Is leaf collection a service for the wealthy? | Philly

Monday, Nov 23, 7:07 PM

Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH

options

Friday, November 6, 2009

Is leaf collection a service for the wealthy?

As we noted this morning, Council is pushing back against ... well, against itself, on its decision to cut mechanical leaf collection and save $400,000.

Isaiah Thompson at City Paper observes that before it was cut, this was a service that was enjoyed by just 10 percent of the city. Which 10 percent, you ask? Isaiah got a map from the streets department. It looks like the neighborhoods that received mechanical leaf collection included Chestnut Hill, West Mt. Airy and the gentrified triangle of West Philly, as well as Somerton and Bustleton in the northeast and a tiny pocket of South Philly.

Says Isaiah:

Asked why these areas - and not others - received service, Streets spokeswoman June Cantor pointed out that they have more leaves. And we don't doubt she's right: but they're also wealthier – a lot wealthier, in some cases – than the rest of the city.

Having more leaves is a pretty good reason to get priority treatment in leaf collection. But the question, given this limited scope, becomes whether this is a service worth preserving. Jeff Shields quotes Councilman Rizzo saying uncollected leaves are "a hazard, choking sewers and causing flooding, or forming dry piles that a hot car muffler can ignite ... We're either going to have to pay now or pay later."

Shields also reports that, yesterday in Council, Bill Green proposed the legislative body find the $400,000 to cut elsewhere, to offset the cost of restoring the service (Council passed a resolution urging Nutter to restore the service). He received no substantive response.

Review city services on our sister site, City Howl.

Posted by Doron Taussig @ 8:33 AM Permalink | 2 comments

Comments

Posted 09:33 AM, 11/06/2009

fafafooey

The cost of the "wealthy" needing leaf collection services from the city has to be BY FAR offset by the confiscatory amount of taxes that they pay, plus the cost of social(ist) services the city provides to the "non-wealthy" that they DON'T use. The socialists in City Council and the Democrat party just look at the "wealthy" as ATM machines for their programs that keep people dependent on government and keep them in office.

Posted 09:39 AM, 11/06/2009

BarryG

I don't buy this "for the wealthy" argument. Those areas in the Northeast are not wealthy--they just have a lot of trees. I don't know if $400k is worth it or not but this is not a class issue. Rich people live where there are trees. I am a bit confused about Packer Park being on that map, but I don't question those folks...

2 comments

About It's Our Money

Every year, city government spends slightly more than $4 billion. Where does all that money come from? More importantly, where does it go? Are we getting the most bang for our tax buck? “It's Our Money” is a joint project between Philadelphia Daily News and WHYY, funded by the William Penn Foundation, designed to answer these questions.

EXCLUSIVE: UNION PRESIDENT SPEAKS OUT

It's Our Money's Ben Waxman interviews TWU Local 234 president Willie Brown on why he called the strike when he did, what it's like to be more hated than A-Rod, and what it will take the union to go back on the job. Click here to see the exclusive interview.

FOLLOW THE (LACK OF) MONEY

Philadelphia’s five-year plan includes $300 million in service cuts. Which departments are seeing their budgets slashed, and what are the consequences? Our Follow the (lack of) Money series takes stock of the effects of the budget crisis. This week: Housing Trust Fund.

State and local budget news:

National budget news:

Ben Waxman reports and blogs for “It's Our Money.” Before joining “It's Our Money,” he was a regular contributor to the Philadelphia Daily News op-ed page and former contributor to the blog Young Philly Politics. He studied political science at Juniata College in Huntingdon, PA.

Doron Taussig is the Project Manager for “It's Our Money.” He is also a graduate student in communications at Temple University. Previously he worked as a Staff Writer and News Editor for the Philadelphia City Paper.

Dave Merrell is the Web Editor for "It's Our Money." He comes to the project from Philly.com, where he is a web producer. Originally from upstate New York, he moved to Philadelphia after graduating from Haverford College with a degree in math and economics.

Anthony Campisi reports and blogs for "It's Our Money." Originally hailing from Central Jersey, he came to Philadelphia while a student at the University of Pennsylvania, where he studied intellectual history. He also writes about transportation for PlanPhilly, an innovative urban planning website started by PennPraxis, the consulting arm of the Penn School of Design.