don’t really need to do much. Well, that logic looks a little wobbly now that those very same Giants, looking to repeat as World Series champs, have won the Beltran sweepstakes.

Everyone agrees the Phillies are good enough to reach the postseason for the fifth straight year. The issue is whether they’ve learned from two consecutive years of being eliminated because their always streaky lineup goes ice-cold against bigtime pitching. Standing pat now won’t cost the Phillies the NL East title. But it may haunt them in a series against the Giants or Braves or Red Sox or Yankees.

There’s no shame in losing the NLCS or the World Series. But it would be a shame not to address an easily predicted problem now, when there are some options.

If it’s Game 6 of the NLCS and Domonic Brown drives in the winning run while Beltran struggles against the Phillies’ pitching staff, then standing pat will look brilliant. But if Beltran is part of a mob of Giants celebrating on the field at the Bank this October, this is the week that made that possible.

Whatever happens, it makes for a fascinating storyline.

Of course, Amaro can still add to the cast of characters this week.

59 comments
Comments  (59)
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 8:19 PM, 07/27/2011
    Hunter Pence
    Bretzky
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 8:25 PM, 07/27/2011
    beltran was the best fit for us, going to the giants is the worst scenario for us. not good
    TooManyAdsOnThisSite
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 8:33 PM, 07/27/2011
    Knock knock .... Where is Ruben?
    shawnmac
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 8:36 PM, 07/27/2011
    Cosmo...Quentin hitting HRs is not an anomoly...he's got over 100 HR's in the past 3 1/2 seasons...and two of those were cut short by injury. Now, with that said, his playing the whole season so far might be the anomoly. Also, for those that think having the best record in the majors means anything than maybe you didnt watch last years playoffs...they had the best record and their bats went ice cold against good pitching. I mean even the cincy series, the no hitter and great pitching on our end hid what was relatively some weak hitting. They have about a three year window to get us all on Broad street, beers in hand!
    relly142
  • Comment removed.
  • Comment removed.
  • Comment removed.
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 10:36 PM, 07/27/2011
    Doesn't matter how many "Aces' you have, need the consistant (being the operative word) bats to back them up....
    M60tanker
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 12:56 AM, 07/28/2011
    we arent at the trade deadline just yet...Beltran was certainly a domino that had to fall...I'd like to see the Phillies grab Pence, if not, I am sure someone is gonna call Ruben on the phone with someone to offer
    danielboyer
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 2:45 AM, 07/28/2011
    If Brown drives in the winning run?
    Even if he does, what about the balls he butchers in the outfield? Why isn't anyone writing about the importance of defense in a short series, and just how awful Brown is out there?
    VicM
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 6:22 AM, 07/28/2011
    While I did not want Beltran (A rental) for several current players or prospects, I understand they were willing to trade us Beltran for Singleton, Cusart or Brown and the Phillies said no. THAT WAS STUPID. Where in heaven's name is Singleton a first baseman going to play when Howard is here until the sun extinguishes itself? And Brown? Let me ask: do you trust this man in the outfield, especially in a post season game? Did you see how he approached that ball hit to him yesterday? And he is starting to develop that long swing at outside breaking balls ala Howard. HE IS PATHETIC. TRADE BROWN FOR PENCE NOW.
    stop2think
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 8:39 AM, 07/28/2011
    Uh oh...I have this feeling that the Phillies and Giants will once again meet in the NLCS, and that the outcome will be the same as last year with one exception....this year, playing the role of Cody Ross will be none other than....you guessed it.....Carlos Beltran!

    mitchb
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 9:31 AM, 07/28/2011
    Absolutely under no circumstances should the Phils trade Worley for anyone. Pitching is always king and Worley is the real deal. Look at what just happened to Blanton - nerve damage. Thinkin we need Worley back.
    pennfan
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 3:57 PM, 07/28/2011
    The bats get one more chance tonight to prove themselves with Lincecum on the mound. Unfortunately, one bat isn't going to turn the tide here. The big contract players Howard and Utley need to step up when it counts.
    JRum


View comments: 1  |  2  |  3  |  4
About this blog
Phil Sheridan has been covering pro and college sports in his hometown since 1985. He has been a columnist at the Inquirer since 2003, after a seven-year run as the paper's Eagles beat writer. Sheridan has covered eight Olympics, numerous Super Bowls and World Series, and has seen Guided By Voices and Wilco too many times to count. He lives, cooks and pursues the ultimate margarita blend in Langhorne. Reach Phil at psheridan@phillynews.com.

Phil Sheridan
Phil Sheridan Inquirer Columnist
Philly.com Sports Videos