Thursday, April 24, 2014
Inquirer Daily News

Delaware River Keeper sues Phila. Gun Club over pigeon shoots

For three decades animal welfare activists have waged an Quixotic struggle to stop live pigeon shoots in Pennsylvania. They have battled gun clubs with powerful local constituents, the gun lobby which controls Harrisburg and district attorneys who regularly block attempts by humane offficers to file cruelty charges.

Delaware River Keeper sues Phila. Gun Club over pigeon shoots

    (A rare pigeon shoot survivor rescued from Delaware River)

 

For three decades animal welfare activists have waged a Quixotic struggle to stop live pigeon shoots in Pennsylvania.

They have battled gun clubs with powerful local constituents, they have fought the gun lobby which controls Harrisburg and waged war with district attorneys who regularly block attempts by humane officers to file cruelty charges for the inhumane treatment of wounded birds.

Several years ago the animal rights group SHARK won the support and financial backing of game show legend Bob Barker. His million-dollar donation has financed lawyers and high tech equipment to document the brutality of pigeon shoots (see video at SHARK site www.pashame.com) but they have not been able to halt the shoots through legislative or court action.

In fact, more shoots are cropping up at gun clubs beyond Bucks, Dauphin and Berks counties.

But recently the anti-pigeon shoot forces landed a new powerful ally in the Delaware River Keeper Network - environmental protector of the waterway that courses the length of eastern Pennsylvania. 

The group filed a lawsuit against the Philadelphia Gun Club in Bensalem, Bucks County, alleging that the activity - with its near-weekly hailstorm of lead shot and slain birds over the Delaware - is polluting the river.

My colleague, Bob Moran, reported on the suit for the Inquirer:

Their complaint alleges that the pigeon shoots, which occur many times a year, pollute the Delaware with lead shot and fragments, as well as dead and injured birds.

The shoots attract animal-rights' protesters, including one who positioned a boat near the club during a shoot and recorded video of what appears to be shot and fragments falling into the water around him.

The gun club did not respond to a request for comment.

According to the suit, the club is about 132 years old and hosts at least a dozen trap-shoot meets a year. Instead of using clay targets, the club uses pigeons.

The pigeons are stuffed into steel traps and then launched into the air to be shot at, the suit says. Hundreds of dead and injured birds land on club property, the shoreline, or in the river.

In 2010, the club submitted applications to the U.S. Coast Guard to request a "safety exclusion area offshore" for safety reasons, according to the suit.

At some point, the club withdrew its applications, but has continued to host the pigeon shoots, the complaint alleges.

A Coast Guard spokesman could not be reached for comment.

Van Rossum, whose title is Delaware Riverkeeper, said the suit was necessary because "none of these regulatory agencies or the police are stepping up to do something about this."

Her group sent a notice to the club in October 2010 threatening a lawsuit if the shoots didn't end. The notice satisfied a 60-day-notice requirement for filing a suit based on the Clean Water Act, Van Rossum said.

"Shooting over the river is also a safety hazard and a disturbance for those who are trying to enjoy this reach of the river for wild birding, boating, fishing, or otherwise," she said.

The complaint asks the court to halt the pigeon shoots until the club complies with federal environmental laws. It also asks for the club to remediate any damage to the environment and be subject to civil penalties.

The suit also seeks reimbursement of the plaintiffs' legal costs.

Amy Worden Inquirer Staff Writer
About this blog
Amy Worden is a politics and government reporter for the Inquirer. In that capacity she has explored a range of animal issues from dog kennel law improvements and horse slaughter to the comeback of peregrine falcons and pigeon hunts. From hamsters to horses, animals have always been part of her life. To pass along a tip or contact Amy, click here. Reach Amy at aworden@phillynews.com.

Amy Worden Inquirer Staff Writer
Latest Videos:
Also on Philly.com
Stay Connected
Topics: