Sunday, November 23, 2014
Inquirer Daily News

Fantasy Baseball: Ranking the shortstops

My preseason fantasy rankings continue today with shortstop.

Fantasy Baseball: Ranking the shortstops

Where does Jimmy Rollins rank among the best infielders in the game? (AP Photo/Chris Pizzello)
Where does Jimmy Rollins rank among the best infielders in the game? (AP Photo/Chris Pizzello)

My preseason fantasy rankings continue today with shortstop.

I've already ranked several positions, and here is a look at who has taken home top honors so far, as well as links to my full posst:

Starting Pitcher: Roy Halladay

Relief Pitcher: Heath Bell

More coverage
Is Utley NL's best second baseman?
VOTE: What was the biggest Phillies mistake?
Follow the Phillies: Download our FREE Pro Baseball app!
Buy Phillies jerseys and other gear
WATCH: Daily fantasy baseball updates

Outfield: Carl Crawford

Second Base: Robinson Cano

Overall: Albert Pujols




There is about to be a changing of the guard at shortstop. Perhaps it has already begun.

Looking at the names on my list of top 10 fantasy shortstops, only two are over the age of 30, and several haven't reached their potential yet.

For some of them, this could be the year they break out.

Ian Desmond, for example, has been waiting for a chance to emerge as a top shortstop. He is prime to do that in 2011. Aside from playing in the same division as the Phillies, Desmond looks ready to realize his potential.

He hit 10 home runs last year, but raked 27 doubles. This year, with a full season of big-league plate appearances under his belt, Desmond will undoubtedly see pitches better, and likely hit for a higher average. Leading off for the Nationals, with Jayson Werth, Ryan Zimmerman, and Adam LaRoche hitting behind him, a better OBP will lead to many, many more runs.

Couple that with the fact that the back end of the Nats' lineup (Rick Ankiel, Danny Espinosa, and Ivan Rodriguez) has some pop of its own, Desmond could find himself in more RBI situations than a lead-off hitter usually does.

Desmond has a ton of potential this season, and that is why he finds himself in fourth place in my list. The 25-year old shortstop could surprise some people this season.

The two elder statesmen on my list, Derek Jeter and Jimmy Rollins, have been mainstays on this list for most of the past decade.

Both, however, will need to have bounce-back seasons if they want to continue to stay on this list.

Rollins probably has more fantasy value if Charlie Manuel decides to hit him fifth, but judging from past experiences, I wouldn't bet on that to be the case.

Rollins has been able to produce some unheard of numbers as far as RBI and home runs from the lead-off spot are concerned, but this isn't the same Jimmy Rollins that won the NL MVP in 2007. After getting off to an incredibly hot start last year, he missed a lot of time with several different injuries.

If he can stay healthy this season, he will be a solid player for your team, but don't look for him to carry you to the championship like I'm sure he did for many people in his MVP campaign.

As far as Jeter is concerned, he should put up solid numbers, but again, don't look for him to carry your team. Both these guys are on the decline, or so it would appear, but both also have the ability to put up big numbers.

"Derek Jeter is ranked third! How can he not carry my team?!"

Good question. Simple answer:

Almost no single player can carry your team, and shortstop is just that thin.

Hanley Ramirez and Troy Tulowitzki hold the top two spots on my list, and they are really in a category of their own.

Ramirez had a down season last year, and still hit .300 with 21 home runs and 32 stolen bases. If Ramirez can lift those numbers to what owners and analysts are expecting, he should be in the MVP conversation come September.

Tulowitzki has the good fortune of playing in Coors Field, which certainly helps his power numbers. There is no reason to think that he won't have another big season.

It is really a toss-up between these two. I could have been comfortable with either taking the top spot, but Ramirez gets the nod.

Here is a look at the rest of my top 10:

2010 Statistics AB R HR RBI BB K SB AVG OPS
1. Hanley Ramirez (FLA) 543
2. Troy Tulowitzki (COL) 470 89
3. Derek Jeter (NYY) 663
4. Ian Desmond (WAS) 525 59
5. Jose Reyes (NYM) 563 83
 30 .282
6. Elvis Andrus (TEX) 588
32 .265
7. Jimmy Rollins (PHI) 350 48
8. Stephen Drew (ARI) 565
9. Alexei Ramirez (CWS) 585 83 18
13 .282 .744
10. Starlin Castro (CHC) 463
53 3 41 29 71 10 .300 .755

Don't forget to sign up to play in our FanDuel $25,000 Grand Slam event on April 1. Yes, that's Friday.

We will be adding an extra incentive. Anyone who registers their account through will be eligible for our Beat the Expert prize. That means anyone who registers through the link above and beats my score ('PhillySports') will receive their $10 entry fee back, on top of any other prizes won. Just MAKE SURE that you register through THIS LINK to be eligible to beat the expert.


Matt Mullin is a sports producer at You can e-mail him at and follow him on Twitter @matt_mullin.

About this blog
Pattison Ave. offers an eclectic mix of news and nuggets about Philadelphia sports and beyond. Live chats, analysis, random thoughts, viral videos, odds and ends -- you'll find it all here.

Jonathan Tannenwald Sports Producer
Brian McCardle Sports Producer
Justin Klugh Sports Producer
Jerry Gaul Sports Producer
Vaughn Johnson Sports Producer
Michael Kaskey-Blomain Assistant Sports Producer
Latest Videos:
Also on
Stay Connected