share
email
font size
options
 
Saturday, October 24, 2009

Jimmy Clausen proved last week that he has the nads to play with the big boys, bringing the Irish to the brink of a tie with USC on the last play of the game.

He would have cemented the lead for the Heisman if that ill-conceived last play had somehow connected for a touchdown. Maybe the right play was called and he threw to the wrong guy, because Kyle Rudolph, split wide left, was open in the back of the end zone.

The same play worked to beat Purdue, but on that day, Rudolph was the slot receiver who caught the TD. This time, it was Duval Kumara, but he slipped on the route and the rest is history.

ESPN's Skip Bayless, who definitely underestimated the Irish as did everyone else, was right about one thing. It would have been different if ND had Michael Floyd. USC could not gave doubled Golden Tate.

So chalk it up as getting one step closer to the elite and one step closer to the Heisman. Notre Dame played the first half the same way it did the past two years aaginst USC, conservative and scared. But something happened on defense that changed the complexion of the game in the second quarter. Freshman linebacker Manti Te'o blasted Matt Barkley (cleanly I might add) as the quarterback scrambled to the sidelines after a broken down passing attempt.

The ND freshman sent a wakeup call to USC -- and his own Irish teammates -- this is how the big boys play. This is how you join the elite. You run just as fast and you hit just as hard. (Except in this case, it was a clean hit, thank you very much Trojans for keeping numerous drives alive with late hits and dirty shots, including the last one against Robby Parris. You are the second best team in the country after Alabama, but this is why people don't like you. That and your offensive lienmen have AARP cards.)

Now, schemewise, the Irish are still light years away. USC rushed only four and ran Clausen ragged back in the always disappearing pocket. Clausen, who perfected a new move, the pirouetting right turn and run for your life to gain time as you find a receiver downfield 12-step, started to make the throws that separate him from the rest of the Heisman hopefuls (curiously, Clausen has mysteriously moved up to No. 2 on Todd McShay's pro QB potenntial list while the ESPN Heisman indicator, or whatever that meaningless drivel of a mathematical equation is, still has Tim Tebow at 1, Colt McCoy at 3 and Cincinnati's Tony Pike at 4.

This is why this bogus predictor has to go. Last week was a Heisman primary. Colt McCoy vs. Oklahoma, Clausen (and don't forget Matt Barkley, mind you) vs. USC.

McCoy failed miserably and should disappear immediately from any consideration. He also demolished his pro stock portfolio. Oklahoma took away Jordan Shipley and McCoy was forced to run the Texas version of the wildcat for any meaningful yardage. He also had a critical fumble near the goal line. Texas beat Oklahoma after Sam Bradford went down, but just barely and not because of McCoy.

McCoy was only the second best McCoy on the field that day. Oklahoma's defensive tackle Gerald McCoy was in the Texas backfield as much as Colt. If you include the ND-USC game, Colt McCoy was only the third-best McCoy last week. The real Big McCoy was USC tight end Anthony McCoy, who made some amazing catches, averages over 20 yards a catch, and should be a first-round draft pick and may be the most underrated player in the country.

So while the ESPN fraud indicator has Colt McCoy third on its list, I have him third on my Big McCoy list.

2009 Big McCoy Award

1. Anthony McCoy, USC.

2. Gerald McCoy, Oklahoma.

3. Colt McCoy, Texas.

Now, back to the Heisman.

1. Jimmy Clausen, Notre Dame, QB.

2. Mark Herzlich, Boston College LB

3. Mark Ingram, Alabama, RB

Yes, you read that right. Mark Herzlich of Boston College, the ACC's defensive player of the year as a junior last year, was diagnosed with a rare form of bone cancer, Ewing's sarcoma in his left leg, and has made remarkable strides and says he is 99 percent recovered. (He is still undergoing chemotherapy.) He has appeared on national TV, especially ESPN's Game Day a few weeks ago and has been an inspiration to all. He has, perhaps. the highest profile in college football once you forget about Tim Tebow's concussion (rest him, please, Urban) and Sam Bradford's shoulder (gone for the year, hope he has a policy with Lloyds of London because his pro stock -- location of the injury, his throwing shoulder -- has knocked him out of the No.1 overall pick and is now a crap shoot for the NFL).

Herzlich, a Conestoga High graduate. would have been an elite player and definite all American this season. His courage and strength exemplify all that is great about college football (the Heisman Trophy being emblematic of that) and he has united the entire country with numerous football programs participating in charity work and emotional support, including Charlie Weis, who should be commended for his actions in keeping Herzlich's spirits high. The coach lit a candle at the Grotto at Nore Dame in Herzlich's honor when he heard about the BC linebacker's situation and has kept in touch with him ever since.

I believe Jimmy Clausen deserves the Heisman and will prove it by season's end.

But should he falter, heck, even if he doesn't, start thinking about voting for Mark Herzlich for the Heisman. It even sounds right.

Posted by John Quinn @ 1:40 PM  Permalink | 15 comments
15
Comments   
Posted 05:09 PM, 10/24/2009
wingslax35
Clausen? You're not serious I hope? He is at best 3rd behind Ingram and Tebow.
Posted 08:01 PM, 10/24/2009
Tech_Triumph
Insanity. Notre Dame fans are delusional.
Posted 07:23 AM, 10/25/2009
flalionfan
what is the deal with a philly paper focus on Notre Dame. Pa has Penn State Temple and Pitt football, and more. Who cares about a school in Indiana with all of the talented football in Pa one of the best college football states in the USofA
Posted 11:43 AM, 10/25/2009
PhillyNittanyLion
Why is there a ND blog on a Philly.com site??? Save this for Indiana.
Posted 04:19 PM, 10/25/2009
give me liberty or death
get rid of the notre dame blog, they are no longer a national program. they have been down and out for too long.
Posted 07:48 PM, 10/25/2009
sleepy
Turtle Clausen,nice safety he can't take a hit. All Tebow does is win everywhere, adn his stats are alost as good. Daryl Clark is a much tougher player.
Posted 07:48 PM, 10/25/2009
sleepy
Turtle Clausen,nice safety he can't take a hit. All Tebow does is win everywhere, adn his stats are alost as good. Daryl Clark is a much tougher player.
Posted 08:50 AM, 10/26/2009
JohnnyThunderCak
This guy is such a loser and another reason no one buys these papers anymore. Would a heisman candidate come out of the game on the 1 yard line for the wildcat offense? I doubt it!
Posted 04:27 PM, 10/26/2009
Sports
In order: 1. Tebow is a leader but not a better quarterback than Clausen, and his quarterbacking stats aren't even close this year. 2. A Philly paper "may" focus on Notre Dame because it is a national football program which has loyal fans throughout the country, as is evidenced by the University's ability to schedule "neutral site" games once per year moving forward (including Washington State this weekend in San Antonio). Also, make sure you re-read (or in your case, READ) the BCS selection regulations and notice Notre Dame's unique place in the arrangement, due to its successful history as an independent program. 3. You can say Notre Dame is no longer a national program when it LOSES ITS NATIONAL NBC TELEVISION CONTRACT. Until that time, this is a non-argument. 4. If Daryl Clark is tougher than Clausen, who got to this point in his career by taking a beating steadily for two years, then give Clausen the edge on everything else but running ability. 5. A loser? Come on... Your question: would a Heisman candidate come out of the game on the 1-yard line? The answer: if his coach - who clearly doesn't always make great in-game decisions - told him to, yes. As long as we're in the business of insulting people personally, let's just say your argument doesn't exactly scream "law student." Take care...
Posted 05:04 AM, 10/27/2009
jrepko1
this is a great blog.. keep up the good work!
Posted 11:40 AM, 10/28/2009
pizano13
We have a Notre Dame blog? And the reason behing this is...?
Posted 11:13 AM, 11/05/2009
pj katauskas
GO NAVY!!!
Posted 06:17 PM, 11/07/2009
greenbuff
Jimmy Clausen deserves the bench after his performance tonight! Hahahahaha. Notre Dame is done. Temple>Navy, Navy>Notre Dame, so Temple> Notre Dame.
Posted 02:20 PM, 11/08/2009
borncynic
The most overhyped, overrated, overexposed team in all of sports. When I see a Navy v. Notre Dame, two of the worst teams on College football on TV I laugh. The rules are also all set up to give them every benefit of the doubt to ensure they will be in a bowl game. Did I mention they suck too.
Posted 03:11 PM, 11/18/2009
thegloryofoldstate
A defensive player for Heisman? Unless he does everything, ala Charles Woodson, '98 then there is no chance in heck, no matter how "Brian's Song" his personal life is...
About John Quinn
John Quinn, 55, is deputy sports editor at the Philadelphia Inquirer and is a third generation member of the Subway Alumni.

His grandfather used to listen to the radio and yell out to his son playing on the hardscrabble streets of Corona, Queens: “Bill Shakespeare just threw another touchdown pass!”
His father used to listen to the transistor radio and yell out to his son playing for Stony Brook on Long Island: “Joe Montana just threw another touchdown pass!”
He listens to the radio and yells out to his son watching SpongeBob on a 46-inch HDTV: “Jimmy Clausen just threw another touchdown pass!” Meanwhile, Jack, 8, will not be a fourth generation member of the Subway Alumni.