Posted: Wednesday, March 9, 2011, 1:06 PM | 8 comments |
 
options
 

CLEARWATER, Fla. -- Chase Utley should have surgery as soon as possible – yesterday would be better – and rush back to action for the Phillies.

Easy for me to say. Easy for anyone except Utley to say.

Look, it’s part of the dynamic in Philliesworld these days to fret over every issue and to want immediate solutions to every problem. The baseball team’s recent run of success has raised the temperature up to where the Eagles have operated for years. Maybe even higher.

But Utley is doing the right thing. By definition. Because whatever Utley decides to do for his knee, his body and his career is the right thing. We can debate roster decisions and when to change pitchers or whether they should have bunted in the ninth inning and a million other aspects of baseball. But medical decisions truly are personal and immune from our judgment.

That doesn’t mean Utley is making this decision in a vacuum. He will make about $45 million over the next three years whether he plays well, plays poorly or plays not at all. That kind of coin comes with some obligation to the team that pays it, the fans that make it possible and the teammates who will be affected by your choices. Utley is keenly aware of all those factors. That much is clear after watching him handle his business throughout his career.

I found myself thinking of Ellis Hobbs this morning. Remember how the Eagles cornerback stayed in that game against Tennessee last season? Even though he was getting killed out there? Hobbs followed the code where you make no excuses and play hurt for your teammates. In this case, his noble intentions pretty much cost the Eagles the game.

Utley said something Wednesday about not being able to change the past, only how he handles things in the future. That sounds like someone who realizes that following the code and playing hurt in the past is what led him to this moment of reckoning with his own knee. So he’s being very careful now to do what will prolong his career.

Having taken up a half-hour of Dr. Art Bartolozzi’s valuable time talking about patellar tendinitis the other day (key part's about halfway down page), I have to think surgery will wind up being Utley’s best option here. But if he wants to take a couple of weeks – in March, mind you – to exhaust the alternatives, then that’s his right. If it means he misses a couple of weeks in April, but plays another five years beyond that, well, that’s a small price to pay for his confidence in the decision he has to make here.

Utley makes a lot of money for playing baseball. That’s a privilege. But we’ve also been privileged to watch him play. Sounds like everyone has the same end result in mind here.

Posted by Phil Sheridan @ 1:06 PM  Permalink | File Under: Phillies | 8 comments
8
Comments   
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 1:43 PM, 03/09/2011
    Ask Billy Chair to call Snuffy Stirnweiss and Gerry Priddy
    NewMick314
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 1:46 PM, 03/09/2011
    I am not able to see what Bartolozzi explained as it's not on this page. But surgery is the best option. The back of the patella is roughened up and is constantly rubbing against the knee artilage. No rest or cortisone infections are taking that buildup away. He needs it smoothed down, and if there some lateral patellar tendon release needed that has to be done as well. The real issue here is why it took nearly 6 months to get to this solution. He was having problems then, and if he had the surgery then, he would be back in the lineup soon, if not now. If he was at this point then, or close, he had an obligation to get help for it.
    Bob1
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 2:32 PM, 03/09/2011
    YES, get it done, heal, rehab and be ready for the second half of the season.....it should have been done after last season ......it is not a question of if it should be done...IT SHOULD BE DONE..
    nuggett
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 3:29 PM, 03/09/2011
    2nd half of season? out for year with surgery genius
    fman727
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 3:56 PM, 03/09/2011
    Utley has ruined this team because of his pride. If he had surgery right after their season was finished last year we wouldn't even be talking about this. What a selfish dude.
    TheGuyInCharge69
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 5:15 PM, 03/09/2011
    Unless one is an experienced orthopedic specialist who has examined Utley answering this question is a waste of time and way above the pay grade of writers. Fans who are MD's might want to play the game but will not if they are smart. Providing excellent info is great.
    johnny eagle
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 12:52 AM, 03/10/2011
    Utley is ANYTHING but selfish, GuyinCharge. If you don't realize that, then you haven't been paying attention since 2003.
    But it is true that baseball players always seem to wait until spring training to deal with injuries. Frustrating.
    VicM
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 7:54 AM, 03/10/2011
    Guy in Charge, you're either too dumb, too young, or definitely not a Phillies fan to make a remark like Utley being too selfish. He was hit many times taking "one for the team''. His actions gave the $125 million dollar man a chance to pad his stats. With Utley out, he won't get as many chances to do that this year. I wouldn't accuse him of being selfish.
    phineas


8 comments
About Phil Sheridan
Phil Sheridan
Phil Sheridan has been covering pro and college sports in his hometown since 1985. He has been a columnist at the Inquirer since 2003, after a seven-year run as the paper's Eagles beat writer. Sheridan has covered eight Olympics, numerous Super Bowls and World Series, and has seen Guided By Voices and Wilco too many times to count. He lives, cooks and pursues the ultimate margarita blend in Langhorne.
Follow on Twitter